Empathetic perspective-taking is one of the main psychological mechanisms behind audiences’ engagement with narrative (Coplan 2004; Eder 2006). What happens, however, when a story confronts with a character whose emotions, motivations, and beliefs we fail to understand? This paper examines the phenomenon of “unreadable minds” (Abbott 2008) from a transmedial perspective: how do audiences relate to a character who defies all attempts at making sense of his or her identity despite being the main focus of a narrative? My case studies - the novel American Psycho (1991) by Bret Easton Ellis and the video game Hotline Miami (Dennaton Games 2012) - foreground two such characters: by calling attention to the opaqueness of their protagonists, they heighten the audiences’ interest in - and puzzlement at - their identity. In my comparative analysis I explore two dimensions that contribute to audiences’ sense of unknowability of the protagonists: the hallucinations and delusions experienced by both characters (an instance of what Bernaerts  calls “narrative delirium”); and their extreme violence, which raises unanswered ethical questions. While bringing out the continuities between American Psycho and Hotline Miami, I also highlight how the interactivity of Hotline Miami makes the central paradox of relating to an unknowable character even more salient for the audience. In this way, I show that the video game medium has reached a level of interpretive complexity that can stand the comparison with literary fiction.
If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.
Aarseth Espen. 1997. Cybertext. Baltimore and London: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Abbott H. Porter. 2008. Unreadable Minds and the Captive Reader. Style vol. 42 no. 4: 448-467.
Bernaerts Lars. 2009. Fight Club and the Embedding of Delirium in Narrative. Style vol. 43 no. 3: 373-387.
BioWare. 2007. Mass Effect. Xbox 360. Microsoft Game Studios.
Calleja Gordon. 2011. In-Game: From Immersion to Incorporation. Cambridge MA: MIT Press.
Caracciolo Marco. 2013. Patterns of Cognitive Dissonance in Readers’ Engagement with Characters. Enthymema no. 8: 21-37.
Caracciolo Marco. 2014a. Beyond Other Minds: Fictional Characters Mental Simulation and ‘Unnatural’ Experiences. Journal of Narrative Theory vol. 44 no. 1.
Caracciolo Marco. 2014b. Two Child Narrators: Defamiliarization Empathy and Reader-Response in Mark Haddon’s The Curious Incident and Emma Donoghue’s Room. Semiotica.
CD Projekt RED. 2007. The Witcher. Microsoft Windows. Atari.
Churchland Paul M. 1991. Folk Psychology and the Explanation of Human Behavior. In The Future of Folk Psychology: Intentionality and Cognitive Science ed. John D. Greenwood 51-69. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Ciccoricco David. 2007. “Play Memory”: Shadow of the Colossus and Cognitive Workouts. Dichtung-Digital vol./no. ???37.
Coplan Amy. 2004. Empathic Engagement with Narrative Fictions. The Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism vol. 62 no. 2: 141-152.
Damuel. 2013. Comment. Hotline Miami Steam Discussion Board. http://steamcommunity.com/app/219150/discussions/0/846955554708277184/. Last accessed at 23. 09. 2014.
Dennaton Games. 2012. Hotline Miami. Microsoft Windows. Devolver Digital.
Eder Jens. 2006. Ways of Being Close to Characters. Film Studies vol. 8: 68-80.
Ellis Bret Easton. 1991. American Psycho. New York: Random House.
Gaut Berys. 1999. Identification and Emotion in Narrative Film. In Passionate Views: Film Cognition and Emotion eds. Carl Plantinga and Greg M. Smith 200-216. Baltimore and London: Johns Hopkins University Press.
Gendler Tamar Szabó. 2000. The Puzzle of Imaginative Resistance. The Journal of Philosophy vol. 97 no. 2: 55-81.
Hansen Per Krogh. 2008. Unreliable Narration in Cinema: Facing the Cognitive Challenge Arising from Literary Studies. Amsterdam International Electronic Journal for Cultural Narratology vol. or no. ??5. http://cf.hum.uva.nl/narratology/a09_hansen.htm. Last accessed at 23. 09. 2014.
Hayes Amy E. and Steven P. Tipper. 2012. Affective Responses to Everyday Actions. In Kinesthetic Empathy in Creative and Cultural Practices eds. Dee Reynolds and Matthew Reason 47-58. Bristol: Intellect.
Herman David. 2011. Introduction. In The Emergence of Mind: Representations of Consciousness in Narrative Discourse in English ed. David Herman 1-40. Lincoln and London: University of Nebraska Press.
Ismail Rami. 2012. Why Hotline Miami Is an Important Game. Gamasutra. http://www.gamasutra.com/blogs/RamiIsmail/20121029/180408/. Last accessed at 24. 09. 2014.
Jørgensen Kristine. 2010. Game Characters as Narrative Devices: A Comparative Analysis of Dragon Age: Origins and Mass Effect 2. Eludamos: Journal for Computer Game Culture vol. 4 no. 2: 315-331.
Klecker Cornelia. 2013. Mind-Tricking Narratives: Between Classical and Art-Cinema Narration. Poetics Today vol. 34 no. 1-2: 119-146.
Mäkelä Maria. 2013. Cycles of Narrative Necessity: Suspect Tellers and the Textuality of Fictional Minds. In Stories and Minds: Cognitive Approaches to Literary Narrative eds. Lars Bernaerts Dirk De Geest Luc Herman and Bart Vervaeck 129-151. Lincoln and London: University of Nebraska Press.
Meer Alec. 2012. Wot I Think: Hotline Miami. Rock Paper Shotgun. http://www.rockpapershotgun.com/2012/10/23/hotline-miami-review. Last accessed at 23. 09. 2014.
Onyett Charles. 2012. Crazy Kills: Hotline Miami Review. Ign.com. http://www.ign.com/articles/2012/10/27/hotline-miami-review. Last accessed at 23. 09. 2014.
Palahniuk Chuck. 1996. Fight Club. New York: Norton.
Refn Nicolas Winding. 2011. Drive. FilmDistrict.
Ryan Marie-Laure. 2006. Avatars of Story. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
Serpell C. Namwali. 2009. Repetition and the Ethics of Suspended Reading in American Psycho. Critique: Studies in Contemporary Fiction vol. 51 no. 1: 47-73.
Telltale Games. 2012. The Walking Dead. Microsoft Windows.
Vella Daniel. 2013. “It’s A-Me/Mario:” Playing as a Ludic Character. Foundations of Digital Games Conference Proceedings 31-38. http://www.fdg2013.org/program/papers/paper05_vella.pdf. Last accesed at 23. 09. 2014.