The ethical problems of death pronouncement and organ donation: A commentary on Peter Singer’s article

Open access

Abstract

The article is a critical commentary on Peter Singer’s thesis that the brain death definition should be replaced by a rule outlining the conditions permitting organ harvesting from patients who are biologically alive but are no longer persons. Largely agreeing with the position, I believe it can be justified not only on the basis of utilitarian arguments, but also those based on Kantian ethics and Christianity. However, due to the lack of reliable methods diagnosing complete and irreversible loss of consciousness, we should refrain from implementing upper brain death into medical practice. Organs also should not be harvested from people in a persistent vegetative state or from anencephalic children, for similar reasons. At the same time, patients who suffered from whole-brain death should not be artificially sustained; in light of current knowledge they can be declared dead and become organ donors.

BRATNY, R. (1978): Radość nagrobków [Tombstone joy]. Warszawa: Iskry.

FIODOROW, N. (2012): Filozofia wspólnego czynu [Philosophy of shared action]. Kęty: Wydawnictwo Marek Derewiecki.

KOŁAKOWSKA, A., PATORA, T. & STELMASIAK, M. (2000): Zabijali pacjentów dla pieniędzy [They killed patients for money], [online] [Retrieved September 2, 2018]. Available at: http://wyborcza.pl/1,76842,2638033.html

LIZZA, J. P. (2018a): Defining death: Beyond biology. In: Diametros, 55, pp. 1–19.

LIZZA, J. P. (2018b): In defense of brain death: Replies to Don Marquis, Michael Nair-Collins, Doyen Nguyen, and Laura Specker Sullivan. In: Diametros, 55, pp. 68–90.

MCMAHAN, J. (1995): The metaphysics of brain death. In: Bioethics, 9(2), pp. 91–126.

MCMAHAN, J. (2006): An alternative to brain death. In: Journal of Law, Medicine, and Ethics, 34(1), pp. 44–48.

NAIR-COLLINS, M. (2018): A biological theory of death: Characterization, justification, and implications. In: Diametros, 55, pp. 27–43.

NGUYEN, D. (2018): A holistic understanding of death: Ontological and medical considerations. In: Diametros, 55, pp. 44–62.

NOWAK, P. G. (2018a): Pobieranie narządów po zatrzymaniu krążenia. O nadrzędności neurologicznego kryterium śmierci nad krążeniowym – kwestie regulacyjne [Donation after circulatory determination of death: About the precedence of neurological criterion of ceath over circulatory criterion – regulatory issues]. In: Analiza i Egzystencja, 42, pp. 35–53.

NOWAK, P. G. (2018b): Pobieranie narządów po zatrzymaniu krążenia. O nadrzędności neurologicznego kryterium śmierci nad krążeniowym – kwestie filozoficzne [Donation after circulatory determination of death: About the precedence of neurological criterion of death over circulatory criterion – philosophical issues]. In: Analiza i Egzystencja, 42, pp. 55–71.

PĘDZIWIATR, K. (2015): Uchodźcy muzułmańscy nad Wisła niemile widziani. [Muslim refugees unwelcome in Poland]. In: Biuletyn migracyjny, 52, p. 2 [online] [Retrieved September 2, 2018]. Available at: www.biuletynmigracyjny.uw.edu.pl

SINGER, P. (2018): The challenge of brain death for the sanctity of life ethic. In: Ethics & Bioethics (in Central Europe), 8(3–4), pp. 153–165.

SULLIVAN, L. S. (2018): What does a definition of death do? In: Diametros, 55, pp. 63–67.

TÜCHLE, H. & BOUMAN, C. A. (1986): Historia Kościoła [History of the Church], vol. 3: 1500–1715. Warszawa: Instytut Wydawniczy Pax.

Ethics & Bioethics

(in Central Europe)

Journal Information

Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 91 91 38
PDF Downloads 77 77 19