The making of the South African timeshare industry: spatial structure and development challenges

Open access

Abstract

Research on the accommodation sector attracts only a small fraction of contemporary tourism scholarship relating to sub-Saharan Africa. This paper contributes to this expanding literature on segmentation and the accommodation sector in South Africa. Specifically, it examines the establishment and making of the timeshare industry as a distinctive form of accommodation within the national tourism economy. The timeshare industry in South Africa is the largest and most mature in sub-Saharan Africa and among the most important in the developing world. The analysis uses a longitudinal perspective in order to interpret the emerging spatial organisation and evolving structural issues that impacted upon the development of the timeshare industry in its formative years from 1978 to 2002. The study addresses a knowledge gap around the minimal pursuit of historical research within the existing international literature about timeshare.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Berger B.B. and Chiofaro Jr D.J. 2007: Select-Service Hotels: A Guide to Understanding the Lodging Industry and One of its Most Attractive Segments. Unpublished MSc (Real Estate Development) Boston: Massachusetts Institute of Technology.

  • Bosch A. 2012: Interview Former Executive Director Durban: VOASA 10 June.

  • Bradley G.L. and Sparks B.A. 2012: Antecedents and Consequences of Consumer Value: A Longitudinal Study of Timeshare Owners. In: Journal of Travel Research Vol. 51 pp. 191-204.

  • Business Day (Johannesburg) 7 December 1988 30 August 1989 7 November 1989 8 November 1989 16 February 1993 30 June 1993.

  • Business Times (Johannesburg) 26 September 1992.

  • Cesaret B. Dawande M. and Rajapakshe T. 2013: Bicriteria Timeshare Exchanges with Member Participa tion. Paper prepared at Jindal School of Management Dallas: University of Texas.

  • Chiang L.C. 2001: Marketing Timeshare in Singapore: An Analysis of Potential Customers and Present Owners. In: Asia Pacific Journal of Tourism Research Vol. 6 (2) 17-23.

  • Cortés-Jimenéz I. Pratt S. Bregoli I. and Cooper C. 2012: The European Timeshare Consumer in the Twenty-first Century. In: International Journal of Tourism Research Vol. 14 pp. 153-164.

  • Crotts J.C. and Ragatz R.L. 2002: Recent US Timeshare Purchasers: Who are They What are They Buying and How Can They be Reached? In: International Journal of Hospitality Management Vol. 21 pp. 227-238.

  • Crotts J.C. Aziz A. and Upchurch R.S. 2005: Relationship Between Machiavellianism and Sales Performance. In: Tourism Analysis Vol. 10 (1) pp. 79-84.

  • Deng E.Y. 2013: Timeshares: An Analysis of Development Processes and Methodologies. Masters thesis Austin: University of Texas.

  • Dev C.S. and Hubbard J.E. 1989: A Strategic Analysis of the Lodging Industry. In: Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Quarterly Vol. 30 (1) pp. 19-23.

  • Ferreira S. and Boshoff A. 2014: Post-2010 FIFA Soccer World Cup: Oversupply and Location of Luxury Hotel Rooms in Cape Town. In: Current Issues in Tourism Vol. 17 (2) pp. 180-198.

  • Financial Mail (Johannesburg) 4 September 1992 20 May 1993 4 March 1994 5 August 1994 18 October 2002.

  • Finance Week (Johannesburg) 27 July 1988 9 December 1988 31 August 1989 23 November 1989.

  • Gregory A.M. 2013: Examining the Negative Attributes on Consumer Preference and Willingness to Pay in the Vacation Ownership Industry: A Conjoint Analysis. In: Journal of Tourism Research and Hospitality 2 (3) pp. 1-5.

  • Grundlingh A. 2006: Revisiting the ‘Old’ South Africa: Excursions into South Africa’s Tourist History Under Apartheid 1948-1990. In: South African Historical Journal Vol. 56 pp. 103-122.

