Risk of Malpractice Claims and Changes in Professional Autonomy: A Qualitative Study of Obstetrician-Gynaecologists in Switzerland

Open access


Based on interviews, this article explores how obstetrician-gynaecologists in Switzerland deal with and respond to the risk of malpractice claims. It describes the factors associated with the interviewees’ perceived increasing risk of litigation, as well as three attitudes towards the use of consent forms as a means of managing such a risk. This article suggests that the perceived risk of claims is closely linked to the physicians’ perception of how external regulation shapes their professional autonomy.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Abbott Andrew. 1988. The System of Professions. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

  • Allsop Judith and Linda Mulcahy. 1998. Maintaining Professional Identity: Doctors’ Responses to Complaints. Sociology of Health & Illness 20(6): 802-824.

  • Annandale Ellen. 1989. The Malpractice Crisis and the Doctor-Patient Relationship. Sociology of Health & Illness 11(1): 1-23.

  • Annandale Ellen. 1996. Working in the Front-Line: Risk Culture and Nursing in the New NHS. Sociological Review 44(3): 416-451.

  • Barbot Janine. 2008. Soigner en situation de risque judiciaire. Refus de transfusion et responsabilité médicale. Revue française de science politique 58(6): 985-1014.

  • Barbot Janine and Emmanuelle Fillion. 2006. La « médecine défensive » : Critique d’un concept à succès. Sciences Sociales et Santé 24(2): 5-33.

  • Bergeron Henri and Patrick Castel. 2014. Sociologie politique de la santé. Paris: PUF.

  • Biancucci Matthieu. 2011. Les ajustements de la technique médicale face aux règles de droit. Sociologie du travail 53(3): 369-387.

  • Bucher Rue and Anselm Strauss. 1961. Professions in Process. American Journal of Sociology 66(4): 352-334.

  • Büchler Andrea and Thomas Gächter. 2011. Medical Law in Switzerland. Alphen aan den Rijn: Wolters Kluwer.

  • Bury Michael. 2010. The British Health Care System. Pp. 412-433 in The New Blackwell Companion to Medical Sociology edited by William C. Cockerham. Malden MA: Wiley-Blackwell.

  • Cambrosio Alberto Peter Keating Thomas Schlich and George Weisz. 2006. Regulatory Objectivity and the Generation and Management of Evidence in Medicine. Social Science & Medicine 63(1): 189-199.

  • Cartwright Elizabeth and Jan Thomas. 2001. Constructing Risk. Maternity Care Law and Malpractice. Pp. 218-228 in Birth by Design edited by Raymond Devries Cecilia Benoit Edwin R. Van Teijlingen and Sirpa Wrede. New York: Routledge.

  • Cavalli Samuele. 2014. Gérer le risque et l’incertitude: Une typologie des stratégies professionnelles dans la pratique du dépistage prénatal. PhD dissertation Faculty of Economics and Social Sciences University of Geneva Switzerland.

  • Cook W. Rupert and Charlotte Neff. 1994. Attitudes of Physicians in Northern Ontario to Medical Malpractice Litigation. Canadian Family Physician 40: 689-698.

  • Courvoisier Delphine S. Thomas Agoritsas Thomas V. Perneger Ralph E. Schmidt and Stéphane Cullati. 2011. Regrets Associated with Providing Healthcare: Qualitative Study of Experiences of Hospital-Based Physicians and Nurses. PLoS ONE 6(8) http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0023138 (13.10.2015).

  • Dalton George D. Xanthia F. Samaropoulos and Augustine C. Dalton. 2008. Effect of Physician Strategies for Coping with the US Medical Malpractise Crisis on Healthcare Delivery and Patient Access to Healthcare. Public Health 122(10): 1051-1060.

  • Dingwall Robert and Pru Hobson-West. 2006. Litigation and the Threat to Medicine. Pp. 40-61 in Challenging Medicine 2nd edition edited by David Kelleher Jonathan Gabe and Gareth Williams. London: Routledge.

