Historical European Martial Art a crossroad between academic research, martial heritage re-creation and martial sport practices

Open access

Abstract

Historical European martial arts (HEMA) have to be considered an important part of our common European cultural heritage. Studies within this field of research have the potential to enlighten the puzzle posed by past societies, for example in the field of history, history of science and technology, or fields related to material culture.

The military aspects of history are still to be considered among the most popular themes of modern times, generating huge public interest. In the last few decades, serious HEMA study groups have started appearing all over the world – focusing on re-creating a lost martial art. The terminology “Historical European Martial Arts” therefore also refers to modem-day practices of ancient martial arts. Many of these groups focus on a “hands-on” approach, thus bringing practical experience and observation to enlighten their interpretation of the source material. However, most of the time, they do not establish inquiries based on scientific research, nor do they follow methodologies that allow for a critical analysis of the findings or observations.

This paper will therefore propose and discuss, ideas on how to bridge the gap between enthusiasts and scholars; since their embodied knowledge, acquired by practice, is of tremendous value for scientific inquiries and scientific experimentation. It will also address HEMA practices in the context of modern day acceptance of experimental (or experiential) processes and their value for research purposes and restoration of an historical praxis. The goal is therefore to sketch relevant methodological and theoretical elements, suitable for a multidisciplinary approach, to HEMA, where the “H” for “historical” matters.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Agnew Vanessa ‘History’s Affective Turn: Historical Reenactment and Its Work in the Present’ Rethinking History 11 (2007) 299–312.

  • Anglo Sydney The Martial Arts of Renaissance Europe (New Haven: Yale University Press 2000).

  • Archer Neil ‘Virtual Poaching and Altered Space: Reading Parkour in French Visual Culture’ Modern & Contemporary France 18 (2010) pp. 93–107.

  • Askew Graham N. Frederico Formenti and Alberto E. Minetti ‘Limitations Imposed by Wearing Armour on Medieval Soldier’s Locomotor Performance’ Proceedings of the Royal Society: Biological Sciences (Proc.R.Soc.B) 279 (2012) 640–44.

  • Barber Malcolm and Barker Juliet Tournaments: jousts chivalry and pageants in the Middle Ages (Woodbridge: Boydell 1989).

  • Bauer Matthias Johannes ed. Langes Schwert und Schweinespiess: Die anonyme Fechthandschrift aus den verschütteten Beständen des Historischen Archivs der Stadt Köln (Graz: Akademische Druck- u. Verlagsanstalt 2009).

  • Boffa Sergio Les Manuels de Combat (Fechtbücher’ et Ringbücher) Typologie des sources du Moyen Âge occidental fasc. 87 (Turnhout: Brepols 2014).

  • Bruhn-Hofmeyer Ada ‘From Medieval Sword to Renaissance Rapier’ Gladius 2 (1963) 5–68.

  • Burkart Eric Die Aufzeichnung des Nicht-Sagbaren. Annäherung an die kommunikative Funktion der Bilder in den Fechtbüchern des Hans Talhofer’ Das Mittelalter 19 (2014) 253–301.

  • Burkart Eric The Autograph of an Erudite Martial Artist: A Close Reading of Nuremberg Germanisches Nationalmuseum Hs. 3227a’ in The Late Medieval and early Modern Fightbooks ed. by Daniel Jaquet Timothy Dawson Karin Verelst (Leyden: Brill forthcoming).

  • Cederlöf Olle Våbnenes Historie (Stockholm: Bokforlaget Prisma 1965).

  • Cognot Fabrice L’armement Médiéval: Les armes blanches dans les collections bourguignonnes. Xe–XVe siècles (unpubl. diss. University of Paris 1 2013) <http://www.theses.fr/2013PA010609> [accessed 30 December 2014].

  • Cooper Christine Forensisch-anthropologische und traumatologische Untersuchungen an den menschlichen Skeletten aus der spätmittelalterlichen Schlacht von Dornach (1499 n. Chr.) (unpubl. diss. Universität Mainz 2010).

  • Creutz Kristina Tension and tradition : a study of late iron age spearheads around the Baltic Sea (unpubl. diss. University of Stockholm 2003).

  • Dupuis Olivier ‘A Fifteenth-Century Fencing Tournament in Strasbourg’ Acta Periodica Duellatorum 1 (2013) 67–79.

  • Fillery-Travis Ruth ‘Learning and teaching in experimental archaeology’ paper presented at the 6th Experimental Archaeology Conference York January 7 2012.

  • Gourdon Olivier ‘La pratique de la coupe : un apport à l’étude et à l’interprétation des arts martiaux historiques européen’ in Expérimenter le maniement des armes à la fin du Moyen Âge ed. by Daniel Jaquet and Nicolas Baptiste (Revue d’Histoire Suisse forthcoming 2015).

