Electronic Waste in China, Japan, and Vietnam: A Comparative Analysis of Waste Management Strategies

Open access

Abstract

This paper comparatively analyses the e-waste sector in China, Japan, and Vietnam by examining progress towards the international best practice model of Integrated Sustainable Waste Management (ISWM) within each country. Through three distinct, yet interdependent dimensions of ISWM (stakeholders, waste system elements, and sustainability aspects), similarities and differences between the three East Asian countries are identified. The analysis shows that the e-waste management approaches differ substantially. The Vietnamese e-waste management approach is least consistent with the ISWM framework, while Japan complies the most with the ideals of the model and Chinese progress towards ISWM is mostly located between the two countries. However, a substantial proportion of Japanese e-waste is exported to developing countries in an uncontrolled manner. The analysis further suggests that the state of development and national characteristics have a significant impact on how the three countries approach e-waste management. In particular, the central role of the informal e-waste sectors in China and Vietnam poses a challenge to the establishment of an effective integrated sustainable e-waste management system. In light of the transnational flow of e-waste in the region, only joint actions will lead to long-term solutions to the increasing threat of e-waste to the environment and human health.

Aizawa, Hirofumi, Hideto Yoshida, and Shin-ichi Sakai. “Current Results and Future Perspectives for Japanese Recycling of Home Electrical Appliances.” In Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 52, 2008, pp. 1399-1410

Anschütz, Justine, Jeroen IJgosse, and Anne Scheinberg. Putting Integrated Sustainable Waste Management into Practice: Using the ISWM Assessment Methodology. Gouda: WASTE, 2004

Baldé, Cornelis Peter, Feng Wang, Ruediger Kuehr, and Jaco Huisman. The Global E-waste Monitor - 2014. Bonn: United Nations University, IAS - SCYCLE, 2015

Barbour, Emily C. Issues in International Trade Law: Restricting Exports of Electronic Waste. Washington, D.C.: Congressional Research Service, 2012

Bāsāiěr gōngyuē yàtàiqū yù zhōngxīn 巴塞尔公约亚太区域中心 [BCRC China]. “Bāsāiěr gōngyuē yàtàiqū yù zhōngxīn jiǎnjiè” 巴塞尔公约亚太区域中心简介 [Introduction of BCRC China]. 2010, http://ch.bcrc.cn/col/1256346605715/index.html, accessed 1 January 2016

Bāsāiěr gōngyuē yàtàiqū yù zhōngxīn 巴塞尔公约亚太区域中心 [BCRC China]. “Assessing the Status of E-waste Recycling in Selected Countries in the Asia-Pacific Region and Facilitating the Environmentally Sound Management of E-waste.” 2014, http://en.bcrc.cn/col/1257152616046/2014/05/12/1399858044771.html, accessed 1 January 2016

Basu, Subhankar. “E-waste Generation, Mitigation, and a Case Study, Delhi.” In E-waste: Implications, Regulations, and Management in India and Current Global Best Practices, edited by Rakesh Johri. New Delhi: The Energy and Resources Institute, 2008, pp. 45-68

Bo, Bi and Kayoko Yamamoto. “Characteristics of E-waste Recycling Systems in Japan and China.” In World Academy of Science, Engineering and Technology, 38, 2010, pp. 500-506

Brigden, Kevin, Iryna Labunska, David Santillo, and Michelle Allsopp. Recycling of Electronic Wastes in China and India: Workplace and Environmental Contamination. Amsterdam: Greenpeace International, 2005

Chi, Xinwen, Martin Streicher-Porte, Mark Y. L. Wang, and Markus A. Reuter. “Informal Electronic Waste Recycling: A Sector Review with Special Focus on China.” In Waste Management, 31, 2011, pp. 731-742

Chung, Shan-Shan and Chan Zhang. “An Evaluation of Legislative Measures on Electrical and Electronic Waste in the People’s Republic of China.” In Waste Management, 31, 2011, pp. 2638-2646

Cling, Jean-Pierre, Mireille Razafindrakoto, and François Roubaud. The Informal Economy in Vietnam. Geneva: International Labour Organization (ILO), 2010

