‘Knowledge Workers’ in the Baltic Sea Region: Comparative Assessment of Innovative Performance of the Countries in the Macro-Region

Open access


The article studies the problems of human resources stemming from increased mobility, and the emergence of new aspects of migration processes. A comparative analysis of the connection between academic development in the context of university (and the science system) and the process of labour migration taking place in Poland, Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia was carried out. The article examines the limits of the model through European territorial migration process and concludes that the huge migration of high-skilled labour (called the “knowledge workers”) has had a very negative impact on the innovative and academic potential of Poland, Lithuania, Latvia and a negative impact in Estonia. In the final section, the article examines increase in the requirements for competence in the Baltic Sea macroregion of the European Union and Estonia’s university reform of 2013-2016 as an illustrative experiment to (un)resolved problems. The first results of the reform in higher education indicated that it was ineffective-for students, the good ideas of the reform proved to be a lost experiment and the mobility of knowledge workers, as the future academic resource in homeland, turned from Estonia to larger Europe, especially to Finland and the UK.

Allik, J. (2018), ‘Millist Tartu Ülikooli me tahame?’[What kind of University of Tartu do we want?] Postimees, 10 Feb 2018.

Baltic Development Forum Report (2012), The Top of Europe Bracing Itself for Difficult Times: Baltic Sea Region-Collaboration to Sustain Growth, Copenhagen: Baltic Development Forum.

Communication from the Commission to the European Parliament, The Council, The European Economic and Social Committee and the Committee of Regions concerning the European Union Strategy for the Baltic Sea Region, COM(2009) 248 final, 03.12.2009.

Database of Indicators (2011), ‘Population Migration 1994-2011,’ Population and Social Statistics, Statistics Lithuania, Database of Indicators, Vilnius: Statistikos departamentas.

EC (2010), EUROPE 2020: A strategy for smart, sustainable and inclusive growth, Communication from the Commission, COM (2010)2020 final. Brussels: EC, 03.03.2011.

EHEA (2012), The European Higher Education Area in 2012: The Bologna Process Implementation Report, Brussels: Eurodyke, European Commission and Eurostat.

EHEA (2015), The European Higher Education Area in 2015: The Bologna Process Implementation Report, Brussels: Eurodyke, European Commission and Eurostat.

EIS (2017), European Innovation Scoreboard: ‘Annex B - Performance per indicators’ and ‘Database - Annex C’, Brussels: European Commission.

Eesti Statistika aastaraamat (2016), Statistical Yearbook of Estonia, Tallinn: Statistikaamet.

Ennuste, Ü. (2009), ‘Synthetic conceptions of implementing mechanisms design for public socio-economic information structure: illustrative Estonian examples,’ Proceedings of the Institute for European Studies, no. 4, pp. 9-39.

Estonian Ministry of Science and Education (2017), ‘2016/2017 õppeaasta arvudes,’ [2016/2017 schoolyear statistics]. Retrieved from https://www.hm.ee/sites/default/files/2016-2017-oppeaasta_arvudes.pdf [accessed 10 Feb 2018]

Etzold, T. (2011), ‘Key messages and outlook on 2012,’ in B. Henningsen & T. Etzold (eds.) Political State of the Baltic Sea Region Report 2011, Copenhagen/Gdansk: Baltic Development Forum & Konrad Adenauer Stiftung, pp. 88-90.

Etzold, T. (2012), ‘Final remarks, key messages, conclusions and outlook on 2013,’ in B. Henningsen & T. Etzold (eds.) Political State of the Region Report 2012 - Dilemmas and Coherence in the Baltic Sea Region, Copenhagen: Baltic Development Forum, pp. 69-71.

IMF (2016), Emigration and Its Economic Impact on Eastern Europe, IMF Staff Discussion Note, SDN/16/07, July 2016.

Jakobson, M.-L.; Järvinen-Alenius, P.; Pitkänen, P.; Ruutsoo, R.; Hirvela, E.-K. & Kalev, L. (2012), ‘The emergence of Estonian-Finnish transnational space,’ in Migration and Transformation, Vol. 3, Berlin: Springer, pp. 159-205. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-94-007-3968-0_5

Kerikmäe, T. (2001), ‘Estonian constitutional problems in accession to the EU,’ in A. E. Kellermann, J. W. de Zwaan & J. Czuczai (eds.) EU Enlargement: The Constitutional Impact at EU and National Level, The Hague: Springer, pp. 291−300. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-90-6704-449-3_24

Ketels, C. & Skilling, D. (2017), The Future of Europe and Globalization: Where is the Voice of the Baltic Sea Region? Copenhagen/Stockholm: Baltic Development Forum & Swedish Agency for Economic and Regional Growth.

Kirch, A. (2009), ‘Estonia must focus on the grand challenges of our time: the process of the implementation of the knowledge triangle,’ Proceedings of the Institute for European Studies, no. 6, pp. 36−50.

Kirch, A.; Mezentsev, V. & Rodin, M. (2011), ‘The human resources in Baltic Sea macro-region: facts, trends and potential risks to fulfilling the Strategy 2020

targets,’ in T. Muravska (ed.) European Integration and Baltic Sea Region: Diversity and Perspectives, Riga: The University of Latvia, pp. 533−543.

