Provincializing Constitutions: History, Narrative, and the Disappearance of Canada’s Provincial Constitutions

Open access

Abstract

Constitutional scholarship in Canada since Confederation has been characterized by two primary narratives. The dualist narrative, which characterized constitutional scholarship between the late-nineteenth and mid-twentieth centuries, focussed on the parallel developments of provincial and federal constitutions. The monist narrative, which has become the dominant model of interpretation since the mid-twentieth century, focusses on the federal constitution as a singular foundation of constitutionalism in Canada. As a result of the shift from dualism to monism, provincial constitutions have become largely ignored in Canada and subsumed by the “mega-constitutional” politics of the federal constitution. This paper examines provincial constitutions to highlight the significant reorientation of constitutional scholarship in Canada over the past 150 years, which has become primarily focussed on post-Confederation constitutional history and written constitutionalism.

• Adams Eric M., 2006, ‘Canada’s “Newer” Constitutional Law and the Idea of Constitutional Rights’, McGill Law Journal, LI(3): 435-474.

• Adams Eric M., 2015, ‘Constitutional Nationalism: Politics, Law, and Culture on the Road to Patriation’, in Harder Lois and Patten Steve (eds), Patriation and its Consequences: Constitution Making in Canada, UBC Press, Vancouver, 49-68.

• Ajzenstat Janet, 1990, ‘Canada’s First Constitution: Pierre Bédard on Tolerance and Dissent’, Canadian Journal of Political Science, XXIII(1): 39-57.

• Armour E.D., 1884, ‘The Canadian Legislatures and their Respective Powers’, Week, I(40): 631.

• Armour E.D., 1892, ‘Book Review: Law of the Canadian Constitution’, Canadian Law Times, XII(12): 301.

• Aroney Nicholas, 2012, “’opular Ratification of the State Constitutions’, in Kildea Paul, Lynch Andrew and Williams George (eds) Tomorrow’s Federation: Reforming Australian Government, Federation Press, Sydney, 210-216.

• Aroney Nicholas, Gerangelos Peter, Murray Sarah and Stellios James, 2015, The Constitution of the Commonwealth of Australia: History, Principle, and Interpretation, Cambridge University Press, Port Melbourne.

• Baier Gerald, 2012, ‘Canada: Federal and Subnational Constitutional Practices’, in Burgess Michael and Tarr G. Alan. (eds) Constitutional Dynamics in Federal Systems: Sub-national Perspectives, McGill-Queen’s University Press, Montreal and Kingston, 174-194.

• Baker G. Blaine, 1985, ‘The Reconstitution of Upper Canadian Legal Thought in the Late-Victorian Empire’, Law and History Review, III(2): 223-270.

• Banks Margaret A., 1986, ‘Defining “Constitution of the Province” – The Crux of the Manitoba Language Controversy’, McGill Law Journal, XXXI(3): 466-479.

• Banks Margaret A., 2001, Sir John George Bourinot: Victorian Canadian, McGill-Queen’s University Press, Montreal and Kingston.

• Beck James Murray, 1957, The Government of Nova Scotia, University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

• Borrows John, 2010, Canada’s Indigenous Constitution, University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

• Bourinot John George, 1889, Federal Government in Canada, N. Murray, Baltimore.

• Bourinot John George, 1888, Manual on the Constitutional History of Canada from the Earliest Period to the Year 1888, Dawson Brothers, Montreal.

• Bourinot John George, 1888, Federal and Provincial Constitutions, Maclean, Roger, and. Co., Ottawa.

• Bourinot John George, 1895, How Canada is Governed, 2nd ed., Copp, Clark, Toronto.

• Buckner Phillip Alfred, 1985, The Transition to Responsible Government: British Policy in British North America, 1815-1850, Greenwood, Westport.

• Cairns Alan C., 1971, ‘The Judicial Committee and its Critics’, Canadian Journal of Political Science, IV(3): 301-345.

• Canada, 1865, Parliamentary Debates on the Subject of the Confederation of the British North American Provinces, Hunter, Rose, and Co., Quebec.

