Limits of Understanding in the Study of Lost Martial Arts

Epistemological Reflections on the Mediality of Historical Records of Technique and the Status of Modern (Re-)Constructions

Open access


The paper is organised around the notion of embodied technique. The recent attempts to formulate scientific methodologies for the reconstruction of medieval fighting techniques based on a study of premodern fight books raise questions about the epistemological status of these (re)constructed techniques developed by modern practitioners of Historical European Martial Arts (HEMA).

Approaching the subject from a perspective of cultural history and martial arts studies, the following questions are discussed: What is technique and how is it related to practice? How is technique acquired and transmitted? How can technique be recorded? And finally, how can historical records of technique be understood, interpreted and converted into practice?

Following Ben Spatz, technique is defined as the knowledge content of specific practices and the semiotic references between practice, technique, and symbols referring to embodied technique are discussed. By looking at the intersubjective communication of subjective fighting skills and relying on the work of Michael Polanyi, the possibility to record the “tacit knowing” of these skills as explicit knowledge is questioned. Given the low knowledge content of the fight books in regard to the execution of the referenced techniques, modern HEMA techniques therefore are to be addressed as purely modern constructions based on modern fighting practices instead of as reconstructions of medieval technique. The discourses in HEMA are also compared to a similar debate in musicology, where the status and the “authenticity” of attempts to recreate the sound of medieval music based on interpretations of early musical notation systems was vividly discussed until the early 2000s.

Fighting techniques are furthermore addressed as elements of complex fighting systems that only exist within a given historical culture of fighting and are transformed when transferred to another societal context.

Leeds, Royal Armouries, ms. I.33.

Nürnberg, Germanisches Nationalmuseum. ms. 3227a.

Anglo, Sydney, The Martial Arts of Renaissance Europe (New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 2000).

Bachmann-Medick, Doris, Cultural Turns: New Orientations in the Study of Culture, De Gruyter Textbook (Berlin, Boston: de Gruyter, 2016).

Barber, Richard, and Juliet Barker, Tournaments: Jousts, Chivalry and Pageants in the Middle Ages (Woodbridge: Boydell, 1989).

Bennett, Alexander, Kendo: Culture of the Sword (Oakland, California: University of California Press, 2015).

Boffa, Sergio, Les manuels de combat (Fechtbücher et Ringbücher), Typologie des sources du Moyen Âge occidental, 87 (Turnhout: Brepols, 2014).

Bowman, Paul, Martial Arts Studies: Disrupting Disciplinary Boundaries, Disruptions (London: Rowman & Littlefield International, 2015).

Burkart, Eric, ‘Body Techniques of Combat: The Depiction of a Personal Fighting System in the Fight Books of Hans Talhofer (1443-1467 CE)’, in Killing and Being Killed. Perspectives on Bodies in Battle, ed. by Jörg Rogge [forthcoming].

Burkart, Eric, ‘Den Kampf anhalten: Bildliche Bewegungsdidaktiken in moderner Ratgeberliteratur und in europäischen Handschriften des 14. und 15. Jahrhunderts’, in »Die Welt anhalten«: Von Bildern, Fotografie und Wissenschaft, ed. by Günter Burkart and Nikolaus Meyer (Weinheim, Basel: Beltz Juventa, 2016), 174–201.

Burkart, Eric, ‘Die Aufzeichnung des Nicht-Sagbaren: Annäherung an die kommunikative Funktion der Bilder in den Fechtbüchern des Hans Talhofer’, in Zweikämpfer: Fechtmeister – Kämpen – Samurai, ed. by Uwe Israel and Christian Jaser, Das Mittelalter. Perspektiven mediävistischer Forschung, 19.2 (Berlin: De Gruyter, 2014), 253–301.

Burkart, Eric, ‘The Autograph of an Erudite Martial Artist: A Close Reading of Nuremberg, Germanisches Nationalmuseum, Hs. 3227a’, in Late Medieval and Early Modern Fight Books: Transmission and Tradition of Martial Arts in Europe (14th-17th Centuries), ed. by Daniel Jaquet, Karin Verelst and Timothy Dawson, History of Warfare, 112 (Leiden, Boston: Brill, 2016), 451–80.

Burkart, Eric, ‘Zweikampfpraktiken zwischen sozialer Normierung, medialer Präsentation und wissenschaftlicher Einordnung’, in Agon und Distinktion: Soziale Räume des Zweikampfs zwischen Mittelalter und Neuzeit, ed. by Uwe Israel and Christian Jaser, Geschichte, Forschung und Wissenschaft, 47 (Berlin, Münster: LIT, 2016), 4–14.

