Franchises Lost and Gained: Post-Coloniality and the Development of Women’s Rights in Canada

Open access

Abstract

The Canadian constitution is to some extent characterised by its focus on equality, and in particular gender equality. This development of women’s rights in Canada and the greater engagement of women as political actors is often presented as a steady linear process, moving forwards from post-enlightenment modernity. This article seeks to disturb this ‘discourse of the continuous,’ by using an analysis of the pre-confederation history of suffrage in Canada to both refute a simplistic linear view of women’s rights development and to argue for recognition of the Indigenous contribution to the history of women’s rights in Canada.

The gain of franchise and suffrage movements in Canada in the late nineteenth and early twentieth century are, rightly, the focus of considerable study (Pauker 2015), This article takes an alternative perspective. Instead, it examines the exercise of earlier franchises in pre-confederation Canada. In particular it analyses why franchise was exercised more widely in Lower Canada and relates this to the context of the removal of franchises from women prior to confederation.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • • Anderson Stuart 2010 ‘Local Government’ in Cornish William Rodolph (ed) The Oxford History of the Laws of England Volume XI 1820-1914 English Legal System Oxford University Press Oxford.

  • • Atiyah Patrick S 1986 ‘Form and Substance in Legal Reasoning: The Case of Contract’ in MacCormick Neil and Birks Peter (eds) The Legal Mind: Essays for Tony Honoré Clarendon Press Oxford 19-44.

  • • Backhouse Constance 1991 Petticoats and Prejudice: Women and Law in Nineteenth-Century Canada published for the Osgoode Society by Women’s Press Toronto.

  • • Bailey Joanne 2002 ‘Favoured or Oppressed? Married Women Property and “Coverture” in England 1600-1800’ Continuity and Change XVII(3): 351–72.

  • • Baillargeon Denyse 2014 A Brief History of women in Quebec Wilfrid Laurier Press Waterloo.

  • • Ballara Angela 2017 ‘Mangakahia Meri Te Tai’ Web page Dictionary of New Zealand Biography Accessed August 23 2017 https://teara.govt.nz/en/biographies/2m30/mangakahia-meri-te-tai.

  • • Boutelle Ann Edwards 1986 ‘Frances Brooke’s Emily Montague (1769): Canada and Woman’s Rights’ Women’s Studies XII(1): 7–16.

  • • Bradbury Bettina 2012 Wife to Widow: Lives Laws and Politics in Nineteenth-Century Montreal UBC Press Vancouver.

  • • Brailsford Henry Noel and Hill Christopher 1976 The Levellers and the English Revolution New edition Spokesman Books Nottingham.

  • • Brooke Frances 1995 The History of Emily Montague McClelland & Stewart Toronto.

  • • Brooks Christopher and Sharpe Kevin 1976 ‘History English Law and the Renaissance’ Past and Present no. 72: 133–42.

  • • Brydon Diana and Schagerl Jessica 2005 ‘Empire Girls and Global Girls: A Dialogue on Spaces of Community in the Twentieth Century’ in Kanaganayakam C. (Chelvnayakam) (ed) Moveable Margins: The Shifting Spaces of Canadian Literature TSAR Toronto 27-45.

  • • Campbell Grail 1989 ‘Disenfranchised But Not Quiescent: Women Petitioners in New Brunswick in the Mid-Nineteenth Centuy’ Acadiensis XVIII(2): 22-54.

  • • Carlyle Thomas 1933 The French Revolution J.M. Dent London.

  • • CEDAW 2003 Concluding Comments on the Committee Twenty-Eighth Session Canada’s Fifth Periodic Report CEDAW/C/2003/I/CRP.3/Add.5.1.

  • • CEDAW 2016 ‘Report of the Inquiry Concerning Canada of the Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women under Article 8 of the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women’.

  • • Choquette Leslie 1997 Frenchmen into Peasants: Modernity and Tradition in the Peopling of French Canada Harvard University Press Cambridge Mass.

  • • Clark Anna 2005 ‘Women in Eighteenth-Century British Politics’ in Knott Sarah and Taylor Barbara (eds) Women Gender and Enlightenment 1650-1850 Palgrave Macmillan Basingstoke 570-586.