Kirch, A.; Nezerenko, O. & Mezentsev, V. (2011), ‘Estonia and other countries of the Baltic Sea Region as actors of development: conceptual approach,’ in European Integration Studies: Research and Topicalities, vol. 5, pp. 199-204.

Koikkalainen, S. (2017), ‘Finnish highly skilled migrants and the European economic crisis,’ Baltic Journal of European Studies, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 168-181. https://doi.org/10.1515/bjes-2017-0015

Kotka, T. (2012), ‘Mul on unistus - I have a dream,’ Äripäev, 2. Nov 2012. Retrieved from http://www.ituudised.ee/article/2012/11/2/taavi-kotka-i-have-a-dream [accessed Nov 2017]

Lauristin, M., ed. (2011), Eesti hariduse viis väljakutset: Eesti haridusstrateegia 2012-2020 projekt [Education Strategy in Estonia for 2012-2020, Project of the Estonian Cooperation Assembly]

Murashova, E. & Loginova, V. (2017), ‘University-industry interaction trends in the Baltic Sea Region: a bibliometric analysis,’ Baltic Journal of European Studies, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 28-58. https://doi.org/10.1515/bjes-2017-0009

Population Census (2011), ‘Key Indicators,’ Riga: Central Statistical Bureau of Latvia, 2 Apr 2012. Retrieved from http://www.csb.gov.lv/en/statistikas-temas/populationcensus-2011-key-indicators-33613.html [accessed Oct 2012]

Raidla, J. & Varblane, U. (2018), ‘Väikese Eesti suur lugu,’ [The big story of littleEstonia], Postimees, 3 Feb 2018.

Rannala, H. & Tammur, A. (2010), ‘Eesti rändestatistika ja piirkondlik rahvaarv statistikaameti andmetel,’[Estonian migration and regional population statistics] in Rahvaarv ja ränne - Population and Migration, 4/10, Tallinn: Eesti Statistikaamet, pp. 66-74. Research in Estonia (n.d.), ‘Research institutions,’ Retrieved from http://researchinestonia.eu/research-landscape-2/research-institutions/ [accessed Feb 2018]

State of the Region Report (2011), ‘The top of Europe’s quest for resilience: a competitive region facing a fragile global economy,’ Copenhagen & Gdansk: Baltic Development Forum. Retrieved from http://www.bdforum.org/cmsystem/wp-content/uploads/State-of-the-Region-Report-2011.pdf [accessed 10 Feb 2018]

Statistics Estonia (2017), ‘Eesti Statistikaameti andmebaas teaduse rahastamisest (aastatel 2013-2016)’ [Research and development expenditures and their financing from state and local budgets]. Retrieved from http://andmebaas.stat.ee/Index.aspx?lang=et&DataSetCode=TD052 [accessed 10 Feb 2018]

Statistics Estonia (2018), ‘Population indicators and composition,’ Retrieved from http://andmebaas.stat.ee/?lang=en&SubSessionId=3466baa8-ba47-41ee-ba0c-1e125b71f439 &themetreeid=-200 [accessed 10 Feb 2018]

Statistics Lithuania (2011), ‘Provisional Results of the Population and Housing Census 2011 by County and Municipality,’ Statistics Lithuania Press release, 2 Dec 2011, no. 18/287. Retrieved from http://www.stat.gov.lt/uploads/docs/3surasymas_e.pdf [accessed Oct 2012]

The Economist (2012), ‘French competitiveness: a rude awakening,’ 10 Nov 2012.

The World Bank (2017), Migration and Mobility: Europe and Central Asia Economic Update, Washington, DC: The World Bank Group.

Tiit, E.-M. (2015), ‘Eesti viimase veerandsajandi välisränne. Statistiline hinnang,’ [External migration in Estonia in the past 25 years. A statistical estimate] in Rahvastiku areng - Population Trends, Tallinn: Eesti Statistikaamet, pp. 56-75.

Tiits, M. (2011), Technology Foresight and the Catching-up Strategy in Small Countries: The Case of Estonia, PhD thesis, Series I: Social Sciences, no. 16, Tallinn: TUT Press.

TUT (2017), ‘TTÜ ja Infokolledž ühinevad suurimaks IT õppe-kompetentsikeskuseks,’[ TUT and Info College merge into the largest IT learning and competence centre] Uudised, Tallinn University of Technology, 1 Aug 2017. Retrieved from https://ttu.ee/ttu-ja-it-kolledz-uhinevad-suurimaks-it-oppekompetentsikeskuseks [accessed 10 Feb 2018]

World Economic Forum (2016), Europe’s Hidden Entrepreneurs: Entrepreneurial Employee Activity and Competitiveness in Europe, December 2016, Geneva: World Economic Forum.

Baltic Journal of European Studies

Tallinn Law School, Department of Law, School of Business and Governance, TalTech University

Journal Information

CiteScore 2017: 0.22

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2017: 0.119
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2017: 0.113


All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 148 148 48
PDF Downloads 71 71 22