Bodily Violence and Resistance in Wojtek Smarzowski’s Rose (Róża, 2011)

Elżbieta Ostrowska 1
  • 1 University of Alberta, , Canada


The article argues that Wojtek Smarzowski’s film Rose (Róża, Poland, 2011) undermines the dominant bigendered logic of screen death and suffering in the Polish films depicting the experience of World War II. In these films, there is a significant absence of images of female suffering and death, which is striking when compared to the abundant images of wounded and dying male bodies, usually represented as a lavish visual spectacle. This unrepresented female death serves as a ‘structuring absence’ that governs the systematic signifying practices of Polish cinema. Most importantly, it expels the female experience of World War II from the realm of history to the realm of the mythical. This representational regime has been established in the Polish national cinema during the 1950s, especially in Andrzej Wajda’s films, and is still proving its longevity. As the author argues, Smarzowski’s Rose is perhaps the most significant attempt to undermine this gendered cinematic discourse.

Specifically, the essay explores the ways in which Smarzowski’s Rose departs from previous dominant modes of representation of the World War II experience in Polish cinema, especially its gendered aspect. Firstly, it examines how Rose abandons the generic conventions of both war film and historical drama and instead, utilises selected conventions of melodrama to open up the textual space in which to represent the female experience of historical events. Then the author looks more closely at this experience and discusses the film’s representation of the suffering female body to argue that it subverts the national narrative of the war experience that privileges male suffering. A close analysis of the relationship between sound and image in the scenes of bodily violence reveals how the film reclaims the female body from the abstract domain of national allegory and returns it to the realm of individual embodied experience. The article concludes that Rose presents the female body as resisting the singular ideological inscription, and instead, portrays it as simultaneously submitting to and resisting the gendered violence of war.

If the inline PDF is not rendering correctly, you can download the PDF file here.

  • Ahmed, Sara 2004. The Cultural Politics of Emotion. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

  • Ahmed, Sara; Stacey, Jackie 2001. Thinking Through the Skin. London, New York: Routledge.

  • Blanford, Steven et al. 2001. The Film Studies Dictionary. London, New York: Arnold.

  • Branche, Raphaëlle; Delpla, Isabelle; Horne, John; Lagrou, Pieter; Palmieri, Daniel; Virgili, Fabrice 2012. ‘Writing the History of Rape in Wartime’. – Raphaëlle Branche, Fabrice Virgili (eds.), Rape in Wartime. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 1–16.

  • Brooks, Peter 1976. The Melodramatic Imagination: Balzac, Henry James, Melodrama and the Mode of Excess. New Haven, London: Yale University Press.

  • Brown, William 2013. ‘Violence in Extreme Cinema and the Ethics of Spectatorship’. – Projections 7, 1, 25–42.

  • Caes, Christopher 2003. ‘Catastrophic Spectacles: Historical Trauma and the Masculine Subject in Lotna’. – John Orr, Elżbieta Ostrowska (eds.), The Cinema of Andrzej Wajda: The Art of Irony and Defiance. London, New York: Wallflower Press, 116–131.

  • Cembrzyńska, Patrycja 2014. ‘Wojenne spektakle gwałtu’. – DYSKURS: Pismo Naukowo-Artystyczne ASP we Wrocławiu 17, 126–142. (9 July 2018).

  • De Pascalis, Ilaria A. 2016. ‘The (In)Visibility of Violence: Jasmila Žbanić’s Post-War Cinema’. – European Journal of Women’s Studies 23, 4, 365–380.

  • Dunin, Kinga; Szczawińska, Weronika; Wiśniewska, Agnieszka 2015. ‘Dunin, Szczawińska, Wiśniewska: Pan Tadeusz na Mazurach. Discussion’. – Krytyka Polityczna, 6 March. (29 May 2018).

  • Dzida-Hamela, Katarzyna 2015. ‘Autoreferat. Dokumentacja habilitacyjna’. (9 July 2018).

  • Evangelista, Matthew 2011. Gender, Nationalism, and War: Conflict on the Movie Screen. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

  • Froula, Anna 2014. ‘Preface’. – Karen A. Ritzenhof, Jakub Kazecki (eds.), Heroism and Gender in War Films. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, xi–xv.

