On Haslanger’s Meta-Metaphysics: Social Structures and Metaphysical Deflationism

Open access


The metaphysics of gender and race is a growing area of concern in contemporary analytic metaphysics, with many different views about the nature of gender and race being submitted and discussed. But what are these debates about? What questions are these accounts trying to answer? And is there real disagreement between advocates of differ- ent views about race or gender? If so, what are they really disagreeing about? In this paper I want to develop a view about what the debates in the metaphysics of gender and race are about, namely, a version of metaphysical deflationism, according to which these debates are about how we actually use or should use the terms ‘gender’ and ‘race’ (and other related terms), where moral and political considerations play a central role. I will also argue that my version of the view can overcome some recent and powerful objections to metaphysical deflationism of- fered by Elizabeth Barnes (2014, 2017).

Andreasen, R. 2000. Race: biological reality or social construct? Philosophy of Science 67: S653–66.

Ásta K. Sveinsdóttir. 2011. The metaphysics of sex and gender. In Feminist Metaphysics: Explorations in the Ontology of Sex, Gender and the Self, ed. by C. Witt. Springer, 47–65.

Barnes, E. 2014. Going beyond the fundamental: feminism in contemporary metaphysics. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 104(3): 335–51.

Barnes, E. 2017. Realism and social Structure. Philosophical Studies 174(10): 2417–33. DOI: 10.1007/s11098-016-0743-y

Bettcher, T. 2013. Trans women and the meaning of ‘woman’. In Philosophy of Sex: Contemporary Readings, Sixth Edition, ed. by A. Soble, N. Power and R. Halwani. Rowan and Littlefield, 233–50.

Boghossian, P. 2006. Fear of Knowledge: Against Relativism and Constructivism, Oxford University Press.

Chalmers, D. 2011. Verbal disputes. Philosophical Review 120(4): 515–66.

Díaz-León, E. 2012. Social kinds, conceptual analysis, and the operative concept: a reply to Haslanger. Humana.Mente—Journal of Philosophical Studies 22: 57–74.

Díaz-León, E. 2015. In defence of historical constructivism about races. Ergo 2(21): 247–62.

Díaz-León, E. 2016. Woman as a politically significant term: a solution to the puzzle. Hypatia 31(2): 245–58.

Díaz-León, E. (ms.) Substantive metaphysical debates about gender and race: verbal disputes and metaphysical deflationism. Glasgow, J. 2009. A Theory of Race. Routledge.

Haslanger, S. 2000. Gender and race: (what) are they? (What) do we want them to be? Nous 34(1): 31–55.

Haslanger, S. 2005. What are we talking about? The semantics and politics of social kinds. Hypatia 20(4): 10–26.

Haslanger, S. 2006. What good are our intuitions? Philosophical analysis and social kinds. Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society, Sup. Vol. 80(1): 89–118.

Haslanger, S. 2016. What is a (social) structural explanation? Philosophical Studies 173: 113–30.

Jeffers, C. 2013. The cultural theory of race: yet another look at Du Bois’s ‘The Conservation of Races’. Ethics 123(3): 403–26.

Jenkins, K. 2016. Amelioration and inclusion: gender identity and the concept of Woman. Ethics 126(2): 394–421.

Ludwig, D. 2015. Against the new metaphysics of race. Philosophy of Science 82(2): 244–65.

Mallon, R. 2006. Race: normative, not metaphysical or semantic. Ethics 116(3): 525–51.

Mikkola, M. 2011. Ontological commitments, sex and gender. In Feminist Metaphysics: Explorations in the Ontology of Sex, Gender and the Self, ed. by C. Witt. Springer, 67–83.

Mikkola, M. 2016. Feminist metaphysics and philosophical methodology. Philosophy Compass 11(11): 661–70.

Plunkett, D. 2015. Which concepts should we use? Metalinguistic negotiations and the methodology of philosophy. Inquiry 58(7–8): 828–74.

Putnam, H. 1981. Reason, Truth and History, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Schaffer, J. 2009. On what grounds what. In Metametaphysics: New Essays on the Foundations of Ontology, ed. by D. Chalmers, D. Manley and R. Wasserman. Oxford University Press, 347–83.

Saul, J. 2012. Politically significant terms and philosophy of language: methodological issues. In Out from the Shadows: Analytical Feminist Contributions to Traditional Philosophy, ed. by S. Crasnow and A. Superson. Oxford University Press, 195–216.

Sider, T. 2017. Substantivity in feminist metaphysics. Philosophical Studies 174(10): 2467–78. DOI:10.1007/s11098-016-0739-7.

Spencer, Q. 2014. A radical solution to the race problem. Philosophy of Science 81(5): 1025–38.

Thomasson, A. 2007. Ordinary Objects. Oxford University Press.

Thomasson, A. 2008. Existence questions. Philosophical Studies 141(1): 63–78. Thomasson, A. 2015. Ontology Made Easy. Oxford University Press.

Thomasson, A. 2017. Metaphysical disputes and metalinguistic negotiation. Analytic Philosophy 58(1): 1–28.

Witt, C. 2011. The Metaphysics of Gender. Oxford University Press.