Mos geometricus v. Reality: Quantity, Quality, Time and Information in Combat Simulations since the Middle Ages

Open access

Abstract

The non-lethal simulated training of lethal reality, whether it be single combat or war, was historically a question of life and death.

We provide an analytical framework for evaluating historical precedents in fight simulations by focussing on two key questions: What was the philosophy guiding the conception of reality – in particular, did historical practitioners see reality as deterministic, and if not, how did they see it? And how did the simulations deal with the elements of quantity, quality, timing, and information?

The analysis shows that our ancestors’ perception of the reality of fighting chan-ged over time, as their interpretations of reality for the world at large changed. Considerable intellectual effort and ingenuity were invested into attempts to understand reality and formulate corresponding realistic simulations, making these ludic artefacts reflective, sometimes iconic for, and occasionally ahead of their historical-cultural context. Seemingly irrational phenomena, such as the persistence of lethal duelling, had perfectly pragmatic elements.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Agrippa Camillo Trattato di Scientia d’Arme con vn Dialogo di Filosofia (Rome: Antonio Blado 1553)

  • Anleitung zur Darstellung militairischer Manöver mit dem Apparat des Kriegs-Spiels (Berlin: Mittler 1846)

  • Buchel Alex Muskets and Tomahawks (Lingolsheim: Studio Tomahawk 2012)

  • Chandler Jean Henri Codex Guide to the Medieval Baltic (n.p.: Ire Games 2010/2018)

  • Clarke Richard Chain of Command (n.p.: Too Fat Lardies 2013)

  • v. Clausewitz Carl Vom Kriege (Berlin: Dümmler 1832)

  • Hellwig Johann Christian Ludewig Kriegsspiel: ein Versuch die Wahrheit verschiedener Regeln der Kriegskunst in einem unterhaltenden Spiele anschaulich zu machen (Braunschweig: Reichard 1803)

  • de Jomini baron Antoine-Henri Précis de l’Art de la Guerre (Paris: Anselin 1837)

  • de Jomini baron Antoine-Henri Tableau analytique des principales combinaisons de la guerre (St. Petersburg: Bellizard 1830)

  • Kelly Phil Codex Dark Eldar (5th Ed) (Nottingham: Games Workshop 2010)

  • Lorenz de Rada Francisco Nobleza de la espada cuyo esplendor se expressa in tres libros (Books 1 and 2: Madrid: Joseph Rodriguez Escobar 1705/Book 3: Madrid: Diego Martinez Abad 1705)

  • Lorenz de Rada Francisco Respuesta philosophica y mathematica en la qual se satisface à los ar-gumentos y proposiciones que à los professores de la verdadera destreza y philosophia de las armas se han propuesto por un papel expedido sin nombre de autor (Madrid: Diego Martinez Abad 1695)

  • Lopez de Segura Ruy Libro de la Inuencion Liberal y Arte del Juego del Axedrez (n.p.: Andres de Angulo 1561)

  • Monte Pietro Exercitiorum atque artis militaris collectanea (Milan: Scinzenzeler 1509)

  • Pacheco de Narváez Luis Libro de las grandezas de la espada: en que se declaran muchos secretos del que compuso el Commendador Gerónimo de Carrança: en el qual cada uno se podár licionar y deprender a solas sin tener necesidad de maestro que le enseñe. Compuesto por... (Madrid: Herede-ros de Juán Iñiquez de Lequerica en la Imprenta del Licenciado Varez Castro 1600)

  • Praissac de Braissac Sieur du Briefve Methode Pour Resoudre Facilement toute question militaire proposée (Paris: Guillemot & Thiboust 1614)

  • Sánchez de Carranza Jerónimo Libro de Hierónimo de Carança que trata de la philosophia de las armas y de su destreza y de la aggression y defension christiana (Sanlucar de Barameda: “in casa del mesmo autor” 1582)

  • Sandhurst Free Kriegsspiel < http://www.professionalwargaming.co.uk/160604-KriegsspielDSNotes-Mouat-O.pdf > [accessed 26th Nov. 2018]

