How Long and When: Open Time Interval and Dignified Living Creatures in The Turin Horse

Open access


László Krasznahorkai wrote two different texts (the second being the script of Béla Tarr’s film) from two different perspectives starting from the well-known scene in Turin, Italy, where Friedrich Nietzsche embraced a horse beaten severely by the carter. Why does the interpretation of the Nietzsche-scene change? What kind of temporal, historical or ethical relationship does the differentiation between the two texts depend on? How can the beauty of the crumbs of life be perceivable? This article argues that in these works - in contrast with the commonly assumed precognitions about apocalyptic art - life and humble living creatures are celebrated.

Brecht. Bertolt. 1964. A Short Organum for the Theatre. In Brecht on Theatre: The Development of an Aesthetic, ed. John Willett. 179-205. London: Methuen. Deleuze. Gilles. 2005. Cinema 2: The Time-Image. London: Continuum. Dostoyevsky. Fyodor Mikhailovich. 2005. The Idiot. New York: Barnes & Noble Classics.

Fold6nyi, F. L&szld. 1999. Heinrich von Kleist: Im Netz der Whiter. [Heinrich von Kleist: In the Net of Words], Miinchen: Mathes & Seitz.

Kant. Immanuel. 1997. The Critique of Practical Reason. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Keresztury. Tibor. 1991. Felterpeszben. Arckepek az ujabb magyar irodalombol. [Portraits of Emerging Writers], Budapest: Mag vet 6.

Krasznahorkai. Laszlo. 1992. Az urgaifogoly. [The Captive from Urga], Budapest: Szephalom.

Krasznahorkai. Laszlo. 1993. A Th6seus-61tal6nos. Titkos akadSmiai eldadbsok. [The Theseus-general. Secret Academic Lectures]. Budapest: Szephalom. Krasznahorkai. Laszlo. 1998. Megjbtt Ezsaias. [Isaiah Has Come]. Budapest: Mag vet 6.

Krasznahorkai. Laszlo. 2000. The Melancholy of Resistance. New York: New Directions Books. Krasznahorkai. Laszld. 2004. A torinoi 16. [The Turin Horse].

Krasznahorkai, Liszld. 2013. Legk6s6bb Torindban [At the Latest in T\irin). In Megya vilag. [The World Goes On], 24-26. Budapest: Mag vet 6.

Kristeva, Julia. 1989. Holbein’s Dead Christ. In Black Sun. Depression and Melancholia, 105-138. New York: Columbia University Press.

Last, Angela. 2012. The End of the World - Now Prettier than Ever? http://mutablematter.\\vorld-no\\'-prettier-than-ever. Last accessed 20. 02. 2015.

Mobius, Paul Julius. 1977. Ober den physiologischen Schwachsinn des Weibes. [On the Physiological Idiocy of Women], Miinchen: Matthes & Seitz.

Nietzsche. Friedrich. 2013. On the Use and Abuse of History for Life, Last accessed 20. 02. 2015.

Pilinszkv. Janos. 1997. Apokripha. In The Lost Rider. A Bilingual Anthology, ed. George Szirtes. Budapest: Corvina Books. Online: Last accessed 20. 02. 2015.

Ranciere. Jacques. 2011. Bela Tarr. le temps d apres. [Bela Tarr, the Time After], Paris: Capricci.

Valuska, Liszld. 2008. Azelsd hiba, hogy egy n6zdt feltetelez. [The First Mistake Is to Assume a Spectator. Interview with Bela Tarr]

Acta Universitatis Sapientiae, Film and Media Studies

The Journal of Sapientia Hungarian University of Transylvania

Journal Information


All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 152 147 12
PDF Downloads 73 72 8