Higher-Order Vagueness and Numbers of Distinct Modalities

Susanne Bobzien 1
  • 1 University of Oxford,


This paper shows that the following common assumption is false: that in modal-logical representations of higher-order vagueness, for there to be borderline cases to borderline cases ad infinitum, the number of possible distinct modalities in a modal system must be infinite.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Åkerman, Jonas and Greenough, Patrick. 2010. Hold the Context Fixed: Vagueness Still Remains. In Cuts and Clouds: Vagueness, its Nature, and its Logic. Edited by Dietz, Richard and Moruzzi, Sebastian. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 275-88.

  • Bobzien, Susanne. 2010. Higher-order Vagueness, Radical Unclarity, and Absolute Agnosticism. Philosophers’ Imprint 10: 1-30.

  • Bobzien, Susanne. 2012. If it’s Clear, then it’s Clear that it’s Clear, or is it?

  • Bobzien, Susanne Higher-order Vagueness and the S4 Axiom. In Episteme, etc. Edited by Katerina Ierodiakonou and Benjamin Morison. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 189-212.

  • Bobzien, Susanne. 2013. Higher-order Vagueness and Borderline Nestings — a Persistent Confusion. Analytic Philosophy 54: 1-43.

  • Carnielli, Walter and Pizzi, Claudio. 2009. Modalities and Multimodalities. New York: Springer.

  • Chellas, Brian F. 1980. Modal Logic: An Introduction. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

  • Fara, Delia Graff. 2003. Gap principles, penumbral consequence and infinitely higher-order vagueness. In Liars and Heaps: New Essays on Paradox. Edited by J. C. Beall.Oxford: Oxford University Press, 195-222. Originally published under the name ‘Delia Graff’.

  • Greenough, Patrick. 2005. Contextualism about Vagueness and Higher-Order

  • Vagueness. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society (suppl) 105: 167-90.

  • Sainsbury, Mark. 1991. Is There Higher-Order Vagueness? Philosophical Quarterly 41: 167-82.

  • Shapiro, Stewart. 2005. Context, Conversation, and so-called ‘Higher-Order Vagueness’. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society (suppl) 105: 147-65.

  • Williamson, Timothy. 1994. Vagueness. London: Rougledge.

  • Williamson, Timothy. 1999. On the structure of higher-order vagueness. Mind 108: 127-142.

  • Wright, Crispin. 1992. Is Higher-Order Vagueness Coherent? Analysis 52: 129-39.


Journal + Issues