  • • Cleverdon Catherine Lyle 1950 The Woman Suffrage Movement in Canada University of Toronto Press Toronto.

  • • Clio Collective Dumont Micheline and Michel Jean 1990 Quebec Women: a history Three O’Clock Press Toronto.

  • • Cobbett William 1807 Cobbett’s Parliamentary History of England: From the Norman Conquest in 1066 to the Year 1803 Vol.2 Comprising the Period from the Accession of Charles the First in March 1625 to the Battle of Edge-Hill in October 1642 Bagshaw London.

  • • Coke Edward 1669 The Fourth Part of the Institutes of the Lawes of England: Concerning the Jurisdiction of Courts .. The fourth edition Printed for A Crook [and 12 others] booksellers London.

  • • Cour Likke de la Morgan Cecilia and Valverde Mariana 1992 ‘Gender Regulation and State Formation’ in Greer Alan and Radforth Ian Walter (eds) Colonial Leviathan: State Formation in Mid-Nineteenth-Century Canada University of Toronto Press Toronto and Buffalo 163-191.

  • • Courtney John C. (John Childs) 2004 Elections UBC Press Vancouver.

  • • Crawford Elizabeth 1999 The Women’s Suffrage Movement: A Reference Guide 1866-1928 UCL Press London.

  • • Crenshaw Kimberle 1989 ‘Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex: A Black Feminist Critique of Antidiscrimination Doctrine Feminist Theory and Antiracist Politics’ University of Chicago Legal Forum 1989: 139-167.

  • • Curzon of Kedleston George Nathaniel Curzon 1908 Lord Curzon’s Fifteen Good Reasons against the Grant of Female Suffrage National League for Opposing Woman Suffrage London.

  • • Devens Carol 1992 Countering Colonization: Native American Women and Great Lakes Missions 1630-1900 University of California Press Berkeley Calif.

  • • Doucet Nicolas Benjamin 1847 Fundamental Principles of the Laws of Canada as They Existed under the Natives as They Were Changed under the French Kings and as They Were Modified and Altered under the Domination of England : The General Principles of the Custom of Paris as Laid down by the Most Eminent Authors with the Text and a Literal Translation of the Text The Imperial and Other Statutes Changing the Jurisprudence in Either of the Provinces of Canada at Large .. Printed by J Lovell Montreal.

  • • Doughty Arthur G. (Arthur George) and Story Norah 1935 Documents Relating to the Constitutional History of Canada 1819-1828 J.O Patenaude Ottawa.

  • • Elections Canada (ed) 1997 A History of the Vote in Canada Published by Minister of Public Works and Government Services Canada for the Chief Electoral Officer of Canada Ottawa.

  • • FAFIA Feminist Alliance for International Action and NWAC Native Women’s Association of Canada 2015 Murders and Disappearances of Aboriginal Women and Girls: Report to the Human Rights Committee on the Occasion of the Committee's Consideration of the Sixth Periodic Report of Canada http://tbinternet.ohchr.org/Treaties/CCPR/Shared%20Documents/CAN/INT_CCPR_CSS_CAN_20769_E.pdf.

  • • Finlay Hugh 1918 1918 ‘Letter to Sir Evan Nepean Quebec 22nd October 1784’ in Shortt Adam and Doughty Arthur G. (eds) Canadian Archives: Documents Relating to the Constitutional History of Canada: 1759-1791. HDPB Ottawa.

  • • Fischer David Hackett 2008 Champlain’s Dream Simon & Schuster New York.

  • • Foucault Michel 1982 The Archaeology of Knowledge: And the Discourse on Language by Michel Foucault Vintage New York.

  • • Fraser Arvonne S. 1999 ‘Becoming Human: The Origins and Development of Women’s Human Rights’ Human Rights Quarterly XXI(4): 853–90.

  • • Friedman Elizabeth 1995 ‘Women’s Human Rights: The Emergence of a Movement’ in Peters Julie and Wolper Andrea (eds) Women’s Rights Human Rights: International Feminist Perspectives Routledge New York and London 18-35.

  • • Froide Amy M. 2005 Never Married: Singlewomen in Early Modern England Oxford University Press Oxford and New York.

