Finite Element Analysis Of Influence Of Flank Wear Evolution On Forces In Orthogonal Cutting Of 42CrMo4 Steel

Open access


This paper presents analysis of flank wear influence on forces in orthogonal turning of 42CrMo4 steel and evaluates capacity of finite element model to provide such force values. Data about magnitude of feed and cutting force were obtained from measurements with force tensiometer in experimental test as well as from finite element analysis of chip formation process in ABAQUS/Explicit software. For studies an insert with complex rake face was selected and flank wear was simulated by grinding operation on its flank face. The aim of grinding inset surface was to obtain even flat wear along cutting edge, which after the measurement could be modeled with CAD program and applied in FE analysis for selected range of wear width. By comparing both sets of force values as function of flank wear in given cutting conditions FEA model was validated and it was established that it can be applied to analyze other physical aspects of machining. Force analysis found that progression of wear causes increase in cutting force magnitude and steep boost to feed force magnitude. Analysis of Fc/Ff force ratio revealed that flank wear has significant impact on resultant force in orthogonal cutting and magnitude of this force components in cutting and feed direction. Surge in force values can result in transfer of substantial loads to machine-tool interface.


[1] Merchant M.E., Mechanics of the metal cutting process. I.Orthogonal cutting and a type 2 chip, Journal of AppliedPhysics,16 (1945). [2] Oxley P.L.B., Mechanics of machining: an analytical approachto assessing machinability. New York: Wiley, 1989. [3] Alcaraz J. L, Lorenzo I.,Thermomechanical Analysis of a ChipMachining Process, ABAQUS Users’ Conference, Munich,Germany,(2003). [4] Cai Y.J., Dou T., Duan C.Z., Li, Y.,Finite Element Simulationand Experiment of Chip Formation Process during High SpeedMachining of AISI 1045 Hardened Steel, International Journalof Recent Trends in Engineering, 5 (2009). [5] Díaz J., Miguélez H.,Surface integrity in finishing turning ofInconel 718, Proceedings of the 5th ManufacturingEngineering Society International Conference, Saragossa,Spain,(2013). [6] Mashayekhi M., Salimi M., Vaziri M.R.,Evaluation of ChipFormation Simulation Models for Material Separation in thePresence of Damage Models, Simulation Modelling Practiceand Theory, 19 (2011) 718-733. [7] Pantale O.,2D and 3D numerical models of metal cutting withdamage effects, Computer Methods In Applied Mechanics AndEngineering, 193 (2004) 4383-4399. [8] Awang M. B., Hairudin M.,Thermo mechanical Modeling ofTurning Process using an Arbitrary Lagrangian-EulerianMethod, National Postgraduate Conference (NPC),TanjungTokong, Malaysia,(2011). [9] Özel T., Zeren E.,Finite Element Method Simulation ofMachining of AISI 1045 Steel With A Round Edge Cutting Tool,Proc. 8th CIRP Int. Workshop on Modeling of MachiningOperations, Chemnitz, Germany,(2005), 533-541. [10] Razfar M.R., Sadeghinia H., Takabi J.,Simulation ofOrthogonal Cutting Process Using Arbitrary Lagrangian-Eulerian Approach, 3rd WSEAS International Conference OnApplied And Theoretical Mechanics, Tenerife, Spain,(2007). [11] Arrazola P. J., Meslin F., Hammann J.C., Maitre F.,NumericalCutting Modeling with Abaqus/Explicit 6.1, ABAQUS Users'Conference Newport, Rhode Island, USA,(2002). [12] Fleisher J., Schermann T.,Aspects of the simulation of acutting process with ABAQUS/Explicit including theinteraction between the cutting process and the dynamicbehavior of the machine tool, 9th CIRP International Workshopon Modeling of Machining Operations, Bled, Slovenia,(2006). [13] Pantale O.,An ALE Three-dimensional Model of Orthogonaland Oblique Metal Cutting Processes, International Journal ofForming Processes, 9 (1998), 371-388. [14] Usui E., Kitagawwa T., Maekawa K., Shirakashi T., AnalyticalPrediction of Flank Wear of Carbide Tools in Turning PlainCarbon Steels, Bull. Japan Soc. of Prec. Engg, 23 (1989), 263-269. [15] Xie L.J., Schmidt J., Schmidt C., Biesinger F.,2D FEM Estimateof Tool Wear in Turning Operations, WEAR ELSEVIER, 258(2005), 1479-1490. [16] Yen Y. C., Sohner J., Lilly B., Altan T., Estimation of Tool Wearof Carbide Tool in Orthogonal Cutting Using FEM Simulation,Machining Science and Technology, 6 (2002), 467-486. [17] Yue C.X., Liu X.L., Pen H.M., Hu J.S., Zhao X.F.,2D FEMEstimate of Tool Wear in Hard Cutting Operation: Extractive ofInterrelated Parameters and Tool Wear Simulation Result,Advanced Materials Reaserch, 69 (2009),316-321. [18] Koren Y., Ko T.R.,A Comprehensive Wear Model For CuttingTools, Technical Raport No. UM-MEAM-88-5 (1988). [19] Docobu F., Arrazola P. J., Riviere-Lorphevre E., FilippiE.,Finite element prediction of the tool wear influence inTi6Al4V machining, 15th CIRP Conference on Modelling ofMachining Operations, Karlsruhe, Germany, (2015) [20] Kohir V., Dundur S. T.,Finite Element Simulation to study theeffect of flank wear land inclination on Cutting forces andtemperature distribution in orthogonal machining, Journal ofEngineering and Fundamentals, 1 (2014), 30-42. [21] Chen L., El-Wardany T.I., Harris W.C., Modelling the Effects ofFlank Wear Land and Chip Formation on Residual Stresses,CIRP Annals - Manufacturing Technology. 53 (2004), 95-98. [22] Dubiec J., Neslusan M., Micietova A., Cillikova M.,Influenceof Flank Wear on Decomposition of Cutting Forces in Turning,MM Science Journal, 17 (2013). [23] DASSAULT SYSTÈMES, Abaqus Analysis User's Manual,available at: [24] Zorev N.N., Inter-relationship between shear processesoccurringalong tool face and shear plane in metal cutting,International Research In Production Engineering, (1963), 42-49. [25] Ai Y.J., Dou T., Duan C.Z., Li, Y.,Finite Element Simulation andExperiment of Chip Formation Process during High SpeedMachining of AISI 1045 Hardened Steel, International Journalof Recent Trends in Engineering, 5 (2009). [26] Bell T., Srivastava A. K., Zhang X.,Investigations on turningTi-6Al-4V titanium alloy using super-finished tool edgegeometry generated by micro-machining process (MMP), PennState College of Engineering, (2011). [27] Cook W. H., Johnson G. R.,A constitutive model and data formetals subjected to large strains, high strain rates and hightemperatures, Proceedings of the 7th International Symposiumon Ballistics, Haga, Switzerland(1983). [28] Ulutan D., Özel T., Determination of tool friction in presenceof flank wear and stress distribution based validation usingfinite element simulations in machining of titanium and nickelbased alloys, Journal of Materials Processing Technology, 213(2013). [29] Özel T., The influence of friction models on finite elementsimulations of machining, International Journal of MachineTools & Manufacture, 46 (2006).

Journal Information


All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 46 46 36
PDF Downloads 9 9 6