  • Dubar Claude Pierre Tripier and Valérie Boussard. 2011. Sociologie des professions. 3rd edition. Paris: Armand Colin.

  • Exworthy Mark Emma K. Wilkinson Alastair McColl Michael Moore Paul Roderick Helen Smith and John Gabbay. 2003. The Role of Performance Indicators in Changing the Autonomy of the General Practice Profession in the UK. Social Science & Medicine 56(7): 1493-1504.

  • Fillion Emmanuelle. 2009. A l’épreuve du sang contaminé. Paris: Editions EHESS.

  • Flick Uwe. 2009. An Introduction to Qualitative Research. 4th edition. London: Sage.

  • Freidson Eliot. 1970. The Profession of Medicine. New York: Mead and Company.

  • Freidson Eliot. 1985. The Reorganisation of the Medical Profession. Medical Care Review 42(1): 11-35.

  • Freidson Eliot. 1994. Professionalism Reborn: Theory Prophecy and Policy. Oxford: Polity Press.

  • Hafferty Frederic and Donald W. Light. 1995. Professional Dynamics and the Changing Nature of Medical Work. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 36: 132-153.

  • Hammer Raphaël and Claudine Burton-Jeangros. 2013. Tensions around Risks in Pregnancy: A Typology of Women’s Experiences of Surveillance Medicine. Social Science & Medicine 93: 55-63.

  • Harrison Stephen and Waqar I.U. Ahmad. 2000. Medical Autonomy and the UK State 1975 to 2025. Sociology 34(1): 129-146.

  • Harrison Stephen and George Dowswell. 2002. Autonomy and Bureaucratic Accountability in Primary Care: What English General Practitioners Say. Sociology of Health & Illness 24(2): 208-226.

  • Hassenteufel Patrick. 1997. Les médecins face à l’Etat. Une comparaison européenne. Paris: Presses de Science Po.

  • Haug Marie and Bebe Lavin. 1983. Consumerism in Medicine: Challenging Physician Authority. Beverley Hills: Sage Publications.

  • Hupert Nathaniel Ann G. Lawthers Troyen A. Brennan and Lynn M. Peterson. 1996. Processing the Tort Deterrent Signal: A Qualitative Study. Social Science & Medicine 43(1): 1-11.

  • Jacques Béatrice. 2007. Sociologie de l’accouchement. Paris: PUF.

  • Jain Ashok and Jane Ogden. 1999. General Practitioners’ Experiences of Patients’ Complaints: Qualitative Study. British Medical Journal 318(7198): 1596-1599.

  • Jena Anupam B. Seth Seabury Darius Lakdawalla and Amitabh Chandra. 2011. Malpractice Risk According to Physician Specialty. The New England Journal of Medicine 365: 629-636.

  • Laude Anne. 2010. La judiciarisation en France sur la trace des États-Unis ? Les Tribunes de la Santé 26: 49-59.

  • Liang Bryan A. 2003. Layperson and Physician Perceptions of the Malpractice System: Implications for Patient Safety. Social Science & Medicine 57(1): 147-153.

  • Light Donald W. 2010. Health-Care Professions Markets and Countervailing Powers. Pp. 270-289 in Handbook of Medical Sociology 6th edition edited by Chloe E. Bird Peter Conrad Allen M. Fremont and Stefan Timmermans. Nashville TN: Vanderbilt University Press.

  • Lupton Deborah. 1997. Doctors on the Medical Profession. Sociology of Health & Illness 19(4): 480-497.

  • Manaï Dominique. 2010. Le suivi de la grossesse: De l’encadrement légal des analyses prénatales à la responsabilité médicale pour information incomplète. Pp. 71-99 in Risques et information dans le suivi de la grossesse : Droit éthique et pratiques sociales edited by Dominique Manaï Claudine Burton-Jeangros and Bernice Elger. Bern: Stämpfli.

  • Manaï Dominique Claudine Burton-Jeangros and Bernice Elger (Eds.). 2010. Risques et information dans le suivi de la grossesse : Droit éthique et pratiques sociales. Bern: Stämpfli.

