Assessing Selection Parameters for Improving Yield in Organically Grown Onion

Open access


An increasing interest in organically grown vegetables has led to an increasing demand to select cultivars meeting the requirements of the production system. This two-year field study was undertaken to assess the effects of organic and conventional nutrient regimes on onion (Allium cepa L.) yield and several yield contributing characters, as well as to identify the traits that could be important when selecting genotypes attended for different production systems. The trial involved five commercially grown onion cultivars and four nutrient regimes: bacterial fertilizer, fully decomposed farmyard manure, without fertilization (organic) and NPK fertilization (conventional). Onion yield, bulb weight, number of bulbs plot−1, number of days from sowing to emergence, vegetation period, plant height, neck diameter, neck length, bulb diameter, bulb height and bulb index have been analyzed. Significant differences concerning all analyzed traits have been found among the cultivars, treatments and years, with significant corresponding interactions. The obtained results imply the specific adaptation to the particular treatments and weather conditions and therefore the possibility to select onion cultivars performing well in organic environments. Path coefficient analysis revealed positive direct effects of bulb weight and number of bulbs plot−1 on yield, as well as negative direct effects of plant height and number of days from sowing to emergence; therefore, those traits should be considered when selecting genotypes attended for different production systems. Other traits affected yield indirectly, mostly positively via bulb weight.

BLOEM, E., HANEKLAUS, S., SCHNUG, E.: Influence of nitrogen and sulfur fertilization on the alliin content of onions and garlic. J. Plant Nutr., 27:1827-1839, 2004.

BRDAR-JOKANOVIĆ, M., UGRINOVIĆ, M., CVIKIĆ, D., PAVLOVIĆ, N., ZDRAVKOVIĆ, J., ADŽIĆ, S., ZDRAVKOVIĆ, M.: Onion yield and yield contributing characters as affected by organic fertilizers. Field Veg. Crop Res., 48(2)341-346, 2011.

Degawione, A., Alamerew, S., Tabor, G.: Genetic variability and association of bulb yield and related traits in shallot (Allium cepa var. aggregatum Don.). International Journal of Agricultural Research, 6:1-20, 2011.

Edwards, A.L.: Multiple regression and analysis of variance and covariance. Freeman, W.H. Comp, San Francisco, USA, pp.31-38, 1979.

FAROOQ, M., SHAH, A.H., MALIK, A.A., ALI, N., KHAN, U., MAJID, A., AHMAD, H.: Nutrient management for improving onion productivity. American-Eurasian J. Agric. & Environ. Sci., 15(2)220-225, 2015.

DŽIGURSKI, D., NIKOLIĆ, LJ., LJEVNAIĆ-MAŠIĆ, B.: Weed flora in organic onion production – Allium cepa L. (Alliaceae Borkhausen 1797, Amaryllidales). Journal on Processing and Energy in Agriculture, 17(3)130-133, 2013.

FALLER, A.L.K. AND FIALHO, E.: The antioxidant capacity and polyphenol content of organic and conventional retail vegetables after domestic cooking. Food Res. Int., 42:210-215, 2009.

GRIFFITHS, G., TRUEMAN, L., CROWTHER, T., THOMAS, B., SMITH, B.: Onions - A global benefit to health. Phytother. Res., 16:603-615, 2002.

GUO, T., ZHANG, J., CHRISTIE, P., LI, X.: Influence of nitrogen and sulfur fertilizers and inoculation with arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi on yield and pungency of spring onion. J. Plant Nutr., 29:1767-1778, 2006.

HERENCIA, J.F., GARCÍA-GALAVÍS, P.A., DORADO, J.A.R., MAQUEDA, C.: Comparison of nutritional quality of the crops grown in an organic and conventional fertilized soil. Sci. Hort., 129:882-888, 2011.

ISLAM, M.K., ALAM, M.F., ISLAM, A.K.M.R.: Growth and yield response of onion (Allium cepa L.) genotypes to different levels of fertilizers. Bangl. J. Bot., 36:33-38, 2007.

KANE, C.D., JASONI, R.L., PEFFLEY, E.P., THOMPSON, L.D., GREEN, C.J., PARE, P., TISSUE, D.: Nutrient solution and solution pH influences on onion growth and mineral content. J. Plant Nutr., 29:375-390, 2006.