  • • Garner John 1969 The Franchise and Politics in British North America 1755-1867 University of Toronto Press Toronto.

  • • Green Joyce A. (Joyce Audry) 2007 Making Space for Indigenous Feminism Fernwood Publishing Black Point NS.

  • • Greer Allan and Radforth Ian Walter 1992 ‘Introduction’ in Greer and Radforth (eds) Colonial Leviathan: State Formation in Mid-Nineteenth-Century Canada University of Toronto Press Toronto and Buffalo.

  • • Gregory Desmond 1985 The Ungovernable Rock: A History of the Anglo-Corsican Kingdom and Its Role in Britain’s Mediterranean Strategy during the Revolutionary War 1793-1797 Fairleigh Dickinson University Press Rutherford NJ.

  • • Hanley Sarah 1998 ‘The Politics of Identity and Monarchic Governance in France: The Debate over Female Exclusion’ in Smith. Hilda L. (ed) Women Writers and the Early Modern British Political Tradition Cambridge University Press Cambridge and New York 289-304.

  • • Harris Barbara 1990 ‘Women and Politics in Early Tudor England’ The Historical Journal XXXIII(2): 259-281.

  • • Hirst Derek 1975 The Representative of the People?: Voters and Voting in England under the Early Stuarts Cambridge University Press Cambridge and New York.

  • • Hooks Bell 2000 Feminist Theory from Margin to Center 2nd edition Pluto Press London.

  • • Inter-American Commissino on Human Rights 2014 Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women in British Columbia Canada Organisation of American States OEA/Ser.L/V/II.Doc30/14.

  • • Jackson James 2009 The Riot That Never Was: The Military Shooting of Three Montrealers in 1832 and the Official Cover-Up Baraka Books Montreal.

  • • Jennings Cec ‘Winning Back the Vote’ Canada’s History XCV(5).

  • • Keyssar Alexander 2000 The Right to Vote: The Contested History of Democracy in the United States; [with a New Afterword] [Rev ed] Basic Books New York.

  • • Kingdom E. (Elizabeth) 1990 ‘Gendering Rights’ in Arnaud André Jean and Kingdom E. (Elizabeth) (eds) Women’s Rights and the Rights of Man Aberdeen University Press Aberdeen.

  • • King Jason 2007 ‘“Their Colonial Condition”: Connections Between French-Canadians and Irish Catholics in the Nation and the Dublin University Magazine’ Éire-Ireland XLII(1): 108-131.

  • • Klein Kim 1996 ‘A “Petticoat Polity”?: Women Voters in New Brunswick Before Confederation’ Acadiensis XXVI(1): 71-75.

  • • Klinghoffer Judith Apter and Elkis 1992 ‘“The Petticoat Electors”: Women’s Suffrage in New Jersey 1776-1807’ Journal of the Early Republic XII(2): 159-193.

  • • Leacock Eleanor 1980 ‘Montagnais Women and the Jesuit Program for Colonization’ in Etienne Mona and Leacock Eleanor (eds) Women and Colonization: Anthroplogical Perspectives Praeger Publishers New York 25-41.

  • • Leacock Eleanor Burke 1980 ‘Women’s Status in Egalitarian Society’ in Myths of Male Dominance: Collected Papers on Women Cross Culturally Monthly Review Press New York 133-182.

  • • Levine Philippa 2004 ‘Why Gender and Empire?’ in Levine Philippa (ed) Gender and Empire Oxford University Press Oxford and New York.

  • • Lucarelli Sonia and Manners Ian 2006 Values and Principles in European Union Foreign Policy 1st ed Routledge London.

  • • Markoff John 2003 ‘Margins Centers and Democracy: The Paradigmatic History of Women’s Suffrage’ Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society XXIX(1): 85-116.

  • • Martin Archie Chief of the Eastern and Western Metis 2007 ‘The Metis - Who Are We!’ Web page Accessed March 21 http://www.zibiodey.org/CHIEFMARTIN.html.

  • • Martin Ged 1995 Britain and the Origins of Canadian Confederation 1837-67 Macmillan Basingstoke.