• Canada, 1882, Debates of the House of Commons, 4th Parliament, 4th Session.

• Canada, 1888, Journals of the Senate of Canada, 6th Parliament, 2nd Session.

• Cheffins Ronald I. and Tucker Ronald N., 1976, ‘Constitutions’, in Bellamy David J, Pammett Jon H. and Rowat Donald C. (eds) The Provincial Political Systems: Comparative Essays, Methuen, Toronto.

• Clement W.H.P., 1892, The Law of the Canadian Constitution, Carswell, Toronto.

• Cockburn J., 1882, ‘The Power of Disallowance and its National Importance’, Rose-Belford’s Canadian Monthly, VIII: 430.

• Colley Linda, 2014, ‘Empires of Writing: Britain, America and Constitutions, 1776-1848’, Law and History Review, XXXII(2): 237-266.

• Cook Ramsay, 1969, Provincial Autonomy, Minority Rights and the Compact Theory, 1867-1921, Queen’s Printer, Ottawa.

• Ducharme Michel, 2010, Le concept de liberté au Canada à l’époque des Révolutions atlantiques (1776-1838), McGill-Queen’s University Press, Montreal and Kingston.

• Gérin-Lajoie Paul, Constitutional Amendment in Canada, University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

• Hodgins Bruce W., 1972, ‘Disagreement at the Commencement: Divergent Ontarian Views of Federalism, 1867-1871’, in Swainson Donald (ed), Oliver Mowat’s Ontario, Macmillan, Toronto, 52-68.

• Howland O.A., 1891, The New Empire: Reflections on Its Origin and Constitution and Its Relation to the Great Republic, Hart and Company, Toronto.

• Kennedy W.P.M., 1931, ‘Three Views of Constitutional Law’, Canadian Bar Review, IX(8): 553-559.

• Kennedy W.P.M., 1937, ‘The British North America Act: Past and Future’, Canadian Bar Review, XV(6): 393-400.

• Laforest Guy, Brouillet Eugénie, Gagnon Alain-G. and Tanguay Yves (eds.), 2015, The Constitutions That Shaped Us: A Historical Anthology of Pre-1867 Canadian Constitutions, McGill-Queen’s University Press, Montreal and Kingston.

• Lederman, W.R, 1981, Continuing Canadian Constitutional Dilemmas: Essays on Constitutional History, Public Law and Federal System of Canada, Buttersworth, Toronto.

• Loranger T.J.J., 1884, Letters Upon the Federal Constitution Known as the British North America Act (1867), “Morning Chronicle” Office, Quebec.

• Lower Arthur R.M., 1964, Colony to Nation: A History of Canada, 4th ed., Longmans, Don Mills.

• MacDonald Vincent C., 1948, ‘The Constitution in a Changing World’, Canadian Bar Review, XXVI(1): 21-45.

• Macdougall William, 1875, Six Letters to the Honourable O. Mowat on the Amendment of the Provincial Constitution, Mail Printing Company, Toronto.

• Macfarlane Emmett, 2016, ‘The Electoral Reform Debate and the Law’, Policy Options, http://policyoptions.irpp.org/2016/06/07/electoral-reform-debate-law/.

• Martin Chester, 1929, Empire & Commonwealth: Studies in Governance and Self-Government in Canada, Clarendon Press, Oxford.

• McHugh James T., 1999/2000, ‘The Quebec Constitution’, Quebec Studies, XXVIII: 3-26.

• McNairn Jeffrey L., 2000, The Capacity to Judge: Public Opinion and Deliberative Democracy in -Upper Canada, 1791-1854, University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

• Morin Jacques-Yvan and Woehrling José, 1994, Les constitutions du Canada et du Québec du régime français à nos jours, Thémis, Montreal.

• Morton, F.L., 2004, ‘Provincial Constitutions in Canada’, Conference on Federalism and Sub-national Constitutions, http://statecon.camden.rutgers.edu/sites/statecon/files/subpapers/morton.pdf.

• Nova Scotia, 1865, Debates and Proceedings of the House of Assembly, 23rd Parliament, 2nd Session.

