Reflective Knowledge and the Nature of Truth

Open access


I consider the problem of reflective knowledge faced by views that treat sensitivity as a sufficient condition for knowledge, or as a major ingredient of the concept, as in the analysis I advance in Scepticism and Reliable Belief. I present the problem as concerning the correct analysis of SATs — beliefs to the effect that one of my current beliefs is true. I suggest that a plausible analysis of SATs should treat them as neither true nor false when they ascribe truth to a non-existent belief. I argue that the problem is inescapable if we construe SATs as ascribing the property of truth to a belief. Deflationism manages to avoid the problem of reflective knowledge, but it does so by violating alethic priority — the principle that our account of representation must be built on our account of truth. I argue that we can avoid the problem of reflective knowledge while preserving alethic priority with a pragmatist account of truth — according to which truth is explicated in terms of the rules that govern the practice of assessing judgments and related items as true or false.

Becker, Kelly. 2006. Is counterfactual reliabilism compatible with higher-level knowledge? Dialectica 60 (1): 79-84.

Brandom, Robert. 1994. Making It Explicit. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Brandom, Robert. 2000. Articulating Reasons: An Introduction to Inferentialism. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Churchland, Paul M. 1979. Scientiic Realism and the Plasticity of Mind. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Cohen, L. Jonathan. 1992. An Essay on Belief and Acceptance. Oxford: Clarendon.

Collins, John. 2002. Truth or meaning? A question of priority. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 65: 497-536.

Davidson, Donald. 1990. The structure and content of truth. Journal of Philosophy 87: 279-328.

DeRose, Keith. 1995. Solving the skeptical problem. Philosophical Review 104: 1-52.

Dummett, Michael. 1978. Truth. In Truth and Other Enigmas. London: Duckworth.

Field, Hartry. 1994. Deflationist views of meaning and content. Mind 103: 249-85.

Horgan, Terry, and Mark Timmons. 2006. Cognitive expressivism. In Metaethics After Moore, edited by T. Horgan and M. Timmons. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Horwich, Paul. 1990. Truth. Oxford: Basil Blackwell.

Horwich, Paul. 2005. Relections on Meaning. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Hume, David. 1978. A Treatise of Human Nature. 2nd ed. Oxford: Clarendon.

Leite, Adam. 2014. Standing beliefs, skepticism, and some questions about Zalabardo’s probabilistic approach. Teorema 33: 159-70.

Melchior, Guido. 2015. The heterogeneity problem for sensitivity accounts. Episteme 12: 479-96.

Price, Huw. 2011. Truth as convenient friction. In Naturalism Without Mirrors. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Rorty, Richard. 1986. Pragmatism, Davidson, and truth. In Truth and Interpretation: Perspectives on the Philosophy of Donald Davidson, edited by E. LePore. Oxford: Blackwell.

Roush, Sherrilyn. 2005. Tracking Truth. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Rumfitt, Ian. 2014. Truth and meaning. Aristotelian Society Supplementary Volume 88: 21-55.

Salerno, Joseph. 2010. Truth-tracking and the problem of reflective knowledge. In Knowledge and Skepticism, edited by J. Keim Campbell, M. O’Rourke and H. S. Silverstein. Cambridge, Mass.: MIT Press.

Sosa, Ernest. 1999. How to defeat opposition to Moore. In Philosophical Perspectives, 13, Epistemology, edited by J. E. Tomberlin. Malden, Massachusetts and Oxford: Blackwell.

Strawson, Peter F. 1949. Truth. Analysis 9: 83-97.

Strawson, Peter F. 1950. On referring. Mind 59: 320-34.

Vogel, Jonathan. 1987. Tracking, closure, and inductive knowledge. In The Possibility of Knowledge: Nozick and His Critics, edited by S. Luper-Foy. Totowa, New Jersey: Rowman & Littlefield.

Vogel, Jonathan. 2000. Reliabilism leveled. Journal of Philosophy 97: 602-23.

Zalabardo, José L. 2012. Scepticism and Reliable Belief. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Zalabardo, José L. 2014. Replies to my critics. Teorema 33: 181-202.

Zalabardo, José L. 2016. Empiricist pragmatism. Philosophical Issues 26.