  • • Martin Ged and Wilson Britanie 2013 John A Macdonald: Canada’s First Prime Minister Dundurn Group Ltd Toronto.

  • • Mendelson Sara Heller and Crawford Patricia (Patricia M.) 1998 Women in Early Modern England 1550-1720 Clarendon Press Oxford.

  • • Merry Sally Engle 2006 Human Rights and Gender Violence: Translating International Law into Local Justice University of Chicago Press Chicago Ill.

  • • Midgely Clare 2001 ‘British Women Women’s Rights and Empire 1790-1850’ in Grimshaw Patricia and Holmes Katie (eds) Women’s Rights and Human Rights: International Historical Perspectives Palgrave Basingstoke 3-15.

  • • Murray General James 1918 ‘Report on the State of the Government of Quebec in Canada June 5th 1762’ in Shortt Adam and Doughty Arthur G. (eds) Canadian Archives: Documents Relating to the Constitutional History of Canada: 1759-1791. HDPB Ottawa.

  • • Nardo Don 2014 The Split History of the Women’s Suffrage Movement: A Perspectives Flip Book Compass Point Books North Mankato Minn.

  • • Noel Jan 1991 ‘New France: Les Femmes Favorisees’ in Strong-Boag Veronica Jane and Fellman Anita Clair (eds) Rethinking Canada: The Promise of Women’s History 2nd ed Copp Clark Pitman Toronto 23-44.

  • • Palmater Pamela 2015 RCMP Representation of Murdered and Missing Aboriginal Women: Statistics are Skewed Rabble. Ca Blog April 13th 2015 http://rabble.ca/blogs/bloggers/pamela-palmater/2015/04/rcmp-report-on-murdered-and-missing-aboriginal-women-statisti.

  • • Palmater Pamela 20156 ‘Shining a Light on the Dark Places: Addressing Police Racism and Sexualised Violence against Indigenous Women and Girls at the National Inquiry’ CJWL XXVIII(2): 253-284.

  • • Parliamentary Report Lower Canada 1833 ‘Having Reference to The Occurrences Which Took Place in Montreal on the 21st May 1832 and During and After the Representation for the West Ward of the Said City’ CO/45/109 National Archives Kew.

  • • Pauker Magnolia 2015 ‘Suffrage Campaigns and Enfranchisement With Special Reference to Canada: Extended Bibliography’ http://www.academia.edu/30819491/Suffrage_Campaigns_and_Enfranchisement_With_Special_Reference_to_Canada_Extended_Bibliography.

  • • Pearlston Karen 2009 ‘Married Women Bankrupts in the Age of Coverture’ Law XXXIV(2): 265-299.

  • • Pealston Karen 2011 ‘What a Feme Sole Trader Could Not Do: Lord Mansfield on the Limits of a Married Woman’s Commercial Freedom’ in Kippen Kim and Woods Lori (eds) Worth and Repute: Valuing Gender in Late Medieval and Early Modern Europe: Essays in Honour of Barbara Todd Centre for Reformation and Renaissance Studies Toronto 309-336.

  • • Pickering Paul A. 2001 ‘“And Your Petitioners &c”: Chartist Petitioning in Popular Politics 1838-1848’ The English Historical Review CXVI(466): 368-388.

  • • ‘Pitcairn Islands’ 2017 accessed August 23 2017 http://www.government.pn/Pitcairnshistory.php.

  • • Pollard Albert Frederick 1920 The Evolution of Parliament Longmans Green and co. New York.

  • • Power Eileen and Postan M.M. (Michael Moïssey) 1997 Medieval Women Canto ed Cambridge University Press Cambridge.

  • • Prest Wilfrid 1991 ‘Law and Women’s Rights in Early Modern England’ The Seventeenth Century VI: 169-187.

  • • Proctor Candice E. 1990 Women Equality and the French Revolution Greenwood Press New York.

  • Quebec Gazette volumes 69 and 71.

  • • Ratcliffe Donald 2013 ‘The Right to Vote and the Rise of Democracy 1787-1828’ Journal of the Early Republic XXXIII(2): 219-254.

  • • ‘Report of the Inquiry Concerning Canada of the Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women under Article 8 of the Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women’ 2016 CEDAW/ C/ OP.8/CAN/1 para 205.