Burke, Peter, What is Cultural History? (Cambridge, U.K., Malden, MA: Polity Press, 2004).

Butt, John, Playing with History: The Historical Approach to Musical Performance, Musical Performance and Reception (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2004).

Daniel, Ute, Kompendium Kulturgeschichte: Theorien, Praxis, Schlüsselwörter, 5th edn (Frankfurt a. M.: Suhrkamp, 2006).

Forgeng, Jeffrey L., The Medieval Art of Swordsmanship: A Facsimile & Translation of Europe’s Oldest Personal Combat Treatise, Royal Armouries MS I.33 (Union City: Chivalry Bookshelf, 2003).

Frank, Adam D., Taijiquan and the Search for the Little Old Chinese Man: Understanding Identity Through Martial Arts (New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2006).

Grondin, Jean, ‘The Hermeneutical Circle’, in The Blackwell Companion to Hermeneutics, ed. by Niall Keane and Chris Lawn, Blackwell Companions to Philosophy, 60 (Chichester, West Sussex, UK, Malden, MA: John Wiley & Sons, 2016), 299–305.

Huck, Oliver, ‘Meistererzählungen und Meistergesänge: Geschichte und Aufführung der Musik des Mittelalters’, in Meistererzählungen vom Mittelalter: Epochenimaginationen und Verlaufsmuster in der Praxis mediävistischer Disziplinen, ed. by Frank Rexroth, Historische Zeitschrift – Beiheft, N.F., 46 (München: Oldenbourg, 2007), 69–85.

Irving, David R. M., ‘Historicizing Performance Practice: Early Music through Time and Space’, Early Music, 41.1 (2013), 83–85.

Israel, Uwe, and Christian Jaser, eds, Agon und Distinktion: Soziale Räume des Zweikampfs zwischen Mittelalter und Neuzeit, Geschichte, Forschung und Wissenschaft, 47 (Berlin, Münster: LIT, 2016).

Jaquet, Daniel, and Claus F. Sørensen, ‘Historical European Martial Art – A Crossroad between Academic Research, Martial Heritage Re-creation and Martial Sport Practices’, Acta Periodica Duellatorum, 1 (2015), 5–35.

Jaquet, Daniel, and Nicolas Baptiste, eds, Expérimenter le maniement des armes à la fin du Moyen Age: Experimente zur Waffenhandhabung im Spätmittelalter, Itinera, 39 (Basel: Schwabe, 2016).

Jaquet, Daniel and others, ‘Range of Motion and Energy Cost of Locomotion of the Late Medieval Armoured Fighter: A Proof of Concept of Confronting the Medieval Technical Literature with Modern Movement Analysis’, Historical Methods: A Journal of Quantitative and Interdisciplinary History, 49.3 (2016), 169–86.

Jaquet, Daniel, Combattre en armure à la fin du Moyen Âge et au début de la Renaissance d'après les livres du combat (Thèse de doctorat, Université de Genève, 2013).

Jaquet, Daniel, ‘Entre jeux de mains et jeux de mots: faire l'expérience ou expérimenter les gestes d'après les textes techniques. Reproduire ou répliquer les objets…’, in Expérimenter le maniement des armes à la fin du Moyen Age: Experimente zur Waffenhandhabung im Spätmittelalter, ed. by Daniel Jaquet and Nicolas Baptiste, Itinera, 39 (Basel: Schwabe, 2016), 11–18.

Jaquet, Daniel, ‘Experimenting Historical European Martial Arts, a Scientific Method?’, in Late Medieval and Early Modern Fight Books: Transmission and Tradition of Martial Arts in Europe (14th-17th Centuries), ed. by Daniel Jaquet, Karin Verelst and Timothy Dawson, History of Warfare, 112 (Leiden, Boston: Brill, 2016), 216–43.

Jaquet, Daniel, Karin Verelst, and Timothy Dawson, eds, Late Medieval and Early Modern Fight Books: Transmission and Tradition of Martial Arts in Europe (14th-17th Centuries), History of Warfare, 112 (Leiden, Boston: Brill, 2016).

Jaquet, Daniel, ed., L'art chevaleresque du combat: Le maniement des armes à travers les livres de combat (XIVe-XVIe siècles) (Neuchâtel: Éditions Alphil-Presses universitaires suisses, 2013).

Jinnah, Naila, ‘Swimming, United States’, in Sports around the World: History, Culture, and Practice, ed. by Charles Parrish and John Nauright (Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, 2012), vol. 3, 400–05.

