Brain death as irreversible loss of a human’s moral status

Open access

Abstract

Singer claims that there are two ways of challenging the fact that brain-dead patients, from whom organs are usually retrieved, are in fact biologically alive. By means of the first, the so called dead donor rule may be abandoned, opening the way to lethal organ donation. In the second, it might be posited that terms such as “life” and “death” do not have any primary biological meaning and are applicable to persons instead of organisms. This second possibility permits one to acknowledge that brain-dead patients are deceased because they are irreversibly unconscious. In the commentary which follows, I will argue that Singer’s second option is preferable since it (a) provides a higher amount of organs available for transplant, and (b) is better suited to the meaning of “death” which occurs in ordinary language. I will also defend such a concept of death against the objections raised by Michael Nair-Collins in the article Can the brain-dead be harmed or wronged? On the moral status of brain death and its implications for organ transplantation.

AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION (2015): Code of medical ethics of the American medical association. Chicago: American Medical Association.

BEAUCHAMP, T. L. & CHILDRESS, J. F. (2001): Principles of Biomedical Ethics. Oxford & New York: Oxford University Press.

BERNAT, J. (2013): Life or death for the dead-donor rule? In: The New England Journal of Medicine, 369(14), pp. 1289–1291.

DAVIES, J. K. (2007): Precedent autonomy, advance directives, and end-of-life care. In: B. Steinbock (ed.): The Oxford handbook of ethics. New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 349–374.

DE TOMASO, M., NAVARRO, J., RICCI, K., LORENZO, M., LANZILLOTTI, C., COLONNA, F., RESTA, M., LANCIONI, G. & LIVREA, P. (2013): Pain in prolonged disorders of consciousness: Laser evoked potentials findings in patients with vegetative and minimally conscious states. In: Brain Injury, 27(7–8), pp. 962–972.

DWORKIN, R. (1994): Life’s dominion: An argument about abortion, euthanasia, and individual freedom. New York: Vintage Books.

FEINBERG, J. (1986): The moral limits of the criminal law, vol. 1: Harm to others. New York: Oxford University Press.

FERNÁNDEZ-ESPEJO, D. & OWEN, A. M. (2013): Detecting awareness after severe brain injury. In: Nature reviews neuroscience, 14, pp. 801–809.

GALEWICZ, W (2013): Status ludzkiego zarodka a etyka badań biomedycznych [The status of the human embryo and the ethics of the biomedical research]. Kraków: Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego.

JAWORSKA, A. & TANNENBAUM, J. (2018): The Grounds of Moral Status. In: E. N. Zalta (ed.): The Stanford encyclopedia of philosophy (Spring 2018 Edition), [online] [Retrieved September 9, 2018]. Available at: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/grounds-moral-status/.

KANT, I. (1991): The metaphysics of morals, transl. Mary Gregor. New York, Port Chester, Melbourne & Sydney: Cambridge University Press.

KORSGAARD, Ch. (1983): Two distinctions in goodness. In: The Philosophical Review, 92(2), pp. 169–195.

LI, D., HAWLEY, Z. & SCHINER, K. (2013): Increasing organ donation via changes in the default choice or allocation rule. In: Journal of Health Economics, 32(6), pp. 1117–1129.

LIZZA, J. P. (2006): Persons, humanity, and the definition of death. Baltimore: The John Hopkins University Press.

MAGNUS, D. C., WILFOND, B. S. & CAPLAN, A. L. (2014): Accepting Brain Death. In: The New England Journal of Medicine, 370(10), pp. 891–894.

MARQUIS, D. (2010): Are DCD donors dead? In: The Hastings Center Report, 40(3), pp. 24–31.

MCMAHAN, J. (2002): The ethics of killing: Problems at the margins of life. Oxford & New York: Oxford University Press.

MILLER, F. & TRUOG, R. (2012): Death, dying, and organ transplantation. Oxford & New York: Oxford University Press.

MONTI, M. M., VANHAUDENHUYSE, A., COLEMAN, M. R., BOLY, M., PICKARD, J. D., TSHIBANDA, L., OWEN, A. M. & LAUREYS, S. (2010): Willful modulation of brain activity in disorders of consciousness. In: New England Journal of Medicine, 362(7), pp. 578–589

NAGEL, T. (1970): Death. In: Noûs, 4(1), pp. 73–80.

NAIR-COLLINS, M. (2017): Can the brain-dead be harmed or wronged?: On the moral status of brain death and its implications for organ transplantation. In: Kennedy Institute of Ethics Journal, 27(4), pp. 525–559.

NAIR-COLLINS, M. (2018): A biological theory of death: Characterization, justification, and implications. In: Diametros, 55, pp. 27–43.