  • Hans Czynner Würgegriff und Mordschlag: Die Fecht- und Ringlehre des Hans Czynner (1538): Universitätsbibliothek Graz Ms. 963 ed. by Ute Bergner and Johannes Giessauf (Graz: Akademische Druck- u. Verlagsanstalt 2006).

  • Harding Anthony F. ‘Sword Shields and Scholars: Bronze Age Warfare Past and Present’ in Experiment and design: archaeological studies in honour of John Coles ed. by Anthony F. Harding (Oxford; Oakville: Oxbow Books 1999) pp. 87–93.

  • Jaquet Daniel ‘Personne ne laisse volontiers son honneur être tranché’ Les combats singuliers ‘judiciaires’ d’après les livres de combat’ in Armes et jeux militaires dans I’imaginaire (Xlle-XVe siècles) ed. by Catlina Girbea (Paris : Classiques Garnier forthcoming).

  • Jaquet Daniel ‘Experimenting Historical European Martial Arts a Scientific Method?’ in Late Medieval and Early Modern Fight Books. A Handbook ed. by Daniel Jaquet Karin Verelst and Timothy Dawson History of Warfare (Leiden: Brill in preparation).

  • Jaquet Daniel ‘Fighting in the Fightschools Late 15c. Early 16c’ Acta Periodica Duellatorum 1 (2013) 47–66.

  • Jaquet Daniel ‘Sword and pen: Sword and pen. Historical European Martial Arts studies the communities and the academic world’ Acta Periodica Duellatorum 4 [in preparation].

  • Jaquet Daniel Alice Bonnefoy-Mazure Stéphane Armand Caecilia Charbonnier Jean-Luc Ziltener and Bengt Kayser ‘Range of Motion and Energy Cost of Locomotion of the Late Medieval Armoured Fighter: Confronting the Medieval Technical Literature with Modern Movement Analysis’ Plos One (forthcoming).

  • Jaquet Daniel and Walczak Bartlomiej ‘Lignitzer Hundsfeld or Lew? The question of autorship of popular Medieval fighting instructions’ Acta Periodica Duellatorum 2 (2014) 105–48.

  • Jaquet Daniel Le geste le mot et l’image: La mise par écrit de l’art du combat à la fin du Moyen Âge De Diversis Artibus (Turnhout: Brepols forthcoming).

  • Jeffrey Daniel ‘Experiential and Experimental Archaeology with Examples in Iron Processing’ Institute for Archaeo-Metallurgical Studies newsletter.; 24 (2004) 13–16.

  • Kellett Rachel E. Single Combat and Warfare in German Literature of the High Middle Ages: Stricker’s ‘Karl Der Große’ and Daniel von dem blühenden Tal’ MHRA 72 (Leeds: Maney 2008).

  • Lammers-Keijsers Yvonne M. J. ‘Scientific Experiments: A Possibility? Presenting a General Cyclical Script for Experiments in Archaeology’ euroREA 2 (2005) 18–24.

  • Leoni Tomasso. The art of Dueling Salvator Fabri’s rapier fencing treatise of 1606 (Union City: Chivalry Bookshelf 2005).

  • Lieberman Daniel The Story of the Human Body: Evolution Health and Disease (New York: Pantheon Books 2013).

  • Ludwig Ulrike Barbara Krug-Richter and Gerd Schwerhoff eds. Das Duell–Ehrenkämpfe vom Mittelalter bis zur Moderne (Konstanz: UVK Verlagsgesellschaft 2012).

  • Mallinckrodt Rebekka von ed. Bewegtes Leben. Körpertechniken in Der Frühen Neuzeit Ausstellungskataloge Der Herzog-August-Bibliothek (Wolfenbüttel: Herzog-August-Bibliothek 2008).

  • Mele Gregory and Allen Nicole. The Book of Historic Fashion : A Newcomer’s guide to Medieval Clothing (1300–1450) (Wheaton: Freelance Academy Press 2014).

  • Miller Heather Margaret-Louise Archaeological Approaches to Technology (Amsterdam; Boston: Elsevier 2007).

  • Molloy Barry ed. The Cutting Edge: Studies in Ancient and Medieval Combat (Stroud: Tempus 2007).

  • Oakeshott Ewart European Weapons and Armour from the Renaissance to the Industrial Revolution (London: Lutterworth 1978).

  • Oakeshott Ewart The Archaeology of Weapons. Arms and Armour from Prehistory to the Age of Chivalry (Woodbrige/Suffolk: Boyd ell 1960).

  • Outram Alan K. ‘Introduction to Experimental Archaeology’ World Archaeology 40 (2008) 1–6.

  • Peatfield Alan ‘Reliving Greek Personal Combat – Boxing and Pancration’ in The Cutting Edge: Studies in Ancient and Medieval Combat ed. by Barry Molloy (Stroud: Tempus 2007) pp. 20–33.