• O’Flaherty Liam Michael, 2008, ‘Doing Provincial Constitutions Differently: Codifying Responsible Government in the Era of Executive Dominance’, MA Thesis, University of British Columbia.

• O’Sullivan D.A., 1879, A Manual of Government in Canada, J.C. Stuart, Toronto.

• O’Sullivan D.A., 1887, Government in Canada, Carswell, Toronto.

• Read John E., 1948, ‘The Early Provincial Constitutions’, Canadian Bar Review, XXVI(4): 621-637.

• ‘Responsible Government: Its Establishment Fittingly Celebrated on Historic Ground’, Globe (July 18, 1892), 1.

• Richez Emmanuelle, 2016, ‘The Possibilities and Limits of Provincial Constitution-Making Power: The Case of Quebec’, in Macfarlane Emmett (ed) Constitutional Amendment in Canada, University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 164-184.

• Risk R.C.B., 2006, ‘The Scholars and the Constitution: POGG and the Privy Council’, in Baker G. Blaine and Phillips Jim (eds), A History of Canadian Legal Thought: Collected Essays, University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

• Romney Paul, 1999, Getting it Wrong: How Canadians Forgot their Past and Imperilled Confederation, University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

• Rowe Malcolm and Collins J. Michael, 2015, ‘What is the Constitution of a Province?’, in Dunn Christopher (ed), Provinces: Canadian Provincial Politics, 3rd ed.., University of Toronto Press, Toronto, 297-314.

• Russell Peter H., 2004, Constitutional Odyssey: Can Canadians Become a Sovereign People?, 3rd ed., University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

• Russell Peter H. and Sossin Lorne (eds), 2009, Parliamentary Government in Crisis, University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

• Scott F.R., 1950, ‘The British North America (No. 2) Act, 1949’, University of Toronto Law Journal, VIII(2): 201-207.

• Scott F.R., 1977a, ‘Centralization and Decentralization in the Canadian Constitution’, in Essays on the Constitution: Aspects of Canadian Law and Politics, University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

• Scott, F.R., 1977b, ‘The Redistribution of Imperial Sovereignty’, in Essays on the Constitution: Aspects of Canadian Law and Politics, University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

• Sharman Campbell, 1983, ‘The Strange Case of a Provincial Constitution: The British Columbia Constitution Act’, Canadian Journal of Political Science, XVII(1): 87-108.

• Stuart C.A., 1933, ‘Our Constitution Outside the British North America Act’, in Dawson R.M. (ed), Constitutional Issues in Canada, 1900-1931, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

• Tarr G. Alan., ‘Federalism and Subnational Legal Systems: The Canadian Example of Provincial Constitutionalism’, in Clark David S. (ed), Comparative Law and Society, Edward Elgar, Cheltenham.

• Tarr G. Alan, Williams Robert F. and Marko Josef (eds), 2004, Federalism, Subnational Constitutions, and Minority Rights, Praeger, Westport.

• Taylor Fennings, 1879, Are Legislatures Parliaments? A Study and Review, J. Lovell, Montreal.

• Turp Daniel, 2013, La Constitution québécoise: essais sur le doit du Québec de se doter de sa propre loi fondamentale, Éditions JFD, Montreal.

• Vipond Robert C., 1991, Liberty and Community: Canadian Federalism and the Failure of the Constitution, SUNY Press, Albany.

• Watson Samuel James, 1880, The Powers of Canadian Parliaments, C.B. Robinson, Toronto.

• Wiseman Nelson, 1996, ‘Provincial Constitutions’, in Dunn Christopher (ed), Provinces: Canadian Provincial Politics, Broadview, Peterborough.

• Wright Donald A., 2009, The Professionalization of History in English Canada, University of Toronto Press, Toronto.

Journal Information

CiteScore 2018: 0.04

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2018: 0.105
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2018: 0.03

Target Group researchers, academics, practitioners interested in the field of political, economic and legal issues in federal states, regional organizations, and international organizations at global level

Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 243 146 9
PDF Downloads 160 117 7