A defence of Fregean propositions

Open access


Stephen Schiffer 2003 presents six arguments against the Fregean model of propositions, according to which propositions are (a) the referents of that-clauses and (b) structured entities made out of concepts. Schiffer advances an alternative view: propositions are unstructured pleonastic entities. My purpose is to argue in favour of the main tenets of the Fregean model by countering each of Schiffer’s arguments and sketching the guidelines for a theory of concepts as basic components of propositions.

Burge, Tyler. 1977. Belief de re. Journal of Philosophy 74: 338–63.

Burge, Tyler. 1979. Frege and the Hierarchy. Synthese 40: 265–81.

Burge, Tyler. 2005. Postscript to ‘Frege and the Hierarchy’. In T. Burge, Truth, Thought, Reason: Essays on Frege. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005: 167–210.

Cozzo, Cesare. 1994. Meaning and Argument. Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell International, 1994.

Davidson, Donald. 1965. Theories of Meaning and Learnable Languages. In Y. Bar-Hillel (ed.), Proceeding’s of the 1964 Congress for Logic, Methodology, and Philosophy of Science. Amsterdam: North-Holland Publishing Company. Repr. in his Inquiries into Truth and Meaning. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1984: 3–15.

Dummett, Michael. 1973. Frege: Philosophy of Language. London: Duckworth, 1973.

Evans, Gareth. 1982. The Varieties of Reference. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1982.

Horwich, Paul. 1998. Meaning. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1998.

Kaplan, David. 1969. Quantifying In. In D. Davidson and J. Hintikka, (eds.), Words and Objections. Dordrecht: Reidel, 1969: 206–42.

Künne, Wolfgang. 1997. First Person Propositions: A Fregean Account. In W. Künne, A. Newen, M. Anduschus (eds.) Direct Reference, Indexicality, and Propositional Attitudes. Stanford: CSLI Publications, 1997: 49–67.

McDowell, John. 1984. De Re Senses. The Philosophical Quarterly 34: 283–94.

Parson, Terence. 1981. Frege’s Hierarchies of Indirect Sense and the Paradox of Analysis. Midwest Studies in Philosophy 6: 37–57.

Patterson, Douglas. 2002. Theories of Truth and Convention T. Philosophers’ Imprint 2: 1–16.

Peacocke, Christopher. 1996. Entitlement, Self-Knowledge and Conceptual Redeployment. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 96: 117–58.

Sainsbury, Mark. 2001. Sense Without Reference. In A. Newen, U. Nortman, R. Stuhlmann-Laeisz (eds.) Building on Frege. Stanford: CSLI Publications, 2001: 211–30.

Schiffer, Stephen. 1992. Belief Ascription. Journal of Philosophy 89: 499–521.

Schiffer, Stephen. 1994. A Paradox of Meaning. Nous 28: 279–324.

Schiffer, Stephen. 2003. The Things We Mean. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 2003.

Zalta, Edward. 1989. Singular Propositions, Abstract Constituents, and Propositional Attitudes. In J. Almog, J. Perry, H. Wettstein (eds.) Themes from Kaplan. Oxford Oxford: University Press, 1989: 455–78.

Zalta, Edward. 1993. Replies to the Critics. Philosophical Studies 69: 231–42.

Zalta, Edward. 2001. Fregean Senses, Modes of Presentations, and Concepts. Philosophical Perspectives 15: 335–59.