  • Supplement zu den bisherigen Kriegsspiel-Regeln in: Zeitschrift für Kunst Wissenschaft und Geschichte Vol. 13/4 (1828) 68-105

  • Wells H.G. Little Wars: A Game for Boys from twelve years of age to one hundred and fifty and for that more intelligent sort of girl who likes boys’ games and books (1913) < http://www.gutenberg.org/3/6/9/3691/> [accessed 10th Nov. 2018]

  • Abegglen Christoph M. V. The Influence of Clausewitz on Jomini’s Précis de l’Art de la Guerre King’s College London Diss. 2003 (MA War Studies)

  • Beyerchen Alan D. ‘Clausewitz Nonlinearity and the Unpredictability of War’ in: International Security Vol. 17/3 (Winter 1992) 59-90

  • Bomprezzi Alberto ‘El pensamiento militar como generador de un sistema de combate individual: la verdadera destreza de las armas’ in: Perspectivas y novedades de la historia militar: aproximación global Vol. 1 (Madrid: Publicaciones Defensa 2015) 773-784

  • Burkart Eric ‘The Autograph of an Erudite Martial Artist: A Close Reading of Nuremberg Germanisches Nationalmuseum Hs. 3227a’ in: Jaquet/Verelst/Dawson (Eds.) Fight Books 451-480

  • Chandler Jean ‘A comparative analysis of literary depictions of social violence in two important 16th Century autobiographies from the perspective of the fencing manuals of the Renaissance’ in: Acta Periodica Duellatorum Vol. 3/1 (2015) 101-137

  • Choy Christopher Yi-Han British Wargaming 1870-1914 King’s College London Diss. 2013 (MA War Studies)

  • da Costa Ricardo ‘Las definiciones de las siete artes liberales y mecánicas en la obra de Ramón Llull’ in: Anales del Seminario de Historia de la Filosofía Vol. 23 (2006) 131-164

  • van Creveld Martin Wargames: From Gladiators to Gigabytes (Cambridge: Cambridge UP 2013)

  • Deacon Jacob Henry ‘Prologues Poetry Prose and Portrayals: The Purposes of Fifteenth Century Fight Books According to the Diplomatic Evidence’ Acta Periodica Duellatorum Vol. 4/2 (2016) 69-90

  • Deterding Sebastian ‘Living Room Wars’ in: Nina Hunteman/Matt Payne (Eds.) Joystick Soldiers: The Politics of Play in Military Video Games (London: Routledge 2010) 21-38

  • Dubouclez Olivier ‘L’ “ordre géométrique” et le dispositif argumentatif des Méditations métaphysiques de René Descartes’ in: Revue d’histoire des sciences Vol. 69/2 (Jul-Dec 2016) 311-334

  • Gahlen Gundula ‘Das Duell im bayerischen Offizierskorps im 19. Jahrhundert’ in: Ludwig/Krug-Richter/Schwerhoff (Eds.) Duell 259-273

  • Gassmann Jack Jürg Gassmann Dominique Le Coultre ‘Fighting with the Longsword: Modern-day HEMA Practices’ in: Acta Periodica Duellatorum Vol. 5/2 (2017) 115-133

  • Gayol Víctor ‘La imagen de uno mismo y la simulacion á autorrepresentación de la nobleza hispánica a través de Lorenz de Rada y su Nobleza de la espada’ in: Roberto Domínguez Cáceres/Víctor Gayol (Eds.) El imperio de lo visual : imágenes palabras y representación (Zamora Michoacán: Conayct 2018) 427-460

  • Gevaert Bert ‘The use of the saber in the armies of Napoleon’ in: Acta Periodica Duellatorum Vol. 4/1 (2016) 103-151

  • Greer John M. Academy of the Sword (Highland Village TX: Chivalry Bookshelf 2006)

  • Guerlac Henry ‘Vauban: The Impact of Science on War’ in: Paret Strategy 64-90

  • Higuera Rubio José ‘Las artes del arte: las artes liberales en la evolución del arte luliano’ in: Medievalia Vol. 16 (2013) 71-79