Judkins, Benjamin N., ‘The Seven Forms of Lightsaber Combat: Hyper-reality and the Invention of the Martial Arts’, Martial Arts Studies, 2 (2016), 6–22.

Keen, Maurice H., Chivalry (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1984).

Kreutziger-Herr, Annette, Ein Traum vom Mittelalter: Die Wiederentdeckung mittelalterlicher Musik in der Neuzeit (Köln: Böhlau, 2003).

Kreutziger-Herr, Annette, ‘Imagining Medieval Music: A Short History’, in Correspondences: Medievalism in Scholarship and the Arts, ed. by Thomas A. Shippey, Studies in Medievalism, 14 (Cambridge: Brewer, 2005), 81–109.

Landwehr, Achim, Kulturgeschichte, (Stuttgart: Ulmer, 2009).

Leech-Wilkinson, Daniel, The Modern Invention of Medieval Music: Scholarship, Ideology, Performance, Musical Performance and Reception (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002).

Leng, Rainer, Fecht- und Ringbücher, Katalog der deutschsprachigen illustrierten Handschriften des Mittelalters, Bd. 4/2, Lfg. 1/2, Stoffgr. 38 (München: C.H. Beck, 2008).

Lorge, Peter A., Chinese Martial Arts: From Antiquity to the Twenty-first Century (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2012).

Ludwig, Ulrike, Barbara Krug-Richter, and Gerd Schwerhoff, eds, Das Duell: Ehrenkämpfe vom Mittelalter bis zur Moderne, Konflikte und Kultur – Historische Perspektiven, 23 (Konstanz: UVK, 2012).

Ludwig, Ulrike, Das Duell im Alten Reich: Transformation und Variationen frühneuzeitlicher Ehrkonflikte, Historische Forschungen, 112 (Berlin: Duncker & Humblot, 2016).

Matthews, Christopher R., and Alex Channon, ‘Understanding Sports Violence: Revisiting Foundational Explorations’, Sport in Society (2016), 1–17.

Mauss, Marcel, ‘Body Techniques’, in Sociology and Psychology: Essays (London: Routledge and K. Paul, 1979), 95–123.

Mauss, Marcel, ‘Les techniques du corps’, Journal de Psychologie, 32.3-4 (1935), 271–93.

Polanyi, Michael, Personal Knowledge: Towards a Post-Critical Philosophy (Chicago, 1958).

Price, Brian R., ‘A Proposed Methodology for the Validation of Historical European Martial Arts’, Initial. A Review of Medieval Studies, 3 (2015), 57–70.

Reckwitz, Andreas, Die Transformation der Kulturtheorien: Zur Entwicklung eines Theorieprogramms, 3rd edn (Weilerswist: Velbrück, 2012).

Riemer, Nick, Introducing Semantics, Cambridge Introductions to Language and Linguistics (Cambridge, New York: Cambridge University Press, 2010).

Spatz, Ben, What a Body Can Do: Technique as Knowledge, Practice as Research (Abingdon: Routledge, 2015).

Taruskin, Richard, Text and Act: Essays on Music and Performance (Oxford, New York: Oxford University Press, 1995).

Tlusty, Ann, The Martial Ethic in Early Modern Germany: Civic Duty and the Right of Arms, Early Modern History: Society and Culture (Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, 2011).

Wacquant, Loïc J. D., Body & Soul: Notebooks of an Apprentice Boxer (Oxford, New York: Oxford University Press, 2004).

Wetzler, Sixt, ‘Martial Arts Studies as Kulturwissenschaft: A Possible Theoretical Framework’, Martial Arts Studies, 1 (2015), 20–33.

Wetzler, Sixt, ‘Vergleichende Kampfkunstwissenschaft als historisch-kulturwissenschaftliche Disziplin: Mögliche Gegenstände, nötige Quellen, anzuwendende Methoden’, in Menschen im Zweikampf - Kampfkunst und Kampfsport in Lehre und Forschung 2013: Jahrestagung der dvs-Kommission “Kampfkunst und Kampfsport” vom 7.-9. November 2013 in Erlangen, ed. by Sebastian Liebl and Peter Kuhn, Schriften der Deutschen Vereinigung für Sportwissenschaft, 236 (Hamburg: Feldhaus, 2014), 57–66.

Zarrilli, Phillip B., When the Body Becomes All Eyes: Paradigms, Discourses and Practices of Power in Kalarippayattu, a South Indian Martial Art (Delhi: Oxford University Press, 1998).

Journal Information


All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 181 181 77
PDF Downloads 50 50 22