  • Haasbroek N.F.J. 1984: The Concept of Timesharing as Applied in South Africa. Unpublished MBA Thesis Johannesburg: University of the Witwatersrand.

  • Hahm J. Lasten E. Upchurch R.S. and Peterson R. 2007: State of the Timeshare Industry in Aruba-A Call for Research. In: Journal of Retail and Leisure Property Vol. 6 pp. 221-229. Hatjigiannakis M. 2012: Interview. Executive Director Johannesburg: VOASA 28 June.

  • Hatley L.E. 1990: Conflict in the Timeshare Industry. Unpublished MBA Thesis Johannesburg: University of the Witwatersrand.

  • Hawkins D.E. 1985: Tourist Holiday Options: Timeshare Versus Competition. In: Tourism Management Vol. 6 pp. 252-271.

  • Haylock R. 1994a: The European Timeshare Market: The Growth Development Regulation and Economic Benefits of One of Tourism’s Most Successful Sectors. In: Tourism Management Vol. 15 pp. 333-341.

  • Haylock R. 1994b: Timeshare - The New Force in Tourism. In: Seaton A.V. Jenkins C.L. Wood R.C. Dieke P.U.C. Bennett M.M. MacLellan L.R. and Smith R. editors. Tourism: The State of the Art Chichester: John Wiley pp. 230-237.

  • Hicks G.J. and Walker M.D. 2006: Training in the Timeshare Industry. In: Tourism and Hospitality Research Vol. 6 pp. 296-300.

  • Hitchcock N. 2001: The Future of Timesharing. In: Lockwood A. and Medlik S. editors Tourism and Hospitality in the 21st Century London: Butterworth- Heinemann pp. 230-239.

  • Hoogendoorn G. 2011: Low-Income Earners as Second Home Tourists in South Africa. In: Tourism Review International Vol. 15 (1/2) 37-50.

  • Hoogendoorn G. and Visser G. 2011: Second Homes and Economic Development Issues in Small Town South Africa. In: Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie Vol. 102 pp. 275-289

  • Hoogendoorn G. Visser G. and Mellett R. 2005: Second Homes Tourism in Africa: Reflections on the South African Experience. In: Urban Forum Vol. 16 pp. 112-154.

  • Huang C. Pennington-Grey L. Ko Y.J. and Thapa B. 2010a: Engaging Timeshare Owners in Tourism Destination Management: Tourism Planning and Tourism Marketing Implications. In: Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing Vol. 27 pp. 14-30.

  • Huang C. Pennington-Grey L. Thapa B. Phillips R. and Holland S. 2010b: Timeshare Owners’ Perceptions and Preferred Ways of Participating in Tourism Planning. In: Journal of Hospitality Marketing and Management Vol. 20 pp. 103-120.

  • Hyma B. Ojo A. and Wall G. 1980: Tourism in Tropical Africa: A Review of Literature in English and Research Agenda. In: Annals of Tourism Research Vol. 7 (4) pp. 525-553.

  • Kaufman T.J. Upchurch R. and Severt D. 2006: Vacation Ownership: Understanding the Senior Market. In: Journal of Retail and Leisure Property Vol. 5 pp. 95-103.

  • Liu J. Pryer M. and Roberts A. 2001: Timeshare Opportunities in China: An Evaluation of the Conditions for Market Development. In: Journal of Vacation Marketing Vol. 8 (1) pp. 88-98.

  • Magombo A. and Rogerson C.M. 2012: The Evolution of the Tourism Sector in Malawi. In: Africa Insight Vol. 42 (2) pp. 46-65.

  • Mania E.V. 2008: Does the South African Timeshare Market Provide Financial Institutions With an Opportunity to Enter the Industry to Extend Its Product Range Thereby Increasing its Loan Book? Unpublished MBA Thesis Johannesburg: University of the Witwatersrand.