  • v. Hilgers Philipp Kriegsspiele: Eine Geschichte der Ausnahmezustände und Unberechenbarkeiten (München: Wilhelm Fink 2008) = Diss. Berlin 2006

  • v. Hilgers Philipp ‘Eine Anleitung zur Anleitung: Das taktische Kriegsspiel 1812-1824’ in: Board Game Studies Vol. 3 (2000) 59-77

  • Jaquet Daniel Karin Verelst Timothy Dawson (Eds.) Late Medieval and Early Modern Fight Books: Transmission and Tradition of Martial Arts in Europe (14th–17th Centuries) (Leiden: Brill 2016)

  • Jaquet Daniel ‘Fighting in the Fightschools late XVth early XVIth century’ in: Acta Periodica Duellatorum Vol. 1 (2013) 47-66

  • Kinsley D.A. Blades of the British Empire (n.p.: Kinsley 2012)

  • Ludwig Ulrike / Barbara Krug-Richter / Gerd Schwerhoff (Eds.) Das Duell: Ehrenkämpfe vom Mittelalter bis zur Moderne (Konstanz: UVK 2012)

  • Majar János and Zoltán Várhelyi ‘Thibault and Science I: Measure Distance and Proportions in the Circle’ in: Acta Periodica Duellatorum Vol. 2/1 (2014) 67-104

  • Margot Jean-Paul ‘A propósito del “more geometrico” en Descartes y Spinoza’ in: Praxis Filosófica Vol. 29/Jul-Dec (2009) 85-100

  • Meder Stephan Rechtsgeschichte 5th Ed. (Köln/Weimar/Wien: Böhlau 2014)

  • Mondschein Ken Fencing: A Renaissance Treatise by Camillo Agrippa (New York NY: Italica Press 2009)

  • Moya Montes Pablo La esgrima vulgar en los siglos XV y XVI University of Cantabria Thesis 2017 (BA History)

  • Palmer R.R. ‘Frederick the Great Guibert Bülow: From Dynastic to National War’ in: Paret Strategy 91-119.

  • Paret Peter (Ed.) Makers of Modern Strategy: from Machiavelli to the Nuclear Age (Princeton NJ: Princeton UP 1986)

  • Paret Peter ‘Clausewitz’ in: Paret Strategy 186-213

  • Pias Claus Computer Spiel Welten Diss. Leipzig 2000

  • Rubboli Marco and Luca Cesari (Eds.) Filippo Vadi: L’arte cavallaresca del combattimento (Rimini: Il Cerchio 2002)

  • Rubboli Marco and Luca Cesari (Eds.) Anonimo Bolognese: L’arte della spada (Rimini: Il Cerchio 2005)

  • Schmelzer Felix K. E. ‘La esgrima como ciencia matemática: el case curioso de Luis Pacheco de Narváez’ in: Hipogrifo Vol. 4/2 (2016) 339-347

  • Schuurman Paul ‘Models of war 1770-1830: the birth of wargames and the trade-off between realism and simplicity’ in: History of European Ideas Vol. 43/5 (2017) 442-455

  • Shy John ‘Jomini’ in: Paret Strategy 143-185

  • Vego Milan ‘German War Gaming’ in: Naval War College Review Vol. 65/4 (Autumn 2012) 106-147

  • Valle Ortiz Manuel ‘The Destreza Verdadera: A Global Phenomenon’ in: Jaquet/Ver-elst/Dawson (Eds.) Fight Books 324-353

  • Wetzler Sixt ‘Überlegungen zur europäischen Fechtkunst’ in: Ludwig/Krug-Richter/Schwerhoff (Eds.) Duell 61-75

  • Wintjes Jorit ‘Europe’s Earliest Kriegsspiel? Book Seven of Reinhard Graf zu Solms’ Kriegsregierung and the ‘Prehistory’ of Professional War Gaming’ in: British Journal for Military History Vol. 2/1 (November 2015) 15-33

Search
Journal information
Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 181 181 25
PDF Downloads 136 136 29