Cobbing, Madeleine. Toxic Tech: Not in Our Backyard. Uncovering the Hidden Flows of E-waste. Amsterdam: Greenpeace, 2008

Davidson, Gary. Waste Management Practices: Literature Review. Nova Scotia: Dalhousie University, 2011

Dayaneni, Gopal and John Doucette. System Error. San Jose: Silicon Valley Toxics Coalition, 2005

Doyon-Martin, Jacquelynn. “Cybercrime in West Africa as a Result of Transboundary E-Waste.” In Journal of Applied Security Research, 10/2, 2015, pp. 207-220

DTI Global Watch Mission. Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE): Innovating Novel Recovery and Recycling Technologies in Japan. London: Department of Trade and Industry, 2005

Frey, R. Scott. “The E-Waste Stream in the World-System.” In Journal of Globalization Studies, 3/1, 2012, pp. 79-94

Fuse, Masaaki, Eiji Yamasue, Barbara K. Reck, and T. E. Graedel. “Regional Development or Resource Preservation? A Perspective from Japanese Appliance Exports.” In Ecological Economics, 70, 2011, pp. 788-797

Gaidajis, Georgios, Komninos Angelakoglou, and Despoina Aktsoglou. “E-waste: Environmental Problems and Current Management.” In Journal of Engineering Science and Technology Review, 3/1, 2010, pp. 193-199

Gossart, Cédric. StEP Green Paper on E-waste Indicators. Bonn: United Nations University/Step Initiative, 2011

Hai, Huynh Trung, Ha Vinh Hung, and Nguyen Duc Quang. “An Overview of Electronic Waste Recycling in Vietnam.” In Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management, December 2015, pp. 1-9

He, Wenzhi, Guangming Li, Xingfa Ma, Hua Wang, Juwen Huang, Min Xu, and Chunjie Huang. “WEEE Recovery Strategies and the WEEE Treatment Status in China.” In Journal of Hazardous Materials, B136, 2006, pp. 502-512

Heilmann, Sebastian. “Policy Experimentation in China’s Economic Rise.” In Studies in Comparative International Development, 43/1, 2008, pp. 1-26

Herat, Sunil and P. Agamuthu. “E-waste: A Problem or an Opportunity? Review of Issues, Challenges and Solutions in Asian Countries.” In Waste Management & Research, 30/11, 2012, pp. 1113-1129

Hicks, Charlotte, Rolf Dietmar, and Martin Eugster. “The Recycling and Disposal of Electrical and Electronic Waste in China-Legislative and Market Responses.” In Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 25, 2005, pp. 459-471

Hoornweg, Daniel and Perinaz Bhada-Tata. What a Waste: A Global Review of Solid Waste Management. Washington, D.C.: World Bank, 2012

Hotta, Yasuhiko, Atsushi Santo, and Tomohiro Tasaki. EPR-based Electronic Home Appliance Recycling System under Home Appliance Recycling Act of Japan. Tokyo: IGES, 2014

Imura, Hidefumi and Miranda A. Schreurs. Environmental Policy in Japan. Cheltenham and Northampton: World Bank, 2005

ISWA. Solid Waste: Guidelines for Successful Planning. São Paulo: ISWA, 2011

Kankyōshō 環境省 [Ministry of the Environment] and Keizai sangyō shō 経済産業省 [Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry]. “Heisei 26 nendo niokeru kaden risaikuru jisseki nitsuite” 平成26 年度における家電リサイクル実績について [Report on Progress in Recycling Home Appliances in 2014]. 2015, http://www.env.go.jp/press/101129.html, accessed 9 February 2016

Keizai sangyō shō 経済産業省 [Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry]. “10 tsuki wa 3 R (ridyūsu.riyūsu.risaikuru) suishin gekkan desu!” 10 月は3R (リデュース・リユース・リサイクル) 推進月間です! [October is 3R (Reduce, Reuse and Recycle) Awareness Month]. 2015, http://www.meti.go.jp/press/2015/10/20151001004/20151001004.html, accessed 2 February 2016

Kiddee, Peeranart, Ravi Naidu, and Ming H. Wong. “Electronic Waste Management Approaches: An Overview.” In Waste Management, 33, 2013, pp. 1237-1250