  • Massyn P. and Koch E. 2004: African Game Lodges and Rural Benefit in Two Southern African Countries. In: Rogerson C.M. and Visser G. editors Tourism and Development Issues in Contemporary South Africa Pretoria: Africa Institute of South Africa pp. 102-138.

  • Pandy W.R. and Rogerson C.M. 2013: The timeshare industry of Africa: a study in tourism geography. In: Szymańska D. and Chodkowska-Miszczuk J. editors Bulletin of Geography. Socio-economic Series No. 21 Toruń: Nicolaus Copernicus University Press pp. 97- -109. DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.2478/bog-2013-0024

  • Pandy W. and Rogerson C.M. 2013b: An Historical Overview of the Establishment of Timeshare Recreation Accommodation in South Africa (1978-1982). In: African Journal for Physical Health Education Recreation and Dance Vol. 19 (Supplement 2) pp. 106-122

  • Pandy W. and Rogerson C.M. 2013c: The Timeshare Industry of South Africa: Analysis and Contemporary Challenges. In: African Journal for Physical Health Education Recreation and Dance Vol. 19 (Supplement 2) pp. 248-266.

  • Pandy W. and Rogerson C.M. 2014: The Evolution and Consolidation of the Timeshare Industry in a Developing Economy: The South African Experience. In: Urbani Izziv Vol. 25 (Supplement) pp. S162-S175.

  • Pienaar J.J. and Visser G. 2009: The Thorny Issue of Identifying Second Homes in South Africa. In: Urban Forum Vol. 20 pp. 455-469.

  • Pienaar P. 2012: Interview. General Manager Durban: Southern Sun Resorts Central Office 10 June. Pollard L.M. 2010: Perceived Service Quality’s Impact on Behavioral Intentions in the Timeshare Industry. PhD dissertation USA Orlando: University of Central Florida.

  • Powanga A. and Powanga L. 2008: An Economic Analysis of a Timeshare Ownership. In: Journal of Retail and Leisure Property Vol. 7 pp. 69-83.

  • Rand Daily Mail (Johannesburg) 28 January 1983 24 August 1983 11 January 1984 27 July 1984 30 November 1985.

  • Rezak S. 2002: Consumer Research Sheds Light on all Aspects of Resort Timesharing Business. In: International Journal of Hospitality Management Vol. 21 pp. 245-255.

  • Rogerson C.M. 1990: Sun International: The Making of a South African Tourism Multinational. In: GeoJournal Vol. 22 pp. 345-354.

  • Rogerson C.M. 2004: Transforming the South African Tourism Industry: The Emerging Black-owned Bed and Breakfast Economy. In: GeoJournal Vol. 60 pp. 273-281.

  • Rogerson C.M. 2007: The Challenge of Developing Backpacker Tourism in South Africa: An Enterprise Perspective. In: Development Southern Africa Vol. 24 pp. 425-444.

  • Rogerson C.M. 2011: From Liquor to Leisure: The Changing South African Hotel Industry 1928-1968. In: Urban Forum Vol. 22 pp. 379-394.

  • Rogerson C.M. 2012: The Tourism-Development Nexus in Sub-Saharan Africa: Progress and Prospects. In: Africa Insight Vol. 42 (2) pp. 28-45.

  • Rogerson C.M. and Lisa Z. 2005: ‘Sho’t left’: Promoting Domestic Tourism in South Africa. In: Urban Forum Vol. 16 pp. 88-111.

  • Rogerson C.M. and Rogerson J. M. 2011: Tourism Research Within the Southern African Development Community: Production and Consumption in Academic Journals 2000-2010. In: Tourism Review International Vol. 15 (1/ 2) pp. 213-222.

  • Rogerson C.M. and Visser G. 2011: African Tourism Geographies: Existing Paths and New Directions. In: Tijdschrift voor Economische en Sociale Geografie Vol. 102 (3) pp. 251-259.

  • Rogerson J.M. 2010: The Boutique Hotel Industry in South Africa: Definition Scope and Organization. In: Urban Forum Vol. 21 pp. 425-439.