  • Gusain, Renuka 2008. ‘The War Body as Screen of Terror’. – Karen Randell, Sean Redmond (eds.), The War Body on Screen. London: Bloomsbury Academic, 36–49.

  • Hagelin, Sarah 2013. Reel Vulnerability: Power, Pain, and Gender in Contemporary American Film and Television. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.

  • Hayward, Susan 2004. Cinema Studies: The Key Concepts. London, New York: Routledge.

  • Jaworska, Justyna 2012. ‘Róża i krew’. – Dialog 7–8, 64–70.

  • Jelača, Dijana 2016. Dislocated Screen Memory: Narrating Trauma in Post-Yugoslav Cinema. Basingstoke, Hampshire: Palgrave Macmillan.

  • Kalinowska, Izabela 2016. ‘From Political Engagement to Politics of Abjection in Polish Auteur Cinema: The Case of Wojtek Smarzowski’. – Seung-hoon Jeong, Jeremi Szaniawski (eds.), The Global Auteur: The Politics of Authorship in 21st Century Cinema. London: Bloomsbury Academic, 115–132.

  • Mackenzie, Scott 2010. ‘On Watching and Turning Away: Ono’s Rape, Cinéma Direct, Aesthetics, and the Genealogy of Cinéma Brut’. – Dominique Russell (ed.), Rape in Art Cinema. New York: Continuum, 159–170.

  • Morstin, Agnieszka 2012. ‘Mocne filmy i głębokie kompleksy. Róża Wojtka Smarzowskiego wobec Jak być kochaną Wojciecha J. Hasa’. – Kwartalnik Filmowy 77–78, 201–210.

  • Mroz, Matilda 2016. ‘Displacement, Suffering and Mourning Post-War Landscapes in Contemporary Polish Cinema’. – Sander Brouwer (ed.), Contested Interpretations of the Past in Polish, Russian, and Ukrainian Film: Screen as Battlefield. Laiden, Boston: Brill, Rodopi, 59–76.

  • Ostrowska, Elżbieta 2012. ‘Invisible Deaths: Polish Cinema’s Representation of Women in World War II’. – Helena Goscilo, Yana Hashamova (eds.), Embracing Arms: Cultural Representation of Slavic and Balkan Women in War. Budapest, New York: Central University Press, 29–58.

  • Ostrowska, Elżbieta 2016. ‘“What Does Poland Want from Me?”: Male Hysteria in Andrzej Wajda’s War Trilogy’. – Ewa Mazierska, Matilda Mroz, Elżbieta Ostrowska (eds.), The Cinematic Bodies of Eastern Europe and Russia: Between Pain and Pleasure. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 31–52.

  • Penn, Robert 2010. It’s All about the Bike: The Pursuit of Happiness on Two Wheels. New York: Bloomsbury.

  • Randell, Karen; Redmond, Sean 2008. ‘Introduction: Setting the Screen’. – Karen Randell, Sean Redmond (eds.), The War Body on Screen. London: Bloomsbury Academic, 1–14.

  • Richardson, Michael 2016. Gestures of Testimony: Torture, Trauma, and Affect in Literature. New York: Bloomsbury Academic.

  • Scarry, Elaine 1985. The Body in Pain: The Making and Unmaking of the World. New York, Oxford: Oxford University Press.

  • Szpulak, Andrzej 2016. Róża. Poznań: Wydawnictwo Naukowe UAM.

  • Williams, Linda 1998. ‘Melodrama Revised’. – Nick Browne (ed.), Refiguring American Film Genres: Theory and History. Berkeley, Los Angeles, London: University of California Press, 42–88.

  • Wosk, Julie 2001. Women and the Machine: Representations from the Spinning Wheel to the Electronic Age. Baltimore, London: The John Hopkins University Press.

  • Zarzosa, Augustín 2013. Refiguring Melodrama in Film and Television: Captive Affects, Elastic Sufferings, Vicarious Objects. Lanham, Boulder, New York: Lexington Books.


Journal + Issues