  • Marjoribanks Timothy Mary-Jo Delvecchio Good Ann G. Lawthers and Lynn M. Peterson. 1996. Physicians’ Discourses on Malpractice and the Meaning of Medical Practice. Journal of Health & Social Behavior 37(2): 163-178.

  • McKinlay John B. and John D. Stoeckle. 1988. Corporatization and the Social Transformation of Doctoring. International Journal of Health Services 18(2): 191-205.

  • Mello Michelle M. David M. Studdert Catherine DesRoches Jordan Peugh Kinga Zapert Troyen A. Brennan and William M. Sage. 2004. Caring for Patients in a Malpractice Crisis: Physician Satisfaction and Quality of Care. Health Affairs 23(4): 42-53.

  • Moyse Danielle and Nicole Diederich. 2006. Vers un droit à l’enfant normal ? L’arrêt Perruche et l’impact de la judiciarisation sur le dépistage prénatal. Toulouse: Editions Erès.

  • Nettleton Sarah. 1995. The Sociology of Health and Illness. Cambridge: Polity Press.

  • Numerato Dino Domenico Salvatore and Giovanni Fattore. 2012. The Impact of Management on Medical Professionalism: A Review. Sociology of Health & Illness 34(4): 626-644.

  • OECD/WHO. 2011. OECD Reviews of Health Systems: Switzerland 2011. OECD Publishing http://www.oecd-ilibrary.org/social-issues-migration-health/oecd-reviews-of-health-systems-switzerland-2011_9789264120914-en (07.01.2016).

  • Perneger Thomas V. Marie Deom Stéphane Cullati and Patrick A. Bovier. 2012. Growing Discontent of Swiss Doctors 1998-2007. European Journal of Public Health 22(4): 478-483.

  • Rothhardt Valérie. 2015. Bureau d’expertises extrajudiciaires de la FMH - Rapport annuel 2014. Bulletin des médecins suisses 96(18): 636-640.

  • Steurer Johan Ulrike Held Mathias Schmidt Gerd Gigerenzer Brigitte Tag and Lucas M. Bachmann. 2009. Legal Concerns Trigger Prostate-Specific Antigen Testing. Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice 15(2): 390-392.

  • Studdert David M. Michelle M. Mello William M. Sage Catherine DesRoches Jordan Peugh Kinga Zapert and Troyen A. Brennan. 2005. Defensive Medicine among High-Risk Specialist Physicians in a Volatile Malpractice Environment. Journal of the American Medical Association 293(21): 2609-2617.

  • Thomas J. William Erika C. Ziller and Deborah A. Thayer. 2010. Low Costs of Defensive Medicine Small Savings from Tort Reform. Health Affairs 29(9): 1578-1584.

  • Timmermans Stefan and Emily S. Kolker. 2004. Evidence-Based Medicine and the Reconfiguration of Medical Knowledge. Journal of Health and Social Behavior 45(2): 177-193.

  • Tousijn Willem. 2006. Beyond Decline: Consumerism Managerialism and the Need for A New Medical Professionalism. Health Sociology Review 15(5): 469-480.

  • Tussing A. Dale and Martha A. Wojtowycz. 1997. Malpractice Defensive Medicine and Obstetric Behaviour. Medical Care 35(2): 172-191.

  • Vanderminden Jennifer and Sharyn J. Potter. 2010. Challenges to the Doctor-Patient Relationship in the Twenty-First Century. Pp. 355-372 in The New Blackwell Companion to Medical Sociology edited by William C. Cockerham. Malden Mass.: Wiley-Blackwell.

  • Vincent Charles Magi Young and Angela Phillips. 1994. Why Do People Sue Doctors? A Study of Patients and Relatives Taking Legal Action. Lancet 343: 1609-1613.

Journal information
Impact Factor

CiteScore 2018: 0.24

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2018: 0.141
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2018: 0.087

Cited By
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 239 139 5
PDF Downloads 102 72 4