  • Rogerson J.M. 2011a: The Limited Services Hotel in South Africa: The Growth of City Lodge In: Urban Forum Vol. 22 pp. 343-361.

  • Rogerson J.M. 2011b: The Changing All-suite Hotel in South Africa: From ‘Extended Stay’ to African Condo Hotel. In: Tourism Review International Vol. 15 (1/2) pp. 107-121.

  • Rogerson J.M. 2012a: The Changing Location of Hotels in South Africa’s Coastal Cities. In: Urban Forum Vol. 23 pp. 73-91.

  • Rogerson J.M. 2012b: Hotels as a Property Asset Class: International and South African Trends. In: Africa Insight Vol. 42 pp. 200-211.

  • Rogerson J.M. 2013a: Reconfiguring South Africa’s Hotel Industry 1990-2010: Structure Segmentation and Spatial Transformation In: Applied Geography Vol. 36 pp. 59-68.

  • Rogerson J. M. 2013b: The Economic Geography of South Africa’s Hotel Industry 1990 to 2010. In: Urban Forum Vol. 24 (3) pp. 425-446.

  • Rogerson J.M. 2013c: Market Segmentation and the Changing Budget Hotel Industry in South Africa. In: Urbani Izziv 24 (2) pp. 112-123.

  • Rogerson J.M. 2013d: The Changing Accommodation Landscape of Free State 1936-2010. In: African Journal for Physical Health Education Recreation and Dance Vol. 19 (Supplement 2) pp. 86-104.

  • Rogerson J.M. 2014a: Hotel Location in Africa’s World Class City: The Case of Johannesburg South Africa. In: Bulletin of Geography: Socio-Economic Series Vol. 25 pp. 181-196.

  • Rogerson J.M. 2014b: Changing Hotel Location Patterns in Ekurhuleni South Africa’s Industrial Workshop. In: Urbani Izziv 25 (Supplement) pp. S81-S95.

  • Rogerson J.M. and Kotze N. 2011: Market Segmentation and the Changing South African Hotel Industry 1990 to 2010. In: African Journal of Business Management Vol. 5 pp. 13523-13533.

  • Rogerson J.M. and Sims S.R. 2012: The Greening of Urban Hotels in South Africa: Evidence from Gauteng. In: Urban Forum Vol. 23 pp. 391-407. Saturday Star (Johannesburg) 1 November 1992.

  • Sharma S. and Chowdhary N. 2012: Leveraging Tourism: The Business of Timeshare. In: South Asian Journal of Tourism and Heritage Vol. 5 pp. 111-128.

  • Shrivastava P.K. 2013: A Study of Influence Factors and Satisfaction Level of Customers Belonging to Timeshare Industry. In: Research Analysis and Evaluation 4 (43-44) pp. 48-49.

  • Singh A. and Hurwitz R. 2006: The Board of Directors in Timeshare Governance: Owner-management Relations in Timeshare Resort Operations. In: Journal of Retail and Leisure Property Vol. 5 (3) pp. 185-196.

  • Sparks B. and Smith J. 2010: The De Haan Family and RCI: The development of the timeshare industry. In: Butler R.W. and Russell R.A. editors Giants of Tourism Wallingford: CAB International.

  • Sparks B. Bradley G. and Jennings G. 2011: Customer Value and Self-Image Congruency at Different Stages of Timeshare Ownership. In: Tourism Management Vol. 32 pp. 1176-1185.

  • Sparks B.A. Bradley G.L. Jennings G.R. and Johnston N.R. 2014: Cooling Off and Backing Out: Understanding Consumer Decisions to Rescind a Product Purchase. In: Journal of Business Research Vol. 67 (1) pp. 2903-2910.

  • Stocks B. 2008: Specific developments within the industry. Paper presented at the RCI Star Conference Johannesburg.

