The First-Person Plural and Immunity to Error

Joel Smith 1
  • 1 University of Manchester,


I argue for the view that some we-thoughts are immune to error through misidentification (IEM) relative to the first-person plural pronoun. To prepare the ground for this argument I defend an account of the semantics of ‘we’ and note the variety of different uses of that term. I go on to defend the IEM of a certain range of we-thoughts against a number of objections.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Anscombe, G.E.M. 1975. The first person. In Mind and Language: Wolfson College Lectures 1974, edited by Samuel D. Guttenplan. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

  • Blomberg, Olle. 2018. Practical knowledge and acting together. In Socially Extended Epistemology, edited by J. A. Carter, A. Clark, J. Kallestrup, O. Palermos and D. Pritchard. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • Bratman, Michael E. 2014. Shared Agency: A Planning Theory of Acting Together. New York: Oxford University Press.

  • Braun, David. 2008. Complex demonstratives and their singular contents. Linguistics and Philosophy 31: 57–99.

  • Campbell, John. 1997. Sense, reference and selective attention. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society: Supplementary Volume 71: 55–74.

  • Campbell, John. 1999. Schizophrenia, the space of reasons, and thinking as a motor process. The Monist 82: 609–25.

  • Campbell, John. 2002. Reference and Consciousness. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

  • Corazza, Eros. 2002. ‘She’ and ‘he’: politically correct pronouns. Philosophical Studies 111: 173–96.

  • Evans, Gareth. 1981. Understanding demonstratives. In Meaning and Understanding, edited by H. Parret and J. Bouveresse. Berlin: de Gruyter.

  • Evans, Gareth. 1982. The Varieties of Reference. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

  • García-Carpintero, Manuel. 2018. De se thoughts and immunity to error through misidentification. Synthese 195: 3311–33.

  • Husserl, Edmund. 1900. Logical Investigations, 2 Vols. London: Routledge.

  • Kaplan, David. 1989a. Afterthoughts. In Themes From Kaplan, edited by J. Almog, J. Perry and H. Wettstein. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • Kaplan, David. 1989b. Demonstratives. In Themes From Kaplan, edited by J. Almog, J. Perry and H. Wettstein. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • King, Jeffrey C. 2001. Complex Demonstratives: A Quantiicational Account. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

  • Korta, Kepa. 2016. The meaning of us. Disputatio: Philosophical Research Bulletin. 4: 335–61.

  • Langland-Hassan, Peter. 2015. Introspective misidentification. Philosophical Studies 172: 1737–58.

  • McDowell, John. 1997. Reductionism and the first person. In Reading Parit, edited by Jonathan Dancy. Oxford: Blackwell.

  • Nunberg, Goeffrey. 1993. Indexicality and deixis. Linguistics and Philosophy 16: 1–43.

  • O’Brien, Lucy. 2007. Self-Knowing Agents. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • O’Brien, Lucy. 2012. Action and immunity to error through misidentification. In Immunity to Error Through Misidentiication: New Essays, edited by Simon Prosser and François Recanati. Cambridge University Press.

  • Oliver, Alex; and Timothy Smiley. 2013. Plural Logic. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • Pavlidou, Theodossia-Soula (ed). 2014. Constructing Collectivity: ‘We’ Across Languages and Contexts Amsterdam: John Benjamins.

  • Peacocke, Christopher. 2008. Truly Understood. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • Perry, John. 2001. Reference and Relexivity. Stanford, CA: CSLI Publications.

  • Prosser, Simon. 2012. Sources of immunity to error through misidentification. In Immunity to Error Through Misidentiication: New Essays, edited by Simon Prosser and François Recanati. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

  • Prosser, Simon; and François Recanati (eds). 2012. Immunity to Error Through Misidentiication: New Essays Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

  • Pryor, James. 1999. Immunity to error through misidentification. Philosophical Topics 26: 271–304.

  • Quine, W. V. O. 1950. Identity, ostension, and hypostasis. The Journal of Philosophy 47: 621–33.

  • Salje, Léa. 2017. Thinking about you. Mind 126: 817–40.

  • Schmid, Hans Bernhard. 2016. On knowing what we’re doing together: groundless group self-knowledge and plural self-blindness. In The Epistemic Life of Groups: Essays in the Epistemology of Collectives, edited by Michael Brady and Miranda Fricker. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • Schmid, Hans Bernhard. 2018. The subject of ‘we intend’. Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences 17: 231–43.

  • Searle, John. 1990. Collective intentions and actions. In Intentions in Communication, edited by Philip Cohen, Jerry Morgan and Martha E. Pollack. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

  • Shoemaker, Sydney. 1970. Persons and their pasts. American Philosophical Quarterly 7: 269–85.

  • Smith, Joel. 2006. Which immunity to error. Philosophical Studies 130: 273–83.

  • Smith, Joel. 2010. Seeing other people. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 81: 731–48.

  • Smith, Joel. 2015. The phenomenology of face-to-face mindreading. Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 90: 274–93.

  • Stevens, Graham. 2011. The Theory of Descriptions: Russell and the Philosophy of Language. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.

  • Vallée, Richard. 1996. Who are we? Canadian Journal of Philosophy 26: 211–30.


Journal + Issues