Of “You” and “Thou,” Lips and Pilgrims in the Translation of Romeo and Juliet’s “Shared Sonnet”: A Hands-On Perspective

Anca Ignat 1  and Alexandru M. Călin 2
  • 1 Lucian Blaga University of Sibiu, , Romania
  • 2 University of Bucharest, , Romania

Abstract

It is not a recent discovery in the field of language history that the address pronouns thou and you were not, in Shakespeare’s time, used indiscriminately. If the speaker did have a choice between the two forms, that choice was by no means random, idiosyncratic or arbitrary, but always dictated by the social, relational or attitudinal context of a speech act. Nonetheless, all 20th-century Romanian translations of Romeo and Juliet (and of other Shakespearean plays) – from Haralamb Leca’s rather loose rendering (1907) to Ștefan-Octavian Iosif’s and to Virgil Teodorescu’s more refined versions (1940 and 1984, respectively) – seem to ignore the difference in associative meaning between the two forms, which is sometimes essential for a correct assessment of the relationships between characters. The latest Romanian translation of the play, which we have jointly submitted for publication within the Shakespeare for the Third Millennium project (William Shakespeare. Opere XIII, 2018) acknowledges the importance of the various associative meanings that the two pronouns carry and strives to restore these meanings to the text, though not without difficulty, given the rather restrictive form of the original, i.e. iambic pentameters, often with strict rhyme schemes. Thus, focusing on the well-known “shared sonnet” as one of the most relevant instances of pronoun alternation in the play, our paper discusses the uses of you and thou in Early Modern English and sets out to assess how much is lost in 20th-century translations, to show how our own translation restores the associative meanings of the two pronominal forms and finally to exemplify how we managed to overcome translation difficulties entailed by the metrical and stylistic demands of the text.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Brown, R., and A. Gilman. “The Pronouns of Power and Solidarity.” Style in Language. Ed. T. A. Sebeok. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press, 1960. 253-276.

  • Belsey, Catherine. Romeo and Juliet: Language and Writing. London: Bloomsbury Arden Shakespeare, 2014.

  • Crystal, David, and Ben Crystal. Shakespeare’s Words: A Glossary and Language Companion. London: Penguin, 2002.

  • Ford, Boris, ed. The New Pelican Guide to English Literature. Vol. 2: The Age of Shakespeare. London: Penguin, 1982.

  • Leech, Geoffrey. Semantics: The Study of Meaning. 2nd ed. London: Penguin, 1990.

  • Shakespeare, William. Romeo and Juliet. Ed. Rene Weis. London: Bloomsbury Arden Shakespeare, 2012.

  • Shakespeare, William. Romeo et Juliette. Trans. François-Victor Hugo. 1868. Wikisource, la bibliotheque libre. Web. 28 Nov. 2018.

  • Shakespeare, William. Romeo și Julieta. Trans. Anca Ignat and Alexandru M. Călin. William Shakespeare: Opere XIII. Ed. George Volceanov. Bucharest: TracusArte, 2018. 50-178.

  • Shakespeare, William. Romeo și Julieta. Trans. Ștefan-Octavian Iosif. Bilingual ed. Craiova: Fortuna, 2006.

  • Shakespeare, William. Romeo și Julieta. Trans. Haralamb G. Leca. Ed. G. Săndulescu and Lidia Vianu. Bucharest: Contemporary Literature P, 2016.

  • Shakespeare, William. Romeo și Julieta. Shakespeare: Opere Complete. Vol. 3. Trans. Virgil Teodorescu. Ed. Leon D. Levițchi. Bucharest: Univers, 1984. 9-107.

  • Walker, Terry. Thou and You in Early Modern English Dialogues: Trials, Depositions, and Drama Comedy. Amsterdam: Benjamins, 2007.

OPEN ACCESS

Journal + Issues

Search