Are the objects and events that take place in Virtual Reality genuinely real? Those who answer this question in the affirmative are realists, and those who answer in the negative are irrealists. In this paper we argue against the realist position, as given by Chalmers (2017), and present our own preferred irrealist account of the virtual. We start by disambiguat- ing two potential versions of the realist position—weak and strong— and then go on to argue that neither is plausible. We then introduce a Waltonian variety of fictionalism about the virtual, arguing that this sort of irrealist approach avoids the problems of the realist positions, fits with a unifying theory of representational works, and offers a better ac- count of the phenomenology of engaging in virtual experiences.
If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.
Bennett K. 2009. Composition colocation and metaontology. In Metametaphysics: New Essays on the Foundations of Ontology ed. by David John Chalmers David Manley and Ryan Wasserman. Oxford University Press pp. 38–76.
Chalmers D. J. 2003. The matrix as metaphysics. Online at thematrix.com. Published in print in Philosophers Explore the Matrix ed. by C. Grau. Oxford University Press 2005.
Chalmers D. J. 2009. Ontological anti-realism. In In Metametaphysics: New Essays on the Foundations of Ontology ed. by David John Chalmers David Manley and Ryan Wasserman. Oxford University Press pp. 77–129.
Chalmers D. J. 2017. The virtual and the real. Disputatio 9(46): 309–52. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1515/disp-2017-0009.
Cogburn J.; and Silcox M. 2014. Against brain-in-a-vatism: On the value of virtual reality. Philosophy and Technology 27: 561–79.
Dummett M. 1978. Realism. In his Truth and Other Enigmas. London: Duckworth 145–65.
Everett A. 2013. The Nonexistent. Oxford University Press.
Friend Stacie. 2008. Imagining fact and fiction. In New Waves in Aesthetics ed. by Kathleen Stock and Katherine Thomsen-Jones. Palgrave-Macmillan. pp. 150–169.
Heim M. 2000. Virtual Realism. Oxford University Press.
Jenkins C. S. 2010. What is ontological realism? Philosophy Compass 5 (10):880–90.
Joyce R. Moral anti-realism. In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Summer 2009 Edition) ed. by E. Zalta. 2009. URL http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/sum2009/entries/moral-anti-realism/
Kim J. 1993. The non-reductivist’s troubles with mental causation. In Heil and Mele 1993 pp. 189–210. Reprinted in Kim 1993a pp. 336-57.
Lewis D. 1991. Parts of Classes. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.
Lodder A. R. 2013. Dutch Supreme Court 2012: virtual theft ruling a one-off or first in a series? Journal For Virtual Worlds Research [S.l.] 6(3): 1–12.
Merricks T. 2001. Objects and Persons. Oxford University Press.
Noveck B.; and Balkin J. 2006. The State of Play: Law Games and Virtual Worlds. New York University Press.
Nozick R. 1974. Anarchy State and Utopia. Basic Books.
Putnam H. 1981. Reason Truth and History. Cambridge University Press.
Reichenbach H. 1958. The Philosophy of Space and Time. New York: Dover.
Salmon Wesley C. 1998. Causality and Explanation. Oxford University Press.
Schiffer S. 1987. Remnants of Meaning. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Wall D. 2009. Crime and Deviance in Cyberspace. Routledge.
Walton K. L. 1990. Mimesis as Make-Believe: On the Foundations of the Representational Arts. Harvard University Press.
Walton K. 2013. Fictionality and imagination reconsidered. In Fictionalism to Realism: Fictional and Other Social Entities ed. by C. Babero M. Ferraris and A. Voltolini. Cambridge Scholars Publishing pp. 9–26.
Wildman N. (ms). Learning by fictionally doing. Unpublished manuscript.
Wildman N. and Woodward R. 2018. Interactivity fictionality and incompleteness. In The Aesthetics of Video Games ed. by J. Robson and G. Tavinor. Routledge pp. 112–27.
Woodward R. 2014. Walton on fictionality. Philosophy Compass 9 (12): 825–36.
Wright C. 1986. Realism Meaning and Truth. Second edition. Oxford: Blackwell 1993.
Zhong L. 2014. Sophisticated exclusion and sophisticated causation. Journal of Philosophy 111(7): 341–60.