Lee, Soo-cheol and Sung-in Na. “E-Waste Recycling Systems and Sound Circulative Economies in East Asia: A Comparative Analysis of Systems in Japan, South Korea, China and Taiwan.” In Sustainability, 2, 2010, pp. 1632-1644

Leung, Anna O. W., Nurdan S. Duzgoren-Aydin, K.C. Cheung, and Ming H. Wong. “Heavy Metals Concentrations of Surface Dust from E-waste Recycling and Its Human Health Implications in Southeast China.” In Environmental Science and Technology, 42/7, 2008, pp. 2674-2680

Liu, Xianbing, Masaru Tanaka, and Yasuhiro Matsui. “Electrical and Electronic Waste Management in China: Progress and the Barriers to Overcome.” In Waste Management & Research, 24, 2006, pp. 94-101

Lundgren, Karin. The Global Impact of E-waste: Addressing the Challenge. Geneva: International Labour Organization (ILO), 2012

Menikpura, Nirmala, Atsushi Santo, and Yasuhiko Hotta. “Assessing the Climate Co-benefits from Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment (WEEE) Recycling in Japan.” In Journal of Cleaner Production, 74, 2014, pp. 183-190

METI. Towards a 3R-Oriented, Sustainable Society: Legislation and Trends 2010. Tokyo: METI, 2010

MOE. “Fundamental Plan for Establishing a Sound Material-Cycle Society.” 2013, https://www.env.go.jp/en/recycle/smcs/3rd-f_plan.pdf, accessed 2 January 2016

MOE. “The Asian Network for Prevention of Illegal Transboundary Movement of Hazardous Wastes.” 2015a, http://www.env.go.jp/en/recycle/asian_net/index.html, accessed 2 January 2016

MOE. “Asia E-waste Project.” 2015b, http://www.env.go.jp/en/recycle/asian_net/Project_N_Research/Asia_E-waste_Project.html, accessed 2 January 2016

MOE. “Activities for Prevention of Illegal Import/Export.” 2015c, http://www.env.go.jp/en/recycle/basel_conv/Activities/index.html, accessed 31 January 2016

Mungai, Christine. “The Mobile Phone Comes First in Africa; Before Electricity, Water, Toilets or Even Food.” Mail & Guardian Africa, 3 March 2015, http://mgafrica.com/article/2015-03-03-mobile-come-first-in-africa-before-electricity-water-toilets-or-even-food, accessed 29 July 2015

Nguyen, Duc-Quang, Eiji Yamasue, Hideyuki Okumura, and Keiichi N. Ishihara. “Use and Disposal of Large Home Electronic Appliances in Vietnam.” In Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management, 11/4, 2009, pp. 358-366

Ni, Hong-Gang and Eddy Y. Zeng. “Law Enforcement and Global Collaboration are the Keys to Containing E-Waste Tsunami in China.” In Environmental Science & Technology, 43/11, 2009, pp. 3991-3994

Nnorom, Innocent C. and Oladele Osibanjo. “Overview of Electronic Waste (E-Waste) Management Practices and Legislations, and Their Poor Applications in the Developing Countries.” In Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 52, 2008, pp. 843-858

Ogushi, Yasuhiko and Milind Kandlikar. “Assessing Extended Producer Responsibility Laws in Japan.” In Environmental Science & Technology, July 2007, pp. 4502-4508

OECD. Extended Producer Responsibility: A Guidance Manual for Governments. Paris: OECD, 2001

OECD. Environmental Outlook to 2030. Paris: OECD, 2008

OECD. “How Does the Chinese E-waste Disposal Fund Scheme Work.” 2014, http://www.oecd.org/environment/waste/China%20case%20study%20final.pdf, accessed 30 January 2016

OECD and MOE. “The State of Play on Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR): Opportunities and Challenges.” In Global Forum on Environment: Promoting Sustainable Materials Management through Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR), Tokyo, Japan, 17-19 June 2014

Pham, Sy Liem. “Handling of Solid Waste in Vietnam.” Presentation at the 4th Civil Engineering Conference in the Asian Region held by the Asian Civil Engineering Coordinating Council (ACECC), Taipei, Taiwan, 26-28 June 2007