  • Stocks B. 2012: Interview Chief Executive Director Southern Sun Timesharing 28 June.

  • Stringam B.B. 2010: Timeshare and Vacation Ownership Executives’ Analysis of the Industry and The Future. In: Journal of Retail and Leisure Property Vol. 9 pp. 37-54.

  • Sunday Express (Johannesburg) 21 August 1983.

  • Sunday Times (Johannesburg) 3 June 1984 19 August 1986 3 December 1988 10 June 1990 14 October 1990 25 March 1990 26 September 1992 6 March 1994 Terry G.A. 1994: Resort timesharing - Coming of age. In: Tourism Management Vol. 15 pp. 327-332.

  • The Star (Johannesburg) 9 September 1992

  • Thomas L.Y. 2010: Evaluating Point-of-sale Buying Decisions: Understanding Why Consumers Purchase Timeshares. Unpublished PhD Thesis. Las Vegas: University of Nevada.

  • Timothy D. J. and Teye V.B. 2009: Tourism and the Lodging Sector London: Butterworth-Heinemann.

  • Upchurch R. S. and Gruber K. 2002: The Evolution of a Sleeping Giant: Resort Timesharing. In: International Journal of Hospitality Management Vol. 21 pp. 211-225.

  • Upchurch R.S. and Lashley C. 2006: Timeshare Resort Operations Oxford: Butterworth-Heinemann.

  • Upchurch R. S. and Rompf P. 2006: Postpurchase Behavior: A Case Study into a Vacation club product. In: Tourism Analysis Vol. 11 pp. 45-59

  • Upchurch R. Rompf P. and Severt D. 2006: Segmentation and Satisfaction Preferences of specific Looking Glass Cohorts Profiles: A Case Study of the Timeshare Industry. In: Journal of Retail and Leisure Property Vol. 5 pp. 173-184

  • Van der Merwe C.G. 2010: Sectional Titles Share Blocks and Time-Sharing Vol. 1 Sectional Titles Durban: LexisNexis Butterworths.

  • Visser G. 2003: Visible Yet Unknown: Reflections on Second-Home Development in South Africa. In: Urban Forum 14 (4) 379-407.

  • Visser G. 2013: Looking Beyond the Urban Poor in South Africa: The New terra incognita for Urban Geography? In: Canadian Journal of African Studies Vol. 47 (1) pp. 75-93.

  • Visser G. and Hoogendoorn G. 2011: Current Paths in South African Tourism Research. In: Tourism Review International Vol. 15 (1/2) pp. 5-20.

  • Visser G. and Rogerson C.M. 2014: Reflections on 25 Years of Urban Forum. In: Urban Forum Vol. 25 pp. 1-12

  • Visser G. and Van Huyssteen M. K. R. 1997: Guest Houses - New Options for Tourists in the West ern Cape Winelands. In: Acta Academica Vol. 29 pp. 106-133.

  • Visser G. and Van Huyssteen K. 1999: Guest Houses: The Emergence of a New Tourist Accommodation Type in the South African Tourism Industry. In: Tourism and Hospitality Research Vol. 1 pp. 155-175.

  • Weaver D.B. and Lawton L.J. 1998: A Profile of Time- Sharing on the Gold Coast of Australia. In: Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Research Vol. 22 pp. 225-238. Weekly Mail (Johannesburg) 16 November 1994.

  • World Bank 2012: Transformation Through Tourism: Development Dynamics Past Present and Future Washington DC The World Bank.

  • Zacharatos G. and Stavrinoudis T. 2009: The Standards- Characteristics Matrix: A Methodological Tool for the Codification and Evaluation of the International Operational Implementation of Timeshare. Paper presented at 4th International Scientific Conference Rhodes Island Greece 3-5 April.

Search
Journal information
Impact Factor


CiteScore 2018: 1.11

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2018: 0.218
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2018: 0.591

Cited By
Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 226 124 3
PDF Downloads 164 110 3