NAIR-COLLINS M., GREEN, S. R. & SUTIN, A. R. (2015): Abandoning the dead donor rule? A national survey of public views on death and organ donation. In: Journal of Medical Ethics, 41(4), pp. 297–302.

NOWAK, P. G. (2016): Umiarkowanie liberalna koncepcja śmierci jako uzasadnienie dla neurologicznych kryteriów śmierci [The moderately liberal concept of death as a basis for neurological criteria of death]. In: Przegląd Filozoficzny – Nowa Seria [Philosophical Review – New Series], 25(2), pp. 200–211.

NOWAK, P. G. (2018a): Pobieranie narządów po zatrzymaniu krążenia. O nadrzędności neurologicznego kryterium śmierci nad krążeniowym – kwestie regulacyjne [Donation after circulatory determination of death: About the precedence of neurological criterion of death over circulatory criterion – regulatory issues]. In: Analiza i egzystencja [Analysis and existence], 42, pp. 35–53.

NOWAK, P. G. (2018b): Pobieranie narządów po zatrzymaniu krążenia. O nadrzędności neurologicznego kryterium śmierci nad krążeniowym – kwestie filozoficzne [Donation after circulatory determination of death: About the precedence of neurological criterion of death over circulatory criterion – philosophical issues]. In: Analiza i Egzystencja [Analysis and existence], 42, pp. 55–71.

OWEN, A. M., COLEMAN, M. R., DAVIS, M. H., BOLY, M., LAUREYS, S. & PICKARD, J. D. (2006): Detecting awareness in the vegetative state. In: Science, 313(5792), p. 1402.

POLISH MEDICAL CODE OF ETHICS [online] [Retrieved August 29, 2018]. Available at: http://www.nil.org.pl/__data/assets/pdf_file/0003/4764/Kodeks-Etyki-Lekarskiej.pdf

POSNER, J. B., SAPER, C. B., SCHIFF, N. D. & PLUM, F. (2007): Plum and Posner’s Diagnosis of Stupor and Coma. Oxford & New York: Oxford University Press.

REGAN, T. (1983/2004): The case for animal rights. Berkeley: University of California Press.

RITHALIA, A., MCDAID, C., SUEKARRAN, S., LINDSEY, M. & SOWDEN, A. (2009): Impact of presumed consent for organ donation on donation rates: a systematic review. In: BMJ, 338, p. a3162.

SHEWMON, A. D. (1998): Chronic “brain death”: Meta-analysis and conceptual consequences. In: Neurology, 51(6), pp. 1538–1545.

SILVER, D. (2003): Lethal injection, autonomy and the proper ends of medicine. In: Bioethics, 17(2), pp. 205–211.

SINGER, P. (1994): Rethinking life and death: The collapse of our traditional ethics. New York: St. Martin’s Press.

SINGER, P. (2018): The challenge of brain death for the sanctity of life ethic. In: Ethics & Bioethics (in Central Europe), 8(3–4), pp. 153–165.

TRUOG, R. (2016): The price of our illusions and myths about the dead donor rule. In: Journal of Medical Ethics, 42(5), pp. 318–319.

VEATCH, R. M. (2003): The dead donor rule: True by definition. In: The American Journal of Bioethics, 3(1), pp. 10–11.

VEATCH, R. M. (2015): Killing by organ procurement: Brain-based death and legal fictions. In: Journal of Medicine and Philosophy, 40(3), pp. 289–311.

VEATCH, R. M. & ROSS, L. F. (2015): Transplantation ethics. Washington, D. C.: Georgetown University Press.

WARREN, A. M. (1973): On the moral and legal status of abortion. In: The Monist, 57(1), pp. 43–61.

WARREN, A. M. (1997): Moral status. In: R. G. Frey & Ch. H. Wellman (eds.): A Companion to applied ethics. Malden, MA: Blackwell, pp. 439–450.

WILKINSON, T. M. (2011): Ethics and the acquisition of organs. Oxford & New York: Oxford University Press.

WILKINSON, T. M. & SAVULESCU, J. (2012): Should we allow organ donation euthanasia? Alternatives for maximizing the number and quality of organs for transplantation. In: Bioethics, 26(1), pp. 32–48.

YU, T., LANG, S., VOGEL, D., MARKL A., MÜLLER, F. & KOTCHOUBEY, B. (2013): Patients with unresponsive wakefulness syndrome respond to the pain cries of other people. In: Neurology, 80(4), pp. 345–352.

ŻURADZKI, T. (2011): Rola świadomości w decyzjach dotyczących zaprzestania podtrzymywania funkcji życiowych [The role of consciousness in the end-of-life decisions]. In: Rocznik kognitywistyczny [Yearbook of cognitive science], 5, pp. 191–198.

Ethics & Bioethics

(in Central Europe)

Journal Information

Metrics

All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 194 194 61
PDF Downloads 193 193 56