Premakumara, Dickella G. J. and Toshizo Maeda. “Municipal Solid Waste: The Burgeoning Environmental Threat.” In Routledge Handbook of Environment and Society in Asia, edited by Paul G. Harris and Graeme Lang. Abingdon and New York: Routledge, 2015, pp. 176-196

Premalatha, M., Tabassum-Abbasi, Tasneem Abbasi, and Sakineh Abbasi. “The Generation, Impact, and Management of E-Waste: State of the Art.” In Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology, 44/14, 2014, pp. 1577-1678

Puckett, Jim, Leslie Byster, Sarah Westervelt, Richard Gutierrez, Sheila Davis, Asma Hussain, and Madhumitta Dutta. Exporting Harm: The High-Tech Trashing of Asia. Seattle and San Jose: Basel Action Network and Silicon Valley Toxics Coalition, 2002

Sawhney, Puja, Mikael Henzler, Stefan Melnitzky, and Anita Lung. Best Practices for E-waste Management in Developed Countries. Berlin: Adelphi Research, 2008

Schluep, Mathias, Christian Hagelueken, Ruediger Kuehr, Federico Magalini, Claudia Maurer, Christina Meskers, Esther Mueller, and Feng Wang. Recycling - From E-waste to Resources. Berlin: United Nations Environment Programme and United Nations University, 2009

Schwartz, Frank J. and Susan J. Pharr. The State of Civil Society in Japan. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003

Seadon, Jeffrey K. “Sustainable Waste Management Systems.” In Journal of Cleaner Production, 18, 2010, pp. 1639-1651

Shinkuma, Takayoshi and Nguyen Thi Minh Huong. “The Flow of E-Waste Material in the Asian Region and a Reconsideration of International Trade Policies on E-waste.” In Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 29, 2009, pp. 25-31

StEP. One Global Definition of E-waste. Bonn: United Nations University/Step Initiative, 2014

Sthiannopkao, Suthipong and Ming Hung Wong. “Handling E-waste in Developed and Developing Countries: Initiatives, Practices, and Consequences.” In Science of the Total Environment, 463-464, 2013, pp. 1147-1153

Streicher‐Porte, Martin. “An Introduction to ‘Best of 2 Worlds’ Project.” 2009, http://ewasteguide.info/files/Streicher-Porte_2009_Bo2W.pdf, accessed 30 January 2016

Terazono, Atsushi and Aya Yoshida. “Current International Flows of Electronic Waste, Future Tasks, and Possible Solutions.” In E-waste Management: From Waste to Resource, edited by Klaus Hieronymi, Ramzy Kahhat and Eric Williams. London and New York: Routledge, 2012, pp. 137-164

Thai, Nguyen Thi Kim. “Hazardous Industrial Waste Management in Vietnam: Current Status and Future Direction.” In Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management, 11, 2009, pp. 258-262

Tue, Nguyen Minh, Agus Sudaryanto, Tu Binh Minh, Tomohiko Isobe, Shin Takahashi, Pham Hung Viet, and Shinsuke Tanabe. “Accumulation of Polychlorinated Biphenyls and Brominated Flame Retardants in Breast Milk from Women Living in Vietnamese E-waste Recycling Sites.” In Science of the Total Environment, 408/9, 2010a, pp. 2155-2162

Tue, Nguyen Minh, Go Suzuki, Shin Takahashi, Tomohiko Isobe, Pham T. K. Trang, Pham Hung Viet, and Shinsuke Tanabe. “Evaluation of Dioxin-like Activities in Settled House Dust from Vietnamese E-waste Recycling Sites: Relevance of Polychlorinated/brominated Dibenzo-pdioxin/furans and Dioxin-like PCBs.” In Environmental Science & Technology, 44/23, 2010b, pp. 9195-9200

UNDP. Human Development Report 2014. Sustaining Human Progress: Reducing Vulnerabilities and Building Resilience. New York: United Nations Development Programme (UNDP), 2014

UNEP. “International Environmental Technology Centre (IETC).” 2015, http://www.unep.org/ietc/AboutIETC/tabid/56241/Default.aspx, accessed 15 December 2015