  • Pendragon Joshua ‘Masters Fencers and Collectors: George Silver’s Paradoxes of Defence and the Lost Fencing Library of Arsène Vigeant’ in The Noble Art of the Sword: Fashion and Fencing in Renaissance Europe 1520–1630 ed. by Tobias Capwell (London: Paul Holberton Publishing 2012) pp. 237–44.

  • Poliakoff Michael B. Combat Sports in the Ancient World. Competition Violence and Culture (New Haven; London: Yale University Press 1987).

  • Porter Roy ‘History of the Body Reconsidered’ in New perspectives on historical writing ed. by Peter Burke (Polity: Cambridge Univ. Press 2001) pp. 232–60.

  • Reynolds Peter J. ‘The Nature of Experiment in Archaeology’ in Experiment and design: archaeological studies in honour of John Coles ed. by Anthony F. Harding (Oxford; Oakville: Oxbow Books 1999) pp. 156–62.

  • Sørensen Claus : ‘Et semiddelalderligt tysk fægtemesterhåndskrift på Det Kongelige Bibliotek. Ms. 290 2º’ in Fund og Forskning i Det Kongelige Biblioteks Samling 50/1 (2011) 159–189.

  • Tanaka Shogo ‘The Notion of Embodied Knowledge’ in: Theoretical Psychology: Global Transformations and Challenges ed. by Paul Stenner John Cromby Johanna Motzkau Jeffrey Yen and Haoscheng Ye (Ontario: Captus University Press 2011) pp. 149–57.

  • Teyssier Éric and Lopez Brice Gladiateurs – Des sources à l’expérimentation (Paris: Éditions Errance 2005).

  • Tlusty B. Ann The Martial Ethic in Early Modern Germany: Civic Duty and the Right of Arms (Basingstoke: Palgrave 2011).

  • Tryggedsson Matthias ’Middelalderens sværdbrug – eksperimentelle forsøg’ in Anno Domini (Aarhus: Middelalderarkæologisk Forum forthcoming 2015).

  • Tuaillon Demésy Audrey La Re-création du passé: enjeux identitaires et mémoriels Approche socio-anthropologique de I’histoire vivante médiévale (Besançon: Presses Univ. Franche-Comté 2013).

  • Walton Steven A. ‘Proto-Scientific Revolution or Cookbook Science? Early Gunnery Manuals in the Craft Treatise Tradition’ in Craft treatises and handbooks. The dissemination of technical knowledge in the Middle Ages ed. by Ricardo Cordoba De Diversis Artibus 91 (Turnhout: Brepols 2013) p. 221–236.

  • Wanke Tilman ‘Anderthalbhänder – Zweihänder – Langes Schwert zu Klassifikation Nutzung und Bezeichnung der großen Schwerter des Spätmittelalters und der Frühen Neuzeit’ Zeitschrift für historische Waffen- und Kostümkunde 51/2 (2009).

  • Warzecha Roland ‘Mit Hieb Und Stich Über Die Handhabung von Schwertem.’ in Mittelalterliche Kampfesweisen Bd. 3: Scheibendolch und Stechschild ed. by André Schulze (Mainz: Ph. von Zabem 2007) pp. 55–61.

  • Welle Rainer... vnd mit der rechten faust ein mordstuck. Baumanns Fecht- und Ringkampfhandschrift: Edition und Kommentierung der anonymen Fecht- und Ringkampfhandschrft (München: Herbert Utz 2014).

  • Welle Rainer ‘...und wisse das alle hobischeit kompt von deme Ringen’: Der Ringkampf als adelige Kunstim 15. und 16. Jahrhundert: Eine sozialhistorische und bewegungsbiographische Interpretation aufgrund der Handschriftlichen und gedruckten Ringlehren des Spätmittelalters (Pfaffenweiler: Centaurus-Verlagsgesellschaft 1993).

  • Wetzler Sixt ‘Überlegungen Zur Europäischen Fechtkunst’ in Das Duell — Ehrenkämpfe vom Mittelalter bis zur Moderne ed. by Ulrike Ludwig Barbara Krug-Richter and Gerd Schwerhoff (Konstanz: UVK Verlagsgesellschaft 2012) pp. 60–75.

  • Wetzler Sixt ‘Vergleichende Kampfkunstwissenschaft Als Historischkulturwissenschaftliche Disziplin – Mögliche Gegenstände Nötige Quellen Anzuwendende Methoden’ in Menschen im Zweikampf – Kampfkunst und Kampfsport in Forschung und Lehre ed. by Sebastian Liebl and Peter Kuhn DVS 236 (Hamburg : Czwalina 2014) pp. 57–66.

  • Zabinski Grzegorz The Longsword Teachings of Master Liechtenauer: The early sixteenth century swordsmanship comments in the 'Goliath' manuscript (Torun: Wydawnictwo Adam Marsz 2010).

Search
Journal information
Cited By
Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 884 477 15
PDF Downloads 351 206 13