KIMANI, P.M., KARIUKI, J.W., PETERS, R., RABINOWITCH, H.D.: Influence of the environment on the performance of some onion cultivars in Kenya. Afr. Crop Sci. J., 1:15-23, 1993.

KRISTENSEN, K. AND ERICSON, L.: Importance of growth characteristics for yield of barley in different growing systems: will growth characteristics describe yield differently in different growing systems? Euphytica, 163:367-380, 2008.

KUMAR, S., IMTIYAZ, M., KUMAR, A.: Effect of differential soil moisture and nutrient regimes on postharvest attributes of onion (Allium cepa L.). Sci. Hortic., 112:121-129, 2007.

LAMMERTS VAN BUEREN, E.T., OSMAN, A:M., TIEMENS-HULSCHER, M., STRUIK, P.C., BURGERS, S.L.G.E., VAN DEN BROEK, R.C.F.M.: Are specific testing protocols required for organic onion varieties? Analysis of onion variety testing under conventional and organic growing conditions. Euphytica, 184:181-193, 2012.

LEE, J., HWANG, S., LEE, S., HA, I., HWANG, H., LEE, S., KIM, J.: Comparison study on soil physical and chemical properties, plant growth, yield, and nutrient uptakes in bulb onion from organic and conventional systems. HortScience, 49(12)1563-1567, 2014.

MAGGIO, A., DE PASCALE, S., PARADISO, R., BARBIERI, G.: Quality and nutritional value of vegetables from organic and conventional farming. Sci. Hortic., 164:532–539, 2013.

MALLOR, C., BALCELLS, M., MALLOR, F., SALES, E.: Genetic variation for bulb size, soluble solids content and pungency in the Spanish sweet onion variety Fuentes de Ebro. Response to selection for low pungency. Plant Breeding, 130:55-59, 2011.

MIRZAEI, R., LIAGHATI, H., MAHDAVI DAMGHANI, A.: Evaluating yield quality and quantity of garlic as affected by different farming systems and garlic clones. Pak. J. Biol. Sci., 10:2219-2224, 2007.

QASEM, J.R.: Response of onion (Allium cepa L.) plants to fertilizers, weed competition duration, and planting times in the central Jordan Valley. Weed Biol. Manag., 6:212-220, 2006.

REID, T.A., YANG, R.-C., SALMON, D.F., SPANER, D.: Should spring wheat breeding for organically managed systems be conducted on organically managed land? Euphytica, 169:239-252, 2009.

REID, T.A., YANG, R.-C., SALMON, D.F., NAVABI, A., SPANER, D.: Realized gains from selection for spring wheat grain yield are different in conventional and organically managed systems. Euphytica, 177:253-266, 2011.

SHARANGI, A.B., SAHU, P.K.: Effect of placement and dose of phosphatic fertilizers on onion. J. Plant Nutr., 32:1901-1913, 2009.

ÜNLÜ, H., ÖZDAMAR ÜNLÜ, H., KARAKURT, Y., PADEM, H.: Influence of organic and conventional production systems on the quality of tomatoes during storage. Afr. J. Agr. Res., 6:538-544, 2011.

VLACHOSTERGIOS, D.N. AND ROUPAKIAS, D.G.: Response to conventional and organic environment of thirty-six lentil (Lens culinaris Medik.) varieties. Euphytica, 163:449-457, 2008.

VLAJIĆ, S., GVOZDANOVIĆ-VARGA, J., STOJANOVIĆ, A., MAŠIREVIĆ, S., MEDIĆ PAP, S., TAKAČ, A.: Winter garlic rust (Puccinia spp.) rate under organic and conventional production conditions. Ratar.Povrt., 52(1)39-43, 2015.

WOLFE, M.S., BARESEL, J.P., DESCLAUX, D., GOLDRINGER, I., HOAD, S., KOVACS, G., LÖSCHENBERGER, F., MIEDANER, T., ØSTERGÅRD, H., LAMMERTS VAN BUEREN, E.T.: Developments in breeding cereals for organic agriculture. Euphytica, 163:323-346, 2008.

YASSEN, A.A. AND KHALID, KH.A.: Influence of organic fertilizers on the yield, essential oil and mineral content of onion. Int. Agrophys., 23:183-188, 2009.

Contemporary Agriculture

The Serbian Journal of Agricultural Sciences

Journal Information


All Time Past Year Past 30 Days
Abstract Views 0 0 0
Full Text Views 229 151 10
PDF Downloads 134 104 13