  • • Scott Joan Wallach 1988 Gender and the Politics of History Columbia University Press New York.

  • • Seuffert Nan 2005 ‘Nation as Partnership: Law “Race” and Gender in Aotearoa New Zealand’s Treaty Settlements’ Law XXXIX(3): 485-526.

  • • Seymour Charles and Frary Donald Paige 1918 How the World Votes: The Story of Democratic Development in Elections Etc C.A. Nichols Co. Springfield.

  • • Sharpe Robert J. and McMahon Patricia I. 2007 The Persons Case: The Origins and Legacy of the Fight for Legal Personhood published for the Osgoode Society for Canadian Legal History by University of Toronto Press Toronto and London.

  • • Shoemaker Robert Brink 1998 Gender in English Society 1650-1850: The Emergence of Separate Spheres? Longman London.

  • • Shortt Adam and Doughty Arthur G. 1918 Canadian Archives: Documents Relating to the Constitutional History of Canada: 1759-1791 HDPB Ottawa.

  • • Stanton Elizabeth Cady 1993 ‘Address Delivered at Seneca Falls and Rochester NY (1870)’ in Moynihan Ruth Barnes Russett Cynthia Eagle and Crumpacker Laurie (eds) Second to None: A Documentary History of American Women University of Nebraska Press Lincoln and London 257-262.

  • • Stopes Charlotte (Carmichael) 1894 British Freewomen Their Historical Privilege: By Charlotte Carmichael Stopes Swan Sonnenschein & Co Paternoster Square London.

  • • Stretton Tim 1998 Women Waging Law in Elizabethan England Cambridge University Press Cambridge.

  • • Strong-Boag Veronica Jane 2002 ‘The Citizen Debate 1885’ in Chunn Dorothy E. Menzies Robert J. and Adamoski Robert L. (eds) Contesting Canadian Citizenship: Historical Readings Broadview Press Peterborough Ont.

  • • Thomas Keith V. 1958 ‘Women and the Civil War Sects’ Past no. 13: 42-62.

  • • Tripp Aili Mari 2006 ‘Challenges in Transnational Mobilisation’ in Ferree Myra Marx and Tripp Aili Mari (eds) Global Feminism: Transnational Women’s Activism Organizing and Human Rights New York University Press New York 296-312.

  • • Turner Edward Raymond 1915 ‘Women’s Suffrage in New Jersey 1790-1807’ Smith College Studies I(4).

  • • Turpel Mary Ellen 1993 ‘Patriarchy and Paternalism: The Legacy of the Canadian State for First Nations Women’ Canadian Journal of Women and Law VI(1): 174-192.

  • • Van Kirk Sylvia 1983 Many Tender Ties: Women in Fur-Trade Society 1670-1870 1st American ed University of Oklahoma Press Norman Okla.

  • • Voyageur Cora Jane 2008 Firekeepers of the Twenty-First Century: First Nations Women Chiefs McGill-Queen’s University Press Montreal and Ithaca.

  • • Wagner Sally Roesch 2001 Sisters in Spirit: The Iroquois Influence on Early American Feminists Native Voices Summertown Tenn.

  • • Wagner Sally Roesch 2004 ‘The Indigenous Roots of United States Feminism’ in Ricciutelli Luciana Miles Angela R. (Angela Rose) and McFadden Margaret (eds) Feminist Politics Activism and Vision: Local and Global Challenges Inanna Publications and Education Toronto.

  • • Williams Robert A. Jr. 1989 ‘Gendered Checks and Balances: Understanding the Legacy of White Patriarchy in an American Indian Cultural Context’ Georgia Law Review XXIV: 1019-1044.

  • • Young Brian J. 1994 The Politics of Codification: The Lower Canadian Civil Code of 1866 McGill-Queen’s University Press [for] the Osgoode Society for Canadian Legal History Montreal.

Search
Journal information
Impact Factor

CiteScore 2018: 0.04

SCImago Journal Rank (SJR) 2018: 0.105
Source Normalized Impact per Paper (SNIP) 2018: 0.03

Metrics
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 490 329 14
PDF Downloads 354 256 6