United Nations Human Settlements Programme (ed.). Solid Waste Management in the World’s Cities. London and Washington, D.C.: United Nations Human Settlements Programme (UNHABITAT), 2010

UNODC. Transnational Organized Crime in East Asia and the Pacific: A Threat Assessment. Bangkok: United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC), 2013

United Nations University and Step Initiative. “China.” 2016, http://www.stepinitiative.org/Overview_China.html, accessed 1 January 2016

United States Environmental Protection Agency. “What Is Integrated Solid Waste Management?” 2002, http://www.epa.gov/climatechange/wycd/waste/downloads/overview.pdf, accessed 11 July 2015

URENCO. The Development of E-waste Inventory in Vietnam. Hanoi: URENCO Urban Environmental Company Limited, 2007

Van de Klundert, Arnold and Justine Anschütz. Integrated Sustainable Waste Management - The Concept. Gouda: WASTE, 2001

Vietnam Environment Administration. “Introduction on E-Waste Management in Vietnam.” 2011, http://www.unep.org/ietc/Portals/136/Events/WEEEE%20workshop%20July%202011/12.Vietnam.pdf, accessed 31 January 2016

VNS. “Consortium Launches E-waste Recycling Programme in Vietnam.” 2015, http://english.vietnamnet.vn/fms/environment/127608/consortium-launches-e-waste-recyclingprogramme-in-vietnam.html, accessed 31 January 2016

Wang, Feng, Ruediger Kuehr, Daniel Ahlquist, and Jinhui Li. E-waste in China: A Country Report. Bonn: United Nations University/StEP Initiative, 2013

Wang, Zhaohua, Bin Zhang, Jianhua Yin, and Xiang Zhang. “Willingness and Behavior Towards E-waste Recycling for Residents in Beijing City, China.” In Journal of Cleaner Production, 19, 2011, pp. 977-984

Wei, Lin and Yangsheng Liu. “Present Status of E-Waste Disposal and Recycling in China.” In Procedia Environmental Sciences, 16, 2012, pp. 506-514

Widmer, Rolf, Heidi Oswald-Krapf, Deepali Sinha-Khetriwal, Max Schellmann, and Heinz Böni. “Global Perspectives on E-waste.” In Environmental Impact Assessment Review, 25/5, 2005, pp. 436-458

Wiesmeth, Hans, Dennis Häckl, Quang Trung Do, and Duy Cam Bui. “A Holistic Approach to Recycling of CRT Glass and PCBs in Vietnam.” In Journal of Vietnamese Environment, 2/1, 2012, pp. 1-7

World Bank. Vietnam Environment Monitor 2004. Washington, D.C.: World Bank, 2005

World Bank. “GDP Per Capita (current US$).” 2016, http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.PCAP.CD, accessed 20 February 2016

Yang, Jianxin, Bin Lu, and Cheng Xu. “WEEE Flow and Mitigating Measures in China.” In Waste Management, 28, 2008, pp. 1589-1597

Yoshida, Aya, Tomohiro Tasaki, and Atsushi Terazono. “Material Flow Analysis of Used Personal Computers in Japan.” In Waste Management, 29, 2009, pp. 1602-1614

Yoshida, Fumikazu and Haruyo Yoshida. “Japan, the European Union, and Waste Electronic and Electrical Equipment Recycling: Key Lessons Learned.” In Environmental Engineering Science, 27/1, 2010, pp. 21-28

Yoshida, Fumikazu and Haruyo Yoshida. “E-Waste Management in Japan: A Focus on Appliance Recycling.” In Advanced Materials Research, 878, 2014, pp. 420-423

Yu, Jinglei, Eric Williams, Meiting Ju, and Chaofeng Shao. “Managing E-waste in China: Policies, Pilot Projects and Alternative Approaches.” In Resources, Conservation and Recycling, 54, 2010, pp. 991-999

Zhou, Lei and Zhenming Xu. “Response to Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipments in China: Legislation, Recycling System, and Advanced Integrated Process.” In Environmental Science & Technology, 46, 2012, pp. 4713-4724.

Journal Information

Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 138 138 18
PDF Downloads 102 102 17