Application of Extreme Value Analysis in the Assessment of Budget Variance Risk

Open access


This paper presents the methods for the evaluation of budget variance risk, i.e. the risk of a difference between the budgeted and actual figures. The postulated approach is based on extreme value analysis (EVA), to offer, among other things, the evaluation of maxima distribution parameters for studied phenomena. The proper recognition of these parameters yields potential for calculation of probabilities for budget variance to pass certain levels established as critical. This methodology can be used to evaluate deviation levels by time period, and to compare them against historical data. The main objective of this paper was to examine the utility of the theory of extreme values in the estimation of budget deviation risks. The study presents the results of probabilistic analyses of data obtained from a budgetary cost control unit of a production company located in eastern Poland, for the period of 2011-2012. The developed method of analysis and assessment of budget deviations is in line with the development of concepts and methods of management accounting.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Anthony R. N. 1977 Zero-base budgeting: a useful fraud? Alexandria Va.: s.n. vol. 26 pp. 7-10 ZBB= Zero-Base Budgeting.

  • Anthony R. N. et al. 2014 Management Control Systems: European Edition McGraw-Hill Higher Education.

  • Armstrong M. (ed.) 1993 A Handbook of Management Techniques 3rd edition Kogan Page Business Books London.

  • Atkinson A. et al. 2006 Management Accounting 5th edition Prentice Hall Upper Saddle River New York.

  • Bierman Jr. H. Fouraker L.E. Jaddicke R. K. 1961 A use of probability and statistics in performance evaluation Accounting Review 7 vol. 36.

  • Bragg S. M. 2014 Budgeting. A Comprehensive Guide 3rd edition Centennial Colo.: Accounting Tools=.

  • Cooper D.F. Walker P. Raymond G. Grey S. 2014 Project Risk Management Guidelines: Managing Risk with ISO 31000 and IEC 62198 John Wiley & Sons.

  • Embrechts P. Klüppelberg C. Mikosch T. 1997 Modelling Extremal Events for Insurance and Finance Stochastic Modelling and Applied Probability.

  • Embrechts P. Klüppelberg C. Mikosch T. 2008 Modelling Extremal Events for Insurance and Finance 4th cor. ed. and 8th ed. Springer (Stochastic modelling and probability) Berlin.

  • England K. Hidsal H. Frigessi A. 2004 practical extreme value modelling of hydrological floods and droughts: a case study Extremes vol. 7 issue 1 pp. 5-30.

  • Garrison R.H. Chesley G.R. Carroll R.G. 1990 Managerial Accounting. Concepts for Planning Control Decision-Making 1st Canadian ed. Irwin Homewood IL.

  • Garrison R.H. Noreen E.W. Brewer P. C. 2008 Managerial Accounting 12th. edition McGraw Hill Higher Education.

  • Gumbel E. 1937 La duree extreme de la vie humaine Actualites Scientifique et Industrielle.

  • Gumbel E. 1941 The return period of flood flaws Ann. Math. Statist. 12.

  • Gumbel E. 1944a Floods estimated by probability methods Engrg. News – Records vol. 134.

  • Gumbel E. 1944b On the plotting of flood discharges Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union 25.

  • Gumbel E. 1945 Floods estimated by probability methods Engrg. News-Record 134.

  • Gumbel E. 1949 The statistical forecast of floods Water Resources Board Bulletin no. 15.

  • Gumbel E. 1954 Statistical theory of extreme values and some practical applications National Bureau of Standards Applied Mathematics Series vol. 33.

  • Hansen D. Mowen M. 2005 Cost Management. Accounting and Control South-Western Nashville.

  • Hansen S.C. Otley D.T. Van der Stede W.A. 2003 Practice developments in budgeting: an overview and research perspective Journal of Management Accounting Research 9 vol. 15 pp. 95-116.

  • Horngren Ch.T. Datar Srikant M. Foster G. 2007 Cost Accounting: A Managerial Emphasis 12th edition Prentice Hall Upper Saddle River N.J.

  • ISO/TMB 2009 ISO Guide 73:2009 Risk management – Vocabulary Multiple. Distributed through American National Standards Institute.

  • Jedynak P. 2001 Ubezpieczenia gospodarcze. Wybrane elementy teorii i praktyki Księgarnia Akademicka Kraków.

  • Johnson N. Kotz S. 1970 Distributions in Statistics. Continuous Univariate Distributions Houghton Mifflin Boston.

  • Kes Z. 1999 Kontrola budżetowa kosztów [in:] Budżetowanie kosztów ed. E. Nowak Ośrodek Doradztwa i Doskonalenia Kadr Gdańsk.

  • Kes Z. Kuźmiński Ł. 2011 Application of Run Tests for Control Charts in Budgeting Prace i Materia-ły Wydziału Zarządzania Uniwersytetu Gdańskiego (1/2) pp. 123-136.

  • Kotz S. Nadarajah S. 2005 Extreme Value Distributions Theory and Applications Imperial College Press London.

  • Kunreuther H. Roth R. 1998 Paying the Price Joseph Henry Press Washington.

  • Kuźmiński Ł. 2013 Graniczne dystrybuanty wartości ekstremalnych dla zależnych ciągów zmiennych losowych Ekonometria nr 2(29).

  • Kwang Ch.-W. Slavin A. 1962 The simple mathematics of variance analysis Accounting Review 7 vol. 37.

  • Leadbetter M. Lindgren G. Rootzen H. 1983 Extremes and Related Properties of Random Sequences and Processes Springer-Verlag New York.

  • Łada-Cieślak M. 1999 Definicje pojęć „budżet” i „budżetowanie” Zeszyty Teoretyczne Rady Naukowej SKwP 49 pp. 25-33.

  • Magiera R. 2002 Modele i metody statystyki matematycznej Oficyna Wydawnicza GiS Wrocław.

  • Mallouk B. et al. 2007 Managerial Accounting: Second Canadian Edition second edition Thomsom/ Nelson Toron.

  • Mises von R. 1936 La distribution de la plus grande de n valeures Rev. Math. Union Interbalcanique pp. 141-160.

  • Nordquist J. 1945 Theory of largest value applied to earthquake magnitudes Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union 26.

  • Potter W. 1949 Normalcy tests of precipitation and frequency studies of runoff on small watersheds U. S. Department of Agriculture Technical Bulletin 985.

  • Rantz S. Riggs H. 1949 Magnitude and frequency of floods in the Columbia river basin Water Supply Paper 1080.

  • Rayburn L.G. 1986 Principles of Cost Accounting with Managerial Applications Irwin Homewood.

  • Salman T. 2008 Variance Analysis as a Tool for Management Control Published Case Study University of Ilorin Ilorin.

  • Smith R. 1985 Maximum likelihood estimation in a class of non-regular cases Biometrika 72 pp. 67-90.

  • Thomas M. Reiss R. 2007 Statistical Analysis of Extreme Value with Applications to Insurance Finance Hydrology and Other Fields Birkhauser Berlin.

  • Weber Ch. 1963 The mathematics of variance analysis The Accounting Review.

  • Welsch G.A. Hilton R.W. Gordon P.N. 1988 Budgeting. Profit Planning and Control 5th ed. Prentice-Hall Englewood Cliffs NJ.

  • Yen B. 1988 Stochastic methods and reliability analysis in water resources Advances Water Resour- ces vol. 11.

  • Zannetos Z.S. 1963 On the mathematics of variance analysis The Accounting Review.

Journal information
All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 26 26 7